Category: African Witch Hunts

This category includes all our episodes about contemporary witch-hunting in Africa.

  • Ghana’s Outcast Camps: A Conversation with the Coalition Against Witchcraft Accusations

    Join hosts Sarah Jack and Josh Hutchinson for this special episode recorded live on August 10th for World Day Against Witch Hunts 2025. This expert panel discussion explores the ongoing crisis of witchcraft accusations in Ghana, where men, women and children are violently expelled from their communities and forced to live in outcast camps.

    Featured experts include a representative from Amnesty International Ghana discussing their groundbreaking “Branded for Life” research and report, alongside other advocates also from the Coalition Against Witchcraft Accusations (CAWA), The Sanneh Institute, ActionAid Ghana, Songtaba, and TOLEC Ghana. These frontline organizations share stories of survivors, reveal the devastating impact of modern witch hunts, and highlight the incredible resilience of women rebuilding their lives in these camps. 

    Learn first hand about the accusations that can stem from something as simple as a dream or refusing a marriage proposal, discover how survivors are creating communities of hope despite losing everything, and understand what these brave women need most to restore their dignity and safety. Ghana’s Parliament passed a Bill to protect citizens from witchcraft accusations in July 2023, but it was never signed into law by the former president; the bill has been reintroduced in 2025.

    This powerful World Day Against Witch Hunts program reveals a human rights crisis affecting vulnerable people right now and showcases the dedicated experts working to create lasting change for survivors who desperately need our support.

    Hosted by End Witch Hunts nonprofit – working to restore dignity and create safe futures for survivors worldwide.


    โ 

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Links

    Find links to all these organizations at End Witch Hunts website

    About Spiritual and Ritual Abuse

    Hear the stories of Spiritual and Ritual Abuse in the United States

    Ghana: Branded for Life Report

    Global Review: Addressing Harmful Practices Related to Witchcraft Accusations


    Transcript

  • World Day Against Witch Hunts 2025 with Mary Bingham: Ancient Fears, Modern Victims

    The Thing About Witch Hunts: World Day Against Witch Hunts 2025

    Episode Description

    Join hosts Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack as they sit down with fellow End Witch Hunts nonprofit board member Mary Bingham for a powerful discussion about modern-day witch hunts and spiritual ritual abuse in the United States. In this special episode commemorating World Day Against Witch Hunts (August 10th), we explore the devastating reality of supernatural fears that continue to harm vulnerable people in over 60 countries worldwide.

    What You’ll Learn

    • The connection between historical witch trials and contemporary spiritual abuse cases
    • How modern witch hunts manifest in the United States and globally
    • The devastating impact on society’s most vulnerable members
    • Personal insights from descendants of Salem witch trial victims
    • Actionable ways to combat these harmful practices through education and awareness

    Featured Guest

    Mary Bingham – End Witch Hunts nonprofit board member and advocate. Mary’s compelling research draws crucial connections between historical persecution and contemporary cases of harm inflicted on those believed to be spiritually or diabolically possessed.

    Key Topics Discussed

    • Spiritual and Ritual Abuse: Understanding how supernatural fears manifest in harmful practices today
    • Global Crisis: The scope of witch hunt-related violence across 60+ countries
    • Historical Connections: How past and present persecution share common roots
    • Personal Impact: Why this work holds deep meaning for Salem descendants
    • Path Forward: Education and awareness as tools for change

    Important Dates

    World Day Against Witch Hunts: Sunday, August 10th

    About The Thing About Witch Hunts

    Hosted by Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack, this podcast examines the historical and contemporary reality of witch hunts, exploring their impact on vulnerable communities worldwide and advocating for education and awareness to end these harmful practices.

    About End Witch Hunts

    End Witch Hunts is a nonprofit organization dedicated to raising awareness about modern-day witch hunts and working to raise awareness about supernatural-based persecution and violence.

    Resources

    About World Day Against Witch Hunts

    About Spiritual and Ritual Abuse

    Attend the Online Expert Panel Event August 10th

    SarahWildes1692 on Youtube

    Read Article: Salem to San Jose by Mary Bingham

    Read Blog Post: Understanding Ritualistic Crime

    Ghana: Branded for Life Report

    Global Review: Addressing Harmful Practices Related to Witchcraft Accusations

    Content Warning

    This episode discusses violence and harm against vulnerable individuals, including cases of spiritual and ritual abuse that may be disturbing to some listeners.


    If you found this episode meaningful, please share it to help raise awareness about World Day Against Witch Hunts and the ongoing work to end these harmful practices.

    โ 

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    About World Day Against Witch Hunts

    About Spiritual and Ritual Abuse

    Attend the Online Expert Panel Event August 10th

    SarahWildes1692 on Youtube

    Read Article: Salem to San Jose by Mary Bingham

    Read Blog Post: Understanding Ritualistic Crime

    Ghana: Branded for Life Report

    Global Review: Addressing Harmful Practices Related to Witchcraft Accusations


    Transcript

  • Forensics, Witchcraft Accusations, and Ritual Murders with Dr. Keith Silika

    In this gripping episode, we sit down with Dr. Keith Silika, a Zimbabwean-born criminal investigator whose extraordinary journey has positioned him at the crossroads of two worlds most of us never see intersect.

    Raised between his father’s traditional healing practice and devout Catholic faith, Dr. Silika brings an unprecedented perspective to one of today’s most misunderstood and dangerous phenomena, ritual attacks. From his early days in Zimbabwe’s police force to his current work in England’s law enforcement and academic circles, he’s witnessed firsthand how supernatural beliefs continue to cause  modern-day violence and persecution.

    This isn’t your typical true crime discussion. It’s a deep dive into the complex intersection of culture, belief, justice, and human rights that will  inspire you to explore this critical issue further and engage in important conversations about protecting vulnerable communities worldwide.

    Warning: This episode contains discussions of violence and harm that some listeners may find disturbing.

    Friendship Bench Website

    Dr. Silika’s Report: Forensic Investigation and Prevention of Witchcraft-Related Harmful Practices: A Study of Law Enforcement and Human Rights Perspectives in Southern Africa 

    Dr. Silika’s Article: Running for Community Healing: Why I Ran the Manchester 10K for the Friendship Bench

    The International Network Against Witchcraft Attacks and Ritual Abuse

    โ The Thing About Witch Hunts YouTubeโ 

    Support Us! Buy a book from our independent book shop

    โ 

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    โ โ Friendship Bench Website

    Dr. Silika’s Report: Forensic Investigation and Prevention of Witchcraft-Related Harmful Practices: A Study of Law Enforcement and Human Rights Perspectives in Southern Africa 

    Dr. Silika’s Article: Running for Community Healing: Why I Ran the Manchester 10K for the Friendship Bench

    The International Network Against Witchcraft Attacks and Ritual Abuse

    โ The Thing About Witch Hunts YouTubeโ 

    Support Us! Buy a book from our independent book shop


    Transcript

  • Remembering Alice Young with Author Beth Caruso

    Hosts Josh and Sarah welcome back author Beth Caruso to discuss Alice Young, New England’s first documented witch trial victim, executed in Windsor, Connecticut in 1647. Beth shares her groundbreaking research that led to Alice’s official exoneration by the Connecticut legislature in May 2023, after centuries of her story being nearly lost to history. The conversation explores how Beth pieced together Alice’s life through limited historical records, neighborhood land documents, and epidemiological patterns from a 1647 flu outbreak that may have contributed to the accusations against her. They discuss Alice’s lasting legacy through her descendants, connections to broader New England witch trial history, and what still needs to be done to honor her memory through exhibits and memorials.

    Episode Highlights:

    โ€ข Alice Young’s Story – New England’s first documented alleged witch hanging, executed in Connecticut in 1647 (June 5th by modern calendar)

    โ€ข Historic Exoneration – Connecticut’s bipartisan legislative vote in May 2023 officially cleared Alice Young’s name after centuries

    โ€ข Research Challenges – How limited historical records have been  pieced together to share Alice’s life 

    โ€ข The 1647 Flu Epidemic – How neighborhood deaths and epidemiological patterns may have led to Alice’s accusation

    โ€ข Historical Connections – Links between Alice Young’s case and broader New England witch trial history, including connections to the Mather family

    โ€ข Governor Winthrop Jr.’s Role – His alchemical views and connections to people in Alice Young’s life

    โ€ข Alice’s Legacy – Her descendants and lasting impact on Connecticut heritage and colonial history

    โ€ข Ongoing Memorial Efforts – What still needs to be done through exhibits, memorials, and continued awareness

    โ€ข Beth’s Work – Her Connecticut Witch Trial Exoneration Project, CT Witch Memorial Facebook page, and Connecticut Witch Trials Trilogy

    โ€ข Podcast Promotion – Launch announcement for The Thing About Salem podcast and its first episode about Tituba

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    โ โ Buy the book One of Windsor by Beth Caruso

    Author Beth Caruso’s Website 

    Article: Between God and Satan  by Katherine A. Hermes; Beth M. Caruso

    Buy the book: Prospero’s America: John Winthrop, Jr., Alchemy, and the Creation of New England Culture, 1606-1676  by Walter W. Woodward

    ConnecticutWitchTrials.org

    CT W.I.T.C.H. Memorial

    Help Us Build Our New Patreon Community for The Thing About Salem Podcast

    Check out our new podcast, The Thing About Salem, on YouTube!

    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund

    Support Us! Buy Book Titles Mentioned in this Episode from our Book Shop


    Transcript

  • The Evolution of Diabolical Witchcraft Belief, Part 4: Dissecting the Malleus Maleficarum

    Welcome back to the Witch Hunt Podcast. This is the final episode in the four part series:The Evolution of Diabolical Witchcraft Belief.  If you’re just joining us, we recommend checking out the previous series episodes first, though this episode can certainly stand on its own.

    This completes our Evolution of Diabolical Witchcraft conversation with Professor Richard Raiswell of the University of Prince Edward Island, expert on Devil lore. 

    In Part 1 we began examining the critical relationship that developed between demons and witchcraft specifically in the 15th century. In Part 2, we delved deeper into how this connection became the driving force behind the witch hunts that devastated communities across Europe. In parts 3 and 4 we reveal shocking and informing details on the Malleus Maleficarum and its authors Heinrich Kramer, aka Institoris, and Jacob Sprenger. Thank you for joining us as we conclude this chilling and fascinating exploration of how demonology fueled witch persecution.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    โ โ NEW PODCAST: The Thing About Salemโ 

    โ โ โ Check out our new podcast, The Thing About Salem, on YouTube!โ โ โ 

    โ โ Help Us Build Our New Patreon Community for The Thing About Salem Podcastโ โ 

    โ Richard Raiswellโ 

    โ Shop our Nonprofit Bookshop for: The Routledge History of the Devil in the Western Traditionโ 

    โ Purchase the Malleus Maleficarum: The Hammer of Witches, translated by Christopher S. MacKay โ 

    โ Build Your Witch Trial History Library with a Purchase from our Bookshop!โ 

    โ End Witch Hunts U. S. Nonprofit Organizationโ 

    โ Sign up for our Newsletterโ 

    โ Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund


    Transcript

  • The Evolution of Diabolical Witchcraft Belief, Part 3: The Authors of the Malleus Maleficarum

    Today we conclude our series: The Evolution of Diabolical Witchcraft Belief with Professor Raiswell of the University of Prince Edward Island, an expert in medieval devil lore, with another double episode release. If you’re just joining us, we recommend checking out the previous series episodes first, though this episode can certainly stand on its own.

    In this episode, part 3 of the series, Dr. Raiswell takes us into the minds and lives of Heinrich Kramer, aka Institoris, and Jacob Sprenger, the authors of the 15th century witch-hunting book, the Hammer of Witches, formally known as the Malleus Maleficarum.

    This Dr. Raiswell series is essential for understanding how theological concepts about Satan evolved into specific witchcraft accusations and largely gendered persecution mechanisms that still influence witch hunting today.

    The full series, in four parts, is available now wherever you get your podcasts.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    โ โ NEW PODCAST: The Thing About Salemโ 

    โ โ โ Check out our new podcast, The Thing About Salem, on YouTube!โ โ โ 

    โ โ Help Us Build Our New Patreon Community for The Thing About Salem Podcastโ โ 

    โ Richard Raiswellโ 

    โ Shop our Nonprofit Bookshop for: The Routledge History of the Devil in the Western Traditionโ 

    โ Purchase the Malleus Maleficarum: The Hammer of Witches, translated by Christopher S. MacKay โ 

    โ Build Your Witch Trial History Library with a Purchase from our Bookshop!โ 

    โ End Witch Hunts U. S. Nonprofit Organizationโ 

    โ Sign up for our Newsletterโ 

    โ Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund


    Transcript

  • The Evolution of Diabolical Witchcraft Belief, Part 2

    Welcome back to the Witch Hunt Podcast. This is episode 2 in the The Evolution of Diabolical Witchcraft Belief.  If you’re just joining us, we recommend checking out Part 1 first, though this episode can certainly stand on its own.

    This marks the continuation of our conversation with Professor Richard Raiswell of the University of Prince Edward Island, who previously joined us for our fascinating “Speak of the Devil” episode where we explored Satan as one of history’s most enduring and complex figures.

    In Part 1 of we began examining the critical relationship that developed between demons and witchcraft specifically in the 15th century. Now in Part 2, we’ll delve deeper into how this connection became the driving force behind the witch hunts that devastated communities across Europe.

    Professor Raiswell continues to guide us through how theological concepts about Satan evolved into specific accusations and persecution mechanisms. His expertise in medieval devil lore brings clarity to one of history’s darkest chapters.

    Remember, both parts of this special episode are available now wherever you get your podcasts. Thank you for joining us as we continue this chilling and fascinating exploration of how demonology fueled witch persecution. Both Part 1 and Part 2 are available now wherever you get your podcasts.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Richard Raiswell

    Shop our Nonprofit Bookshop for: The Routledge History of the Devil in the Western Tradition

    Purchase the Malleus Maleficarum: The Hammer of Witches, translated by Christopher S. MacKay

    Help Us Build Our New Patreon Community for The Thing About Salem Podcast

    Check out our new podcast: The Thing About Salem on YouTube!

    NEW PODCAST: The Thing About Salem

    Build Your Witch Trial History Library with a Purchase from our Bookshop!

    End Witch Hunts U. S. Nonprofit Organization

    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund


    Transcript

  • The Evolution of Diabolical Witchcraft Belief, Part 1

    We have a special treat for our listeners this week – not one but two new episodes dropping simultaneously! Today marks the return of Professor Richard Raiswell of the University of Prince Edward Island, who previously joined us for our fascinating “Speak of the Devil” episode where we explored Satan as one of history’s most enduring and complex figures.

    In this two-part special, The Evolution of Diabolical Witchcraft Belief, Professor Raiswell takes us deeper into the dark intersection where demonology meets witch persecution. We’ll explore the critical relationship that developed between demons and witchcraft specifically in the 15th century – a connection that would become the driving force behind the witch hunts.

    If you enjoyed our previous exploration of devil lore, these episodes are essential listening, as Professor Raiswell helps us understand how theological concepts about Satan evolved into specific accusations and persecution mechanisms.

    Both Part 1 and Part 2 are available now wherever you get your podcasts.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Richard Raiswell

    Shop our Nonprofit Bookshop for: The Routledge History of the Devil in the Western Tradition

    Purchase the Malleus Maleficarum: The Hammer of Witches, translated by Christopher S. MacKay

    Help Us Build Our New Patreon Community for The Thing About Salem Podcast

    Check out our new podcast: The Thing About Salem on YouTube!

    NEW PODCAST: The Thing About Salem

    Build Your Witch Trial History Library with a Purchase from our Bookshop!

    End Witch Hunts U. S. Nonprofit Organization

    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund


    Transcript

  • Sober and Civil: Sarah Cloyse of Salem with Antonio Stuckey

    In his return to Witch Hunt Podcast, Antonio Stuckey joins hosts Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack to discuss his research and book “Sober and Civil,” chronicling the remarkable life of Salem witch trials survivor Sarah Cloyse. As the younger sister of executed victims Rebecca Nurse and Mary Esty, Sarah Cloyse’s nine-month imprisonment represents a powerful chapter in Massachusetts witch trial historyโ€”one with personal significance to both hosts, who count her among their ancestors.

    Antonio shares how his focused research through court documents and historical records revealed the multidimensional woman behind the accusationโ€”the same figure who inspired the PBS miniseries “Three Sovereigns for Sarah.” The conversation explores Sarah’s defining act of defiance when she walked out of church slamming the door behind her, her complex first marriage to the dispute-prone Edmund Bridges, and her second husband Peter Cloyse’s unwavering loyalty during her imprisonment.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Help Us Build Our New Patreon Community for The Thing About Salem Podcast

    Check out our new podcast: The Thing About Salem on youtube!

    NEW PODCAST: The Thing About Salem

    Build Your Witch Trial History Library with a Purchase from our Bookshop!

    End Witch Hunts U. S. Nonprofit Organization

    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund


    Transcript

  • Perspectives on Disability, Stigma, and Witchcraft Accusations with Dr. Nora Groce

    Anthropologist Dr. Nora Groce from University College London discusses the troubling connection between disability and witchcraft accusations. Dr. Groce shares her research on why people with disabilities are targeted, including her study on the experience of persons with albinism in East Africa. We explore how traditional beliefs create stigma, discuss the global disability rights movement, and examine community-based solutions to protect vulnerable populations. This conversation will inform you on lesser-understood human rights issues related to witchcraft accusations worldwide.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Buy Book: Everyone Here Spoke Sign Language: Hereditary Deafness on Martha’s Vineyard Co-Authored by Nora Groce

    Disability & Inclusion Network Africa

    Prof. Nora Groce on World Disability Day

    CRIP CAMP Trailer

    Check out our new podcast: The Thing About Salem on youtube!

    End Witch Hunts U. S. Nonprofit Organization

    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund


    Transcript

  • The Myth of the Witches’ Flying Ointment with Michael Ostling

    Content Warning: This episode contains discussion of explicit sexual content related to historical witchcraft allegations.

    In this scholarly episode of Witch Hunt Podcast, hosts Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack welcome historian Dr. Michael Ostling to examine one of witchcraft history’s most persistent legends: the hallucinogenic flying ointment.

    Dr. Ostling carefully separates historical evidence from modern misconceptions, revealing how contemporary interpretations often reflect our own misogynistic projections rather than the experiences of those accused of witchcraft. Through thoughtful analysis, this episode respects the memory of innocent victims while providing listeners with a deeper understanding of how witchcraft myths evolve and persist across centuries.

    This conversation challenges popular assumptions and offers valuable historical context on this fascinating yet frequently misunderstood aspect of witch hunt history.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Michael Ostling’s Research

    Buy: Fairies, Demons, and Nature Spirits ‘Small Gods’ at the Margins of Christendom, edited by Michael Ostling

    Buy: Emotions in the History of Witchcraft, co-edited by Michael Ostling

    Buy: Between the Devil and the Host Imagining Witchcraft in Early Modern Poland, by Michael Ostling

    Check out our new podcast: The Thing About Salem on youtube!

    End Witch Hunts U. S. Nonprofit Organization

    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund


    Transcript

  • Genetics, Not Magic: Protecting Persons with Albinism in Uganda with Peter Ogik

    In this powerful episode, Josh and Sarah welcome Peter Ogik, Executive Director of Source of the Nile Union of Persons with Albinism in Uganda, who shares his personal story and advocacy work.

    About our guest: Peter Ogik was born and raised on an island in Lake Victoria, Uganda. As the first person with albinism in his community of about 600 people, Peter faced discrimination from birth but was fortunate to have supportive parents who advocated for him, especially in school settings where he initially struggled due to bullying and visual impairments associated with albinism.

    Key topics discussed:

    • Personal experiences with discrimination: Peter shares how he was called “a thing” rather than a person, and how children were told not to sit near him because of harmful myths.
    • Educational challenges: Teachers initially placed Peter at the back of the classroom despite his visual impairments until his father intervened, leading to improved academic performance.
    • Dangerous misconceptions: Peter survived three kidnapping attempts by those seeking to harvest his body parts for witchcraft, based on the false belief that they bring wealth.
    • Health challenges: Persons with albinism face high risks of skin cancer, with over 90% dying before age 30 without proper protection and care.
    • Women and girls with albinism: They face additional challenges, including sexual violence based on the myth that intercourse with a woman with albinism can cure HIV/AIDS.
    • Advocacy work: Through his organization, Peter works to:
      • Educate communities and change harmful perceptions
      • Provide mobile skin clinics and sun protection
      • Train teachers to better support students with albinism
      • Advocate for policy changes like tax exemptions on sunscreen
    • Signs of progress: Peter notes how community attitudes are changing, with more persons with albinism now graduating as doctors, lawyers, engineers, and other professionals.
    • International Albinism Awareness Day: This UN-recognized day (celebrated since 2015) has become a powerful platform for education and policy influence in Uganda.

    Resources mentioned:

    • Source of the Nile Union of Persons with Albinism (SNUPA)
    • Advantage Africa, a partner organization since 2013

    This episode highlights how education and advocacy can combat deadly superstitions and improve lives for marginalized groups. Peter’s message is one of resilience and hope: “I can’t wait to see the tomorrow whereby a person will not define me by my appearance, but will define me by my abilities.”

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Source of the Nile Union of Persons with Albinism

    Advantage Africa

    International Albinism Awareness Day Facebook Page

    End Witch Hunts U. S. Nonprofit Organization

    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund


    Transcript

  • Miss Albinism Africa with Sierra Leone’s Daniella Garrick

    In this powerful episode, we explore the discrimination faced by persons with albinism across Africa through conversations with two remarkable advocates from the Sierra Leone Association of Persons with Albinism (SLAPWA).

    Join us as we welcome back Jay Kamara, a familiar voice to our listeners, alongside Daniella Garrick, a model, youth leader, and advocate who is representing Sierra Leone in the upcoming Miss Albinism Africa pageant in June 2025.

    Our guests share how marginalized communities can transform visibility from a source of vulnerability into a platform for challenging misconceptions. Through initiatives like the Miss Albinism Africa pageant, they demonstrate how advocacy can operate effectively for communities that have faced persistent discrimination.

    This episode offers valuable insights into:

    • The specific support needed by persons with albinism in Sierra Leone
    • How pageantry becomes an unexpected vehicle for profound human rights advocacy
    • Ways you can participate in these important advocacy efforts

    How to support: The Sierra Leone Association of Persons with Albinism is seeking support for Daniella’s travel, accommodation, and competition expenses for the Miss Albinism Africa pageant. Learn more at albinismsierraleone.org or visit their Facebook page at facebook.com/slapwa17.

    Witch Hunt is dedicated to helping you learn about others’ experiences and providing meaningful opportunities to take action. Join us for this transformative conversation.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    email: slapwa.sl@gmail.com

    Sierra Leone Association of Persons with Albinism

    Sierra Leone Association of Persons with Albinism Facebook Page

    End Witch Hunts U. S. Nonprofit Organization

    Pro Victimis

    Medical Assistance Sierra Leone


    Transcript

  • Ending Witch Hunts in Papua New Guinea: Podcasthon Edition

    Welcome back to our Podcasthon series, “Ending Witch Hunts.”

    In this third installment of our Podcasthon series, Josh and Sarah continue the full story of witch hunting by examining contemporary SARV- sorcery accusations and related violence in Papua New Guinea. As Sarah reveals, “The witch hunting story is bigger than just what most people know. Pull back each layer and you find that witch hunts aren’t a tall tale or an open-and-shut case.”

    We will share about these layers through discussing the  complexities and nuances of SARV across the diverse cultures and developing communities of Papua New Guinea. You need to learn about the  incredible advocacy and victim support that is happening now through creative education and community development. Find out what makes ending SARV such a challenge.

    Podcasthon is a global movement to spread awareness about charities. Join us each day March 15-21 as we participate in Podcasthon 2025, where more than 1,500 podcasters unite to amplify causes close to their hearts. We’re proud to participate with our nonprofit End Witch Hunts, which works to educate about persecution of alleged witches worldwide.

    Tune in daily as we uncover this complex story layer by layer. Learn more at podcasthon.org and discover how you can help at www.endwitchhunts.org.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Help us recognize World Day Against Witch Hunts, August 10th

    Witch Hunt podcast

    Contribute to End Witch Hunts

    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund

    Podcasthon.org

    Papua New Guinea Discussions on Witch Hunt Podcast

    Boris Gershman Witch Hunt Podcast Episode

    Witchcraft Beliefs Around the World: An Exploratory Analysis

    The International Network

    Sorcery National Action Plan

    Give your support to Stop Sorcery Violence
    Peter and Grace Make a Difference Narrative


    Transcript

  • Ending Witch Hunts in Africa: Podcasthon Edition

    Welcome back to our Podcathon series, “Ending Witch Hunts.” In this second installment, Josh and Sarah continue the full story of witch hunting by examining contemporary witch hunts across Africa. As Sarah reveals, “The witch hunting story is bigger than just what most people know. Pull back each layer and you find that witch hunts aren’t a tall tale or an open-and-shut case.”

    We will cover several nations across Africa and how advocates in specific communities are supporting victims and educating the community. On this second day of Podcathon, we feature a special update from human rights activist Dr. Leo Igwe of Advocacy for Alleged Witches in Nigeria.

    Podcathon is a global movement to spread awareness about charities. Join us each day March 15-21 as we participate in Podcathon 2025, where more than 1,500 podcasters unite to amplify causes close to their hearts. We’re proud to participate with our nonprofit End Witch Hunts, which works to educate about persecution of alleged witches worldwide.

    Tune in daily as we uncover this complex story layer by layer. Learn more at podcasthon.org and discover how you can help at www.endwitchhunts.org.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Witch Hunt podcast

    Contribute to End Witch Hunts

    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Donate to Witch Hunt Podcast Conference Fund

    Podcasthon.org

    Boris Gershman Witch Hunt Podcast Episode

    Witchcraft Beliefs Around the World: An Exploratory Analysis

    The International Network

    The International Alliance to End Witch Hunts

    Advocacy for Alleged Witches, Nigeria

    Alhzeimer Dementia Namibia on Facebook

    Total Life Enhancement Center, Ghana

    The Sanneh Institute: Research, Religious, Society

    Advocacy Against Witch Hunts, South Africa

    Sierra Leone Association of Persons with Albinism

    Sierra Leone Association of Persons with Albinism Facebook Page

    The Source of the Nile Union of Persons with Albinism (SNUPA)

    Case Study, Synergies: Contagion of Positive Action

    Stop Child Witchcraft Accusations

    United Nations Human Rights Council Resolution 47/8. Elimination of harmful practices related to accusations of witchcraft and ritual attacks

    Pan African Parliament Guidelines on Accusations of Witchcraft and Ritual Attacks

    Podcast Episode: Ikponwosa Ero on Ending Witch Hunts

    Podcast Episode: Human Rights Day and Albinism: Muluka-Anne Miti-Drummond on Witchcraft Accusations and Ritual Attacks

    FIDA


    Transcript

  • On Protecting Persons with Albinism with Jay Mohammed Osman Kamara

    Safeguarding Persons with Albinism

    We explore the urgent human rights crisis affecting people with albinism in Africa. Expert guest Jay Mohammed Osman Kamara, Executive Director of the Sierra Leone Association of Persons with Albinism (SLAPWA), discusses protecting persons with albinism and the critical significance of UN Resolution 47/8 on eliminating harmful practices related to witchcraft accusations and ritual attacks. Drawing from his experiences and presentation at the Witchcraft and Human Rights Conference, Kamara reveals how deeply-rooted supernatural beliefs fuel deadly misconceptions, discrimination, and ritual attacks against persons with albinism. The conversation examines SLAPWA’s grassroots advocacy, community education initiatives, and protection strategies, while highlighting how the climate crisis creates extreme vulnerabilities for the community. Learn about the critical need for enhanced data collection, stronger government protections, and international cooperation in safeguarding persons with albinism. Content warning: This episode contains discussions of discrimination, violence, and suicide. Crisis support resources – United States: call/text 988 or visit 988lifeline.org; United Kingdom: call 111 or text SHOUT to 85258; Canada: call/text 988; Sierra Leone: dial 019.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    email: slapwa.sl@gmail.com

    SLAPWA

    SLAPWA Facebook Page

    End Witch Hunts U. S. Nonprofit Organization

    Pro Victimis

    Medical Assistance Sierra Leone

    Transcript

  • Stopping Child Witch Accusations: a Conversation with Carolyn Gent

    A critical issue still impacting children in parts of Sub-Saharan Africa is the ongoing crisis of witchcraft accusations. Carolyn Gent, a lawyer and chair of the Stop Child Witch Accusations Coalition, has dedicated her career to community development that prioritizes the safeguarding of children from these harmful accusations and the violence that often accompanies them.

    Carolyn shares her coalitionโ€™s innovative efforts to combat child witch accusations through education, community engagement, and faith-based initiatives. Listeners will gain insight into the root causes of these accusations, including poverty, fear, and misconceptions about child development, and learn about the coalitionโ€™s work to train church leaders and community members to foster safer, more compassionate environments.

    Key points discussed include the development of the โ€œHeart of the Matterโ€ training resource, the role of media in perpetuating harmful beliefs, and the importance of international collaboration in addressing witch hunts globally. Carolynโ€™s experience offers hope, demonstrating how education and compassion can transform communities and protect vulnerable children.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    www.stop-cwa.org

    Case Study, Synergies: Contagion of Positive Action

    Donate to Our UK Conference Trip GoFundMe Campaign to speak and learn about ending witch hunts

    End Witch Hunts

    Connecticut Witch Trial Exoneration Project

    Massachusetts Witch-Hunt Justice Project

    Maryland Witches Exoneration Project 

    Witch Hunt Website

    Salem Witch-Hunt Education Project

    Transcript

  • The Difference Between Witchcraft and Dementia with Andrias Mangundu

    This episode is a follow-up to our podcast episode on “The Link between Witchcraft Accusations and Dementia with Berrie Holtzhausen.” We interview Andrias Musigeni Mangundu, a registered nurse with the Ministry of Health and Social Services in Namibia. Andrias shares his journey into dementia care, heavily influenced by his experience and friendship with Berrie Holtzhausen, the founder of Alzheimerโ€™s Dementia Namibia. He discusses how dementia impacted his personal life, particularly through his mother’s misdiagnosed condition, which was wrongly attributed to witchcraft.

    Andrias educates listeners on the symptoms and types of dementia, dispelling myths that often confuse dementia with witchcraft in local communities. He emphasizes the importance of awareness programs, community education, and collaboration with healthcare providers to advocate for proper dementia care. The conversation also explores the societal challenges and the need for early diagnosis and support systems.

    Join us as we explore the intersection of healthcare and cultural beliefs, highlighting both the obstacles and the inspiring stories of change in Namibian communities. Gain a new perspective on dementia care and the power of education in transforming lives.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Alzheimer’s Dementia Namibia Facebook

    African Witchfinder Documentary 2018

    โ€˜They wanted her to confess to witchcraftโ€™: ending the chilling effects of dementia stigma in Nigeria

    Donate to Our UK Conference Trip GoFundMe Campaign to speak and learn about ending witch hunts

    End Witch Hunts

    Connecticut Witch Trial Exoneration Project

    Massachusetts Witch-Hunt Justice Project

    Witch Hunt Website

    Salem Witch-Hunt Education Project

    Transcript

  • The Link Between Dementia and Witchcraft Accusations with Berrie Holtzhausen

    Welcome to Witch Hunt, where we uncover the ongoing crisis of modern witch hunts and harmful practices. 

    In this episode, we talk with Berrie Holtzhausen, founder of Alzheimerโ€™s Dementia Namibia. Berrieโ€™s incredible journey to become a dementia advocate highlights his dedication to educating communities where those with dementia are often mistaken for harming their community with witchcraft.

    Hear Berrieโ€™s powerful stories of resilience, his fight against stigma, and his efforts to create dementia-friendly communities. Despite his own Alzheimer’s diagnosis, Berrie continues to rescue those falsely accused of witchcraft due to dementia symptoms.

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Alzheimer’s Dementia Namibia Facebook

    African Witchfinder Documentary 2018

    โ€˜They wanted her to confess to witchcraftโ€™: ending the chilling effects of dementia stigma in Nigeria

    Donate: End Witch Hunts UK AdvocacyTrip Fund

    End Witch Hunts

    Connecticut Witch Trial Exoneration Project

    Massachusetts Witch-Hunt Justice Project

    Witch Hunt Website

    Salem Witch-Hunt Education Project

    Transcript

  • Witchcraft Accusations in Ghana with John Azumah

    Joined by John Azumah, an expert who sheds light on the origins and societal impacts of witchcraft accusations, we navigate the intricate landscape of family disputes, community fears, and the national efforts to combat this grave injustice. Our journey takes us into the heart of communities torn apart by fear and suspicion, where accusations of witchcraft have long led to banishment and the resulting formation of ‘witch camps.’ Azumah’s insights offer a profound look at the cultural and societal dynamics that perpetuate these practices, as well as the ongoing struggles to reintegrate victims into their communities amidst threats of re-accusation and violence. This episode is a deep dive into the efforts at various levels to address and hopefully eradicate the stigma and harm caused by these ancient accusations, highlighting the urgent need for reform and protective measures for those unjustly accused.

    Listen with Spotify
    https://anchor.fm/s/f219b110/podcast/rss

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Recommended Reading

    United Nations Human Rights Council Resolution 47/8. Elimination of harmful practices related to accusations of witchcraft and ritual attacks  

    Report of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights: Study on the situation of the violations and abuses of human rights rooted in harmful practices related to accusations of witchcraft and ritual attacks, as well as stigmatization

    Websites of Note

    The Sanneh Institute: Research, Religious, Society

    Total Life Enhancement Center, Ghana

    Songtaba.org  Securing Basic Rights for Women and Girls

    Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom 

    Action Aid Ghana

    Legal Resource Centre Ghana

    Amnesty International, Ghana

    End Witch Hunts

    Why Witch Hunts are not just a Dark Chapter from the Past

    The International Network against Accusations of Witchcraft and Associated Harmful Practices

    Grassroots organizations working with The International Network

    International Alliance to End Witch Hunts

    Transcript

  • Caring for the Mental Health of Women in Ghana’s Witch Camps with Peter Mintir Amadu

    Listen with Spotify
    https://anchor.fm/s/f219b110/podcast/rss
    Witchcraft in the Granite State: Unveiling New Hampshire’s Witch Trials with Tricia Peone

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Show Notes

    We expand our advocacy discussion on modern day witch hunts and human rights abuses associated with accusations related to witchcraft to Ghana. Guest Peter Mintir Amadu is the Executive Director of the Total Life Enhancement Center (TOLEC) Ghana, a non-profit organization dedicated to community mental health advocacy and support. Amadu discusses TOLEC’s immersive and strategic engagement with witch hunt survivors, including psychological assessments and group and individual therapies to address trauma. Despite the challenges of severly scarce resources and logistical difficulties, TOLEC aims to bolster specialized support in ongoing efforts.

    This episode of โ€˜Witch Huntโ€™ underscores the necessity of increased intersectional cooperation, funding, and international awareness to tackle the global phenomenon of witch hunts. 

    Recommended Reading

    United Nations Human Rights Council Resolution 47/8. Elimination of harmful practices related to accusations of witchcraft and ritual attacks  

    Report of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights: Study on the situation of the violations and abuses of human rights rooted in harmful practices related to accusations of witchcraft and ritual attacks, as well as stigmatization

    Websites of Note

    Total Life Enhancement Center, Ghana

    The Sanneh Institute: Research, Religious, Society

    Songtaba.org  Securing Basic Rights for Women and Girls

    Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom 

    Action Aid Ghana

    Legal Resource Centre Ghana

    Amnesty International, Ghana

    End Witch Hunts

    Why Witch Hunts are not just a Dark Chapter from the Past

    The International Network against Accusations of Witchcraft and Associated Harmful Practices

    Grassroots organizations working with The International Network

    International Alliance to End Witch Hunts

    Transcript

    Josh Hutchinson: Welcome to Witch Hunt, the podcast that brings you news from the front lines of the struggle against modern day witch hunts. I'm Josh Hutchinson.
    Sarah Jack: And I'm Sarah Jack. Modern day witch hunts, also known as Harmful Practices Related to Accusations of Witchcraft and Ritual Attacks, are human rights abuses perpetrated against those believed to be witches or sorcerers.
    Josh Hutchinson: These abuses include physical and emotional attacks leading to injury and even death.
    Sarah Jack: Survivors are frequently traumatized by the harrowing experience of being accused of witchcraft.
    Josh Hutchinson: In Ghana, witch hunt refugees flee to so called 'witch camps.'
    Sarah Jack: These camps are for people [00:01:00] banished from their communities following witchcraft accusations.
    Josh Hutchinson: Living conditions in the camps are deplorable, and the residents destitute.
    Sarah Jack: However, concern is developing among advocates and within sectors of the national government in regard to the conditions at the camps and the future of the witch hunt victims.
    Josh Hutchinson: One recent development has been onsite mental health intervention to address the victims' trauma.
    Sarah Jack: This effort involved physicians from the Total Life Enhancement Center, TOLEC,a mental health facility located in Northern Region capital Tamale and led by Executive Director Peter Mintir Amadu.
    Josh Hutchinson: We hung on every word in our engaging interview with Mr. Amadu, and we know that you will too.
    Sarah Jack: In this episode, you will learn about the challenges faced by the victims of witchcraft accusation-related violence.
    Josh Hutchinson: And about some different treatment methods being employed by TOLEC.
    Sarah Jack: We are [00:02:00] delighted to introduce Peter Mintir Amadu, Executive Director of the Total Life Enhancement Center in Ghana and a leading figure in mental health. A licensed clinical health psychologist and university lecturer, Peter is pivotal in advancing mental health services in Northern Ghana.
    Sarah Jack: He advocates for mental health across multiple platforms. He mentors youth, and his work focuses on youth and maternal mental health issues. As chairman of the Ghana Psychological Association's Northern Sector, Peter's
    Sarah Jack: commitment extends to providing consultation and training.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: My name is Peter Mintir Amadu. My background is clinical health psychologist. I'm a lecturer at the University for Development Studies. The University for Development Studies is the premier university in the north. The northern part of Ghana has about five regions, and it was the very first university in the north.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: I am affiliated to the Tamale Teaching Hospital, of which I do [00:03:00] a clinical health psychologist consulting at the internal medicine and virtually for the entire hospital. As it stands now,I'm just among two other psychologists that operate within the Tamale Teaching Hospital as a tertiary and a referral facility.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Come to initiatives, what have I initiated as a person? You got me through an organization called Total Life Enhancement Center. That is my initiative. I just felt that a people, we didn't do so much regarding mental health. And in 2017, I established this organization with a lot of young ones around me. So I founded the organization and I lead it at the civil society space where we advocate for mental health in schools, radio, and in the communities. So Total Life Enhancement Center is a [00:04:00] psychology-focused organization and the first private psychology clinic in the entire northern Ghana. I've mentioned that Northern Ghana has five regions, administrative regions.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: My second initiative has been in the area of mental health advocacy. So in schools, radio, community, religious organization, and CSOs, health facilities and corporate organizations are places where my services and my skill and my passion have actually driven me to.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: What have I supported? I've tried to be a mentor to a lot of young ones in the mental health space who are seeking to appreciate what mental health is and understand. So basic, senior high school, and then the tertiary level.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: What are my research interest? I really have great interest in the area of youth and maternal mental health. That's my area of interest. And recently an article [00:05:00] entitled, 'Drug Abuse Among the Youth of Northern Region, The Realities of Our Time.' And that is really taking a lot of shape in the academic space.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: What's my passion? What has been driving me as a person over the period? I must admit, to make available mental health services to my people has been my passion. And also to make greatly available psychological services to our operational areas. I have played different roles as a person over the period of time in the north. I have been in the Ghana Health Service over two decades, and so I have worked as the chairman of the Ghana Psychological Association members in the Northern sector, psychologist to CSOs in the northern region of Ghana and a service provider to a lot of organizations. And so in brief, this is what I'll say who Peter Mintir [00:06:00] Amadu is.
    Josh Hutchinson: What more can you tell us about the Total Life Enhancement Center?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Yes. Life Enhancement Center, Ghana. TOLEC is an organization with a primary focus in psychology, so the abbreviation is T O L E C G H, and we call it TOLEC. TOLEC is dedicated to the promotion and advocacy towards improving psychological well being. We say that Tolec is an organization that provides mental health and psychosocial support services.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And our vision is to be a center that employs the biopsychosocial and the scientist practitioner approach to delivering comprehensive assessment and health promotion services. The vision of TOLEC is to be a center dedicated to advocating for and delivering holistic health solutions through both local and [00:07:00] external competent methods to our clients. This approach is aimed at enhancing psychological wellbeing, thereby fostering increased productivity and development.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: What's our mandate? Our mandate as an organization is to enhance the location of psychological resources to benefit society through our contribution. TOLEC operates in six thematic areas: mental health advocacy, psychological service provision, counseling services, emotional intelligence and management, livelihood empowerment of capacity building, and mental health research. TOLEC is currently located in the Northern Regional Capital, Tamale, in the Sanaribu Municipality. So this is a little I will say about TOLEC, and TOLEC as a psychology clinic and a service provider have been in the advocacy space [00:08:00] since 2018, and we have done advocacy in schools, radios, communities, and corporate organizations, and we currently stand as among one of the very best mental health service organizations in northern Ghana. Even when it comes to the issues of psychological services, we are the first in the entire northern part of Ghana to provide psychological services as an organization.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: So this is the bit I would say about Total Life Enhancement Center Ghana, TOLEC.
    Sarah Jack: I found your center online when I was doing some research around some alleged witchcraft violence, and I saw that you have an initiative to support women who have been in witch camps. Is that one of your outreaches at your facility?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Yes please. It's one of the outreaches we have undertaken in [00:09:00] the recent past. We have been involved in giving some support to a number of women. In 2020, I was part of a group of organizations. TOLEC was part of a group of organizations that, roll out a number of activities. But the focus at that was with health workers in the districts that hosted this Alleged Witch Camps.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Last year, we took this initiative, and this initiative was supported by the Commission of Human Rights and Administrative Justice (CHRAJ). And they actually partnered us, basically supported almost every bit of the logistical bit of it to go provide, because they came to us. We have been to these women. We have done the normal physical examinations with them. We provided medication, but there's an aspect that has never been talked about. But the organization said to me, 'do you want to do [00:10:00] something with this?' I said, 'why not? It is an opportunity we have all been looking out for.' So they said, 'okay. Get out there and pack your bag and baggage and go to four districts in the north and perform these particular activities for us.'
    Peter Mintir Amadu: So I immediately have to put in place a group of psychologists, that was counseling psychologists, health psychologists, and clinical psychologists, and clinical health psychologists. They were the people I rallied behind to look back. Then, we took up this mantle, and we spent a little over two weeks engaging these women at the alleged witch camps. And so our intervention was the first of its kind in the area of mental health, because people are going in there, but not with assessment in the area of psychology. So we went in there doing psychological assessment.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And what we basically did was to use a particular psychological tool we call DASS, Depression, Anxiety, and Stress [00:11:00] Skill. That is well, utilize and also, and trying to look at some level of distress, psychological distress among these women. So after administering these tools, we found data that was very interesting. Data that was very, at a point, if not for my background as a professional, very scary.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Scary in the sense that a lot of them who have stayed in there years, decades, have nobody to look after them, no shelter, no food, no healthcare, and in most of the places they live in very deplorable states. I, I possibly would delve deeper into this, but let me say that our, that was quite revealing for us, because when it came to the issues of depression, we were quite interested and we realized that even though after administering the psychological [00:12:00] tools, which I must admit we went in there to do an assessment for just around 300 women. We ended up doing a little over 350 women, alleged witches. this was carried out in four districts in Ghana, and those four districts, three of them are found in the northern region. Then one is found in the northeast region of Ghana. And the three found in the northern region of Ghana are the Kpatinga Alleged Witch Camp, which is found in the Gushegu Municipal District. Then we had the Kukuo Witch Camp, which is found in the Nanumba South. And then we had a Gnani Alleged Witch Camp, which is found in the Yendi municipality. Yendi is, call it our [00:13:00] traditional capital. Yendi sits the overlord of our region, call it, I mean we call it, the, the overlord of Dagbon. And so the parliament chief of the northern region sit in Yendi, and in his district also is where, we find the Gnani Alleged Witch Camp. So these 3 are found in northern region. Then in the northeast region is found Gambaga Alleged, Witch Camp, and Gambaga is one administrative district, a colonial administrative district. In the colonial era, Gambaga was one of the, I mean renowned district that govern northern region. So in the colonial era, they had more of Gambaga than even Tamale, where, which is now well pronounced.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: So what did we find among the 335 women in terms of psychological distress? We had [00:14:00] 73% of our respondents, that's a little around 247 participants, who were assessed to have high level of psychological distress. Depression we assess among these groups as 61 percent of the participants. Anxiety was around 72%. And the issues of stress related was around 38%. So this was what we found at the alleged witch camps, where we were supported by the Commission on Human Rights and Administrative Justice to do an assessment and provide intervention.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: So this was the assessment, what we found among them. Many people have come to know very well that when it comes to the issues of alleged witches or witchcraft accusations, a lot of organizations have often [00:15:00] put their energies around the physical bit of it. And two, three years ago, we had the experience of a woman, an old woman who was allegedly accused and beaten to death, and that actually triggered a lot of conversation in the Ghanaian media space regarding the issues of alleged witches. What can we do? And that actually initiated the legislation in the Ghanaian parliament, which is almost at the verge of completion, where accusation of alleged witchcraft will become criminal in the Ghanaian laws.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And these have been terms that we have been finding as, from our research as a professional and leading this institution towards the provision of psychological assessment and intervention. I will take the intervention bit, but I'm sure you may want to ask a bit of questions regarding this.
    Sarah Jack: I'm amazed [00:16:00] at what you are tackling for your community.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Thank you.
    Josh Hutchinson: At this point, do you have plans to return to do more intervention with these women?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Yes. We have a lot of plans towards, engaging further with these women. But, one after our assessment, so the intervention, but what we did, we, after we collected this psychological assessment and found these, what we did was to put the women in group therapy. So we first of all put them in groups, and our psychologists engage them in at different levels, providing support. And then we also went further to then provide individual intervention, because in the group, lemme mention that in our country and,in the space of Sub-Saharan Africa, issues of mental health and, psychotherapy, not well appreciated. We [00:17:00] went on, people can be in the groups and may not talk, so after engaging them at a group level, we decided to also open an opportunity for a number of the women to go talk to the psychologist on one-on-one basis.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And we basically spent, for logistical sakes, we spent two days in every community. We wish we did more. But the logistics were our challenge. So after providing that, we came back and we provided a report to the Commission of Human Rights and Administrative Justice. On our part, as an organization, what we have been thinking is we know psychological therapy will not yield results overnight, and if it will not yield results overnight, what else do we need to do?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: We began this year with some more planning as to what is it that we can go back to the community, but the numbers are huge.
    Sarah Jack: Yeah.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: The numbers are huge. Even when we got in there and the idea was to do 300, we ended up doing [00:18:00] 300 plus. And even doing 350, I mean35, was just because we were running out of the logistics that were being provided. If we had stayed in there, we would have seen closer to 500 people. And that tells us that the numbers are there. And the idea is to, from this year, to see how we can at least either every six months, if we have the resources, or every quarter to go back there, provide an intervention. But first of all, I often have said that the issues of mental health cannot be talked to people in, in, call it hungry stomachs. The belly is not full. They are not going to listen. So our idea has been, how can we then go back to them with a picnic style of therapy, where we are dining with them and providing therapy, letting them understand that, yes, you are here, the challenges are there, but don't give up. [00:19:00] Life still means a lot for you.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: So we are still mobilizing the resources and pushing at our own level to see how we can go back, provide 335 that we have already seen and extend that therapy beyond the individuals. And the idea has always been to also reach out to the communities, these four communities in which these alleged witch,camps are situated. They need support. They need mental health education, they need psychotherapy themself, and they need capacity building, because when they have it these women can be supported, because a number of the women listening to them said that any time at all we are troubled, those who are, who come to our help, our aid, are the chiefs, the community leaders, the assembly members, but these are people who are into a great, but barely doing minimal farming. So when they harvest, it becomes insufficient even for their own families. Let's talk of [00:20:00] supporting another family. So building their capacity, providing agri related support for them so that they can be able to till the land enough to also feed these women.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: We have been thinking of also partnering with other organizations, because a number of organizations are in the area of supporting women. A lot of them are shying away from the support for these vulnerable women who, just allegation, there is no substance in it. Culture, religion, superstition. Then they push them there. Because I keep asking the question, how come we don't have the very elite members of our society, their mothers in these alleged witch camps, but the poor woman that have nobody to defend, the poor woman that the woman that have nobody to talk for, are those who are always accused and put in there, and hunger, lack of shelter, water, [00:21:00] proper, mean sanitary condition becomes a challenge for these women.
    Sarah Jack: Yeah.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: So we really have intention of going back. But we hope we can go back there in another style where we can be able to dine and feast with them and provide therapy, stay there a bit longer than two, three days is the target we're hoping.
    Sarah Jack: Clearly, it was a significant event that your team was able to go and engage in these camps and collect this significant data and then I can see how it would also be a very big effort for you to use that data to get support to move forward in the program.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Yeah. So we are currently trying to document a bit around this, and we have actually done a little around social media publication, working a bit to see how we can publish this in academic journal. So [00:22:00] that we can be able to tell the story. We are still hoping that the district assembly, the government, the region, and then well-meaning individuals will come our aid so that we can go back there and provide enough, but this data really is something I know we can use and to make an impact in society.
    Sarah Jack: Am I understanding that right now, the president has not signed the legislation on these witch camps? If he does close them, how does that impact these communities?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Thank you. You are right. I think, currently the advocacy in the civil society space is to get the president's assent to this bill and make it law, and we're hoping that this will happen before his tenure of office, which is just in the 7th of January, come next year. If that so happens, we know that [00:23:00] will create another huge need for our people.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: But the refreshing part of it is that engaging these women, a good number of them are willing to go back to the communities. So reintegration should be the plan forward, so that in the event where these camps are closed down, where can they go back? Go back to their communities, go back to their families, and the communities need to be sensitized.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: The communities need to be engaged, and so it means advocacy needs to get to the community, to understand that these women are just like your mothers. These women are just like those women you have at home, who could be wives, sisters, aunties, Grandma. And all that we can give them at this moment is to say that you have been with us, and it is a difficult moment that probably you have nobody to support you the way you would have wished.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: But we are here as a community, and we are hoping that we can be able to provide you. [00:24:00] Because of the desire of a number of them to go back to their communities, if this law comes into force and these communities are,dissolved, what it means is that a good number of them will be more ready to go back, have people to accept them.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: The few that have no support, we can look for a reintegrative process where we can engage chiefs, leaders, assembly members to see how they can absorb them. Already, some of the camps have become like towns, have become like big communities. So the women are already very comfortable. A good number of them, they're into agri, into one, I mean small businesses, and they're already doing well. So those of them who don't wanna go back can be supported.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: So in the process of, if these things are dissolved, what we can do is to build their capacity to be well supported. So in terms of economics, in terms of their health care, [00:25:00] and in terms of their general well being, because once they have capital, they have resources, when they are not well, they will go to the hospitals. When they are not well, they'll go to health facilities and look for support. But some of their challenges have always been that, even when I'm not well, I have no money. Even though a good number of them, in Ghana we operate the health insurance system. A good number of them are active health insurance users, but sometimes the facilities are at a distance and they may need even transport to arrive there. So when they are dissolved, I think they can be some level of capacity building for the women, some level of support so that they can be sustaining. So income generating activities to sustain themselves.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And I, that's what I can say if this ever, if it ever happens in the foreseeable future.
    Josh Hutchinson: You mentioned that you're hoping to work with other organizations that deal with women's [00:26:00] issues. When violence against women is considered in Ghana, is witchcraft based violence part of that conversation? Are these other groups already talking about the witchcraft allegations, or have they yet to get involved in that?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: I'm here to get deeper conversations with them. Yes,I have just seen an article about them. I really didn't have so much information. If there is a way, I mean, I'll go into the website and try to get more information, but if there's a way we can connect, you are able to connect us too, we can work greatly together towards supporting, because some other people may have what I call the logistical support. We have a technical support, psychologists, but if we are not able to carry them there, they may not be able to do this particular great service to our women. So I'm looking for that partnership.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: There is this other organization called Songtaba, and Songtaba is a women's [00:27:00] rights organization, and they have often engaged us very much when it comes to the issues of alleged witches, and they have, they were those that engaged me to work with them.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: We're also trying to talk to the health workers within the district that these camps are found, because a lot of them do receive them at the hospital level, and what support they can give them. So I've often served as a consultant for them in the area of helping the health workers. Now, going to the women, they were not part of it, and we are hoping that we can be able to draw them into the system.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: We're also trying to talk to the district assembly, talk to the municipal assemblies, the administrative district, to see. We have something we call the District Assembly Common Fund, and an aspect of it is supposed to be spent on the less vulnerable in society. How can this four districts make this a little token towards supporting mental health services of these women? It's a conversation I think we can begin to initiate.
    Josh Hutchinson: [00:28:00] Based on your experience with the women, do you know what kinds of things they're accused of actually doing with witchcraft? What does witchcraft belief look like in Ghana?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Thank you very much. Yes, engaging and talking to a number of the women, what has brought them to the camps have been the fact that a brother's son woke up and said he saw me in his dream, and having seen me in his dream, I'm the one trying to stifle his progress in life. And that is the level of accusation.
    Sarah Jack: One of the very elderly woman told me Ghana is a very communal community, where I must admit we love each other and we share a lot of things. And this woman, all that she told me, what brought her to the camp was the fact that as an old lady, [00:29:00] that's how she called herself, 'I was eating food, and this small boy was around my environment, and you can see the boy was looking hungry. I basically served the boy food. And this was my crime, accused of witchcraft, and so they have to banish me to come to that community.' And when they banish them, what they say is that they go there to perform a sacrifice, and when you go there to perform the sacrifice, and you don't return, it means all the accusation is true, and some of them go there, and they realize that even before I left the community, they were following me with cutlasses, with clubs, as if I am a chief. And when they get in there, and the chief of the community receive them, give them accommodation, give them the comfort that they need, some of them may not go back, and so they conclude, yes, our allegation is true.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Another woman said that her rival, in the Ghanaian space, we have a [00:30:00] number of women that are married to one man, so polygamy does exist in our environment. 'My rival, who is the second wife told my husband that she keeps seeing me in her dream and she realizes that her business is no longer going on as I mean it used to be. So I am the one responsible, and so the community come chasing me.' Do this woman find herself in the alleged witch camp?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: The pathetic story I heard at this place was the story of one of the women? And what was her story? Her story was that 'I was accused of killing my own son. How did that happen? The child went to school, got to the university, got a job, and started to visit the village, was involved in [00:31:00] an accident and died. And they said that it is the mother, because the mother doesn't want the child to progress. And this woman's pathetic story was, 'if I can bear this child in my womb for nine months, nurse him for five good years, to go past what we used to call childhood killer diseases, why will I hurt this child? This time that he can fetch water for me to drink. This was how painful it was for this woman. If I can take care of a child who was helpless, this is the time you can probably say, mama, I am sending you MoMo, buy a little fish, buy a little meat to cook. Why would I take such a life?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: These are the pathetic stories. And a number of them have been accused in ways that you just cannot imagine it. In our last activity we had, we also discovered [00:32:00] two men, or let me say a number of men, but two of them were willing to speak to us. So we have alleged wizards at some of the camps. And basically, their story didn't go far from that of the women. Because somebody see me as standing in the way of his progress. Was accusation because he's my uncle, and my uncle doesn't want my progress, and so my father will now put pressure and the community will put pressure and will banish this person from the community. Their stories are really pathetic.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And the deep seated pain alone is so much to bear for some of the women, and sometimes I look at it, I see. If all the things that we do as a country, as a region, and as a district, if we could even dedicate a little [00:33:00] resource towards the mental wellbeing of these women, I'm sure a lot of them can live there and still fulfill their life, but unfortunately, the issues of mental health little talked about in our country, because when it comes to the issues of mental health, even among the general population in Ghana, mental health literacy is very low.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And so access to mental health services become very low among our people. There is a document that was added in 2014 by a lot of researchers and, I mean pushed by the mental health authority. Our treatment gap currently in Ghana stands at 98%, and when they come to the issues of mental health resources, the professionals are really not available.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: As I speak to you now, within the northern part of Ghana, we don't have [00:34:00] more than 10 practicing psychologists, and the northern part of Ghana is put all together, it's almost close to 5 million population, and this population have no adequate mental health resources. Talk about psychologists.
    Sarah Jack: And so currently, a lot of us are occasionally under a bit of pressure because as I introduced myself, I teach at the university. I provide consultancy at the Tamale Teaching Hospital, but yet, because TOLEC is a passion for me, I see TOLEC as a passion I must drive to benefit my people, because at the end of the day, TOLEC most of the time doesn't put food on my table. The university puts food on my table. But TOLEC is a passion where I want to be able to reach out to many more people. So at TOLEC, we then bring a lot of young ones to advocate about mental health. And that has been what we have been doing and [00:35:00] leading us to support these women.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And when it come to the issues of maternal mental health, I mentioned that a research interest area.a lot of our women, a research currently on my waiting publication, a little over 60% of mother are battling what we call postpartum depression. In my region, around 58% are battling postpartum anxiety. How can a traumatized woman be able to raise a very successful young man? So I keep telling people when I go to seminars, if we want a very healthy society, our women, our mothers, our aunties, whatever we want to call them, our grandmothers must be in the best of health.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And that health must be in the dual form, mental health and physical health. Unfortunately, mental health is [00:36:00] underplayed, in my country and in my region, a reason why some of us are very passionate about this conversation that we're having.
    Josh Hutchinson: Thank you for this conversation.I'm so glad that you're doing what you do, because these women, they're as important as anybody else, and they deserve their dignity and comfort.
    Sarah Jack: We've learned a little bit from some of the other advocacy work that there needs to be this focus on the youth. And I'm hearing that element in your work, the mental health support into the youth, how that can trickle up into the community as they grow. That is a positive support for the future. How do you get to the point where banishment isn't an answer?
    Sarah Jack: I was thinking [00:37:00] about how the banishment really is this point at which, it's a solution, but it's also a problem.
    Sarah Jack: It's starting a problem.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: When you look at the banishment as we currently have it in our situation, this happens, and those women are banished from the community. They leave all their livelihood, they leave all their connection, they leave all their relationship, and they leave everything they have ever lived for to a land that they don't know anything about, but just because that land is accommodating.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And so the issues of mental health plays a role in this banishment, because at the end of the day, if you think somebody else has a challenge, have you listened to this person? Have you engaged this person? Because in most of the banishment situation, they never, nobody ever listened to this one. There's never a listening ear. [00:38:00] What they call a listening ear, where the problem is sending you to a particular group of people who have already made up their mind anyway, so they just send you there for, okay, we have sent you to this place to verify, but they already know what they want to do. If the conversation around mental health can be enhanced, what we do have is that a lot of people will look at this with some other perspective. What other way could we have looked at this without banishing this woman, without asking this woman to leave her business in that village, to move to a village she knows nobody and she has no connection?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: That conversation can start. And, Maybe a reason why, when we started our organization, the idea was to see how we can engage the youth and our reason for engaging the youth was to say that catch them young and they will [00:39:00] understand mental health and will use mental health services, even in their old age. So if they start understanding mental health now, they will build what I call resilience. They will build what I call self esteem. They will build assertiveness skills. So they will be able to make conversations to fight for people within the community. Sometimes some of the women just need somebody to say that, please, I will challenge you, and the problem will drop that whole accusation, but there's nobody to challenge. And these old women virtually are left to their fate.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Two years ago, I met a woman who told me her story. works in our national capital. A very responsible woman, but her mother stays in the village in the northern part of Ghana, and the children are well to do. A community member allegedly accused the woman, [00:40:00] and within 24 hours, six children of this woman arrived in the village. The best of cars that the village has never seen, arrived in the best of dressing the village, possibly have never seen, and that whole conversation died.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: So this is what it means for our women. Some of them just go through some of these things just because there's nobody to fight for them. And so if the youth of today are educated about mental health, and they're ready to assertively speak for people who are accused wrongly, I'm sure we can go somewhere. We will get a way towards finally minimizing this banishment from our communities.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: And that's why our activities as an organization have taken the youth dimension, where we want the young ones to lead. So we have a basic school mental health advocate. We have secondary, senior high school mental health advocate, and we have tertiary mental [00:41:00] health advocate, where we want the youth to lead the advocacy, youth leading change in the environment, so that they themselves can learn about mental health, educate their colleagues, and provide the resilience that they need, because I keep saying that in the area of our life, I have come to realize that, in my little study in the area of psychology, I have come to develop a statement that I say that we are what we think. And this is premised from Epictetus quote of, 'it is not what happens to you, but how you react to it,' Epictetus, the great philosopher. So I've come to believe that what we think as a community. What we think as a people is what we live with, because we come to think that once I don't make progress in life, somebody's behind that, my challenge. Somebody has not studied, somebody have not invested in his youthfulness, and he think the old lady in the village is the reason [00:42:00] why he's not in the best of motorbike, he's not using the best of cars, he's not in the best of building. But that is just because of the way the person is thinking.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: If we can engage our youth to begin to look at the way they think that will have a great influence in the behavior that will exhibit in their old age and all of that. So the reason why we, the youth have become a focus
    Sarah Jack:
    Peter Mintir Amadu: and we think that if we can do this and do this very much, I'm sure our next generation will be better in terms of mental health access and service provision.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: Let me divert a little bit to the area of women. The reason why we have also diverted to women as a focus. A traumatized woman, an battered woman, and a woman that is battling one challenge or the other cannot raise the best leader of the world. How can [00:43:00] that woman raise a a child, who has been accused of witchcraft? That woman is in pain. That woman is traumatized, and she cannot be in the best frame of mind to raise an adult who become that responsible in society. So we need to support our women and that is an area where we have, we taught, because the research in that area is quite scanty. And the work we have done, we have a number of data just waiting to publish this and let the people understand that we need to support women and the youth, if we want a better society.
    Josh Hutchinson: Are there ways that we and our listeners can support your efforts?
    Peter Mintir Amadu: We have often called for support from the international community. And I must admit we have been operating for the past, seven, eight years. We really don't have any funding, we [00:44:00] don't have any donor, and we don't have anybody who comes to, say, at the beginning of the year, 'what are your plans? Take this and begin to implement in the area of youth mental health or adolescent mental health and in the area of maternal mental health.' No, but we just do this outta passion.
    Sarah Jack: The invitation from you has been my fuel or my source of motivation. Because I keep telling people if goodwill was filling bank accounts, I'm sure I could compete with Bill Gates and his compatriots, because people tell me what you do is good, but that doesn't translate to money in my bank account. It doesn't translate to fuel in the vehicles that we use as an organization.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: But can we stop? Somebody must be ready to take this somewhere. So in the area of funding, I must admit, we have been challenged. And we will more open [00:45:00] and more ready to collaborate with international organization, local organization,even individuals who are passionate about the issues of alleged witchcraft and want to support. We are more ready to collaborate with them, especially to send our psychologists to these women every quarter or even every month. I cannot fund that now.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: So we can only call for support from the international community. But even before the international community come, I want to charge even my own people, the local community, our chiefs, our government functionaries, and the CSOs in Ghana, to see this as a priority, to see this as a need, because if a section of our population are suffering, we cannot claim to be complete.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: For us, I will say, if there are any international organizations that want to partner with us to make mental health [00:46:00] services readily available for these women, the immediate community, the health workers within this community, I must admit, we are, we will be grateful to collaborate and to assure you that your funds that you are donating, your funds that you are pushing through TOLEC will really reach these women in ways that will change their lives, because we will build their capacity.
    Peter Mintir Amadu: We will resource them, and they may not need to continue dependent on the occasional support that people can. People just come and they're coming with a handful of rice. How long will this woman take with this? Sustaining income? Income where they can depend on. So we are more open and we are ready and very willing to collaborate with international organizations to provide therapy, to provide infrastructure, to provide shelter, and to provide clothing [00:47:00] and food for these women, because these are their areas of need.
    Sarah Jack: And now for Minute with Mary.
    Mary-Louise Bingham: It was an honor to meet with advocate on gender-based violence in India, Neelesh Singh. Neelesh and his team help women who are wrongfully accused of practicing sorcery heal both physically and emotionally so they can find their voice and pay it forward. Education is key for the women who learn their legal rights for their unique circumstances.
    Mary-Louise Bingham: To heal the hearts of these wounded survivors, Neelesh and his team offer counseling, music, and art therapy. The art therapy will start small. The survivors will expand their art until they feel comfortable to create street art on walls donated by various law enforcement agencies. In other cases, women will be encouraged to write and direct their own street plays, telling the public of their stories to create [00:48:00] awareness and education.
    Mary-Louise Bingham: Stay tuned for an upcoming episode on this podcast where you will hear more details as to how Neelesh's team empower by helping the survivors gain confidence and find their inner strength so they can be heard. Thank you.
    Sarah Jack: Thank you, Mary.
    Josh Hutchinson: And here's Sarah with End Witch Hunts News.
    Sarah Jack: End Witch Hunts, a non profit, 501c3 organization, Weekly News Update. As we step into Women's History Month, starting Friday, March 1st, with International Women's Day on March 8th, embracing the theme, 'Inspire Inclusion,' I prompt you to reflect on the embodiment of the international woman. Who does she remind you of? A figure of historical significance, or perhaps someone enduring the trials of today's world?
    Sarah Jack: When pondering the enduring persecution and marginalization faced by women throughout history, your thoughts may gravitate towards the women in northern and northeast Ghana [00:49:00] relegated to witch camps due to accusations of witchcraft. These camps, a stark reality for many, symbolize not just the psychological and quality of life detriment stemming from such accusations, but also connect us to a broader narrative that spans centuries and continents.
    Sarah Jack: The prevalence of depression, influenced by factors like gender, marital status, and the absence of biological children among these women in witch camps, coupled with their almost universally low quality of life, underscores the critical mental health and well being issues they face.
    Sarah Jack: These women living on the fringes of society are the modern day echoes of the ancestors who faced execution in historical witch trials, embodying the perennial outcasts, the feared 'witch' within their communities.
    Sarah Jack: As International Women's Day urges us to inspire inclusion, let's remember that the international woman of history is also the woman in a Ghanaian witch camp today. She is the mother, sister, and daughter [00:50:00] ensnared in these circumstances. But she's also the advocate fighting for those trapped in the shadows of vulnerability. In the coming weeks, we invite you to join us in a conversation about women around the world who endure persecution and exclusion,branded as outcasts and feared as witches in their communities.
    Sarah Jack: This Women's History Month, we are called upon to partake in the collective action to impact history for women everywhere. How are you contributing to this chorus of voices, both past and present, forging a future where dialogue is not just powerful, but transformative, evolving into actions that construct a true realm of justice? Together, we can shift narratives and foster a world where inclusivity reigns supreme. Honoring those who have suffered and paving the way for a future where no woman stands alone in the face of injustice.
    Josh Hutchinson: Thank you, Sarah.
    Sarah Jack: You're welcome.
    Josh Hutchinson: And thank you for listening to Witch Hunt.
    Sarah Jack: Join us next week.
    Josh Hutchinson: Subscribe wherever you're [00:51:00] listening.
    Sarah Jack: Visit us at aboutwitchhunts.com/.
    Josh Hutchinson: And remember to tell your friends, families, acquaintances, neighbors, and anybody you meet about witch hunt.
    Sarah Jack: Support our efforts to end witch hunts. Visit endwitchhunts.org to learn more.
    Josh Hutchinson: Have a great today and a beautiful tomorrow.
  • Wonderful Mkhutche on Witch-Hunting in Malawi

    https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/2045153.rss

    Listen in Your Favorite App

    Listen and subscribe wherever you enjoy podcasts:

    Show Notes

    Anti-witch-hunt advocate Wonderful Mkhutche, author, editor, biographer and executive director of Humanist Malawi introduces the witch hunt crisis in Malawi. We dive deep into the prevalent belief in witchcraft, where 74% of the populace acknowledges its existence. Explore Malawians’ perspectives on the powers of witchcraft and confront the legal implications surrounding witchcraft accusations. Wonderful illuminates the harsh realities of violence against the accused and delves into the imprisonment of victims. Gain valuable insights as Wonderful shares efforts to liberate and rehabilitate those unjustly detained due to witchcraft allegations.

    Wonderful Mkhutche Ted Talk, Witchcraft Belief in Malawi

    Humanist Malawi Facebook Page

    Humanists Malawi have called on Malawi to drop proposed legislation that would recognize the existence of witchcraft.

    Wonderful Mkhutche Blog

    Religion and Politics in Malawi: Short Essays

    Dr. Dinesh Mishra on Facebook

    Sign the Petition: MA Witch Hunt Justice Project

    www.massachusettswitchtrials.org

    Bennington Museum Special Exhibits

    Support Us! Shop Our Book Shop

    Advocacy for Alleged Witches, Nigeria

    Support Us! Sign up as a Super Listener!

    End Witch Hunts Movement 

    Support Us! Buy Witch Trial Merch!

    Support Us! Buy Podcast Merch!

    Join us on Discord to share your ideas and feedback.

    Transcript

    [00:00:10] Josh Hutchinson: Welcome to Thou Shalt Not Suffer: The Witch Trial Podcast. I'm Josh Hutchinson.
    
    [00:00:15] Sarah Jack: And I'm Sarah Jack. Today's episode will inform you on the current witch hunt situation in Malawi.
    [00:00:22] Josh Hutchinson: Learn about the nation.
    [00:00:25] Sarah Jack: And the prevalence of witchcraft belief there.
    [00:00:28] Josh Hutchinson: Hear about what Malawians believe about witchcraft.
    [00:00:32] Sarah Jack: And become informed about what the law states about witchcraft accusations, and the reality of the violence against persons accused of witchcraft.
    [00:00:41] Josh Hutchinson: Wonderful talks about why many victims are jailed.
    [00:00:45] Sarah Jack: And how he and others have worked to free and rehabilitate people imprisoned long term following witchcraft accusations.
    [00:00:53] Josh Hutchinson: This is another very educational episode. We hope you'll take what you learned to heart. Witch hunting is a [00:01:00] global crisis and we all must work together to solve it.
    [00:01:03] Sarah Jack: Welcome advocate and author Wonderful Mkhutche. He is the executive director of Humanist Malawi. He has a master's degree in political science and a bachelor's degree in theology and religious studies. He is a professional editor and biographer and has published several books on politics and religion in Malawi.
    [00:01:21] Sarah Jack: What would you like the listeners to know about your background, expertise, and profession?
    [00:01:21] Wonderful Mkhutche: Yeah. Thank you for hosting me. My name is Wonderful Mkhutche. I work as the the executive director of Humanist Malawi. It's the only humanist organization in Malawi. About my background, I have a master's degree in political science and then a bachelor's degree in theology and religious studies. Um I've written several books on politics and religion in Malawi. So these are short essays. We are talking about [00:02:00] humanism. Issues to do with how we can relate about politics and the religion in the context of the Malawian society. Basing from what I have written in the book, I am also a humanist. Of course, I have over two decades history of me being a religious person, a Christian, uh, but. been engaged a lot of humanistic work here in
    [00:02:21] Wonderful Mkhutche: I had over two decades bang in religion. but then around seven to eight years ago, that's when I made the decision to leave the church, our religion into humanism. I left after some years of debates of certain things about religion and then I wasn't dissatisfied from my own conclusions.
    [00:02:40] Wonderful Mkhutche: So I chose to be a humanist, and since then I've been involved in several ways about humanism in Malawi, including the fight against witchcraft, against the violence. Do with the state and religion, how as a Malawian society, again we use the [00:03:00] humanism to to progress ourselves. So these are some of the contextual debates that I do engage with as a humanist.
    [00:03:09] Josh Hutchinson: What do we need to know about the country of Malawi?
    [00:03:14] Wonderful Mkhutche: Yeah. Malawi is a former British colony. We became independent in July 1964. And from then we have had successive leadership. The first president was the Dr. Hastings Kamuzu Banda, who was the, a strict Christian himself. And in those 30 years when he was in power the country was much tilted towards the the religious the religious path, especially the Christian one. And then after him we had the Dr. Bakili Muluzi, a Muslim, uh, but then even though he was a Muslim, he didn't choose that position to to advance Islam in Malawi. He came into power to democracy. So he tried all he could [00:04:00] do to make sure that the country is indeed following the liberal democracy principles.
    [00:04:05] Wonderful Mkhutche: Another thing that we have to know about Malawi is it is one of the most highly religious countries in the world. Close to 90 percent of the population consider themselves to be religious, and in that percentage close to 80% percent Christians, dominated mostly by the Catholics. And around the 15% Muslims and the others small religions like Buddhism, Hinduism.
    [00:04:32] Wonderful Mkhutche: In terms of the economy it is one of the most poorest countries in the world. Our economy is based on agriculture, which is still at the subsistence level. So you can have an idea that the economy is based on agriculture and then it is not mechanized. To that extent, most people living in poverty. We can say close to 80% [00:05:00] of the population is living in poverty. And due to that, that has given a lot of, uh, fertile ground for religion, especially the Pentecostal type of religion, which is promising people shortcuts like witches. These context switches have given rise to this issue it comes to the belief in witchcraft.
    [00:05:25] Wonderful Mkhutche: Last year we had a survey that was done by Afrobarometer, and it established that over 74 percent of the Malawian population believe in the existence of witchcraft. And it's just surprising to see that most people use religion in order to ascertain that indeed witchcraft uh, exists because the Bible says it uh, so the Bible cannot lie. So these are uh, the challenges that we we face, because when an issue to do with [00:06:00] witchcraft has happened, it is hard to convince people that witchcraft doesn't exist, because you are basically a witch trying to fight against the Bible, a book that they consider infallible.
    [00:06:12] Sarah Jack: What is witchcraft in Malawi?
    [00:06:16] Wonderful Mkhutche: Of course it has different levels. The one which is popular in a mythical way is the one people believe that some people during the night they ride brooms. And they go to different places like maybe South Africa or even some people say they do even reach as far as the America. Just within seconds they start off from here and then they go to these far places.
    [00:06:46] Wonderful Mkhutche: And again, people say the witches do meet at the graveyard, where they eat human bodies. But of course this version of witchcraft is not as popular as it used to be but the one that is popular is people going to make witch doctors, and then instructing them to do concoctions in order to order somebody's life. For example they want someone to be dead, so they would ask a
    [00:06:59] Wonderful Mkhutche: the [00:07:00] most popular version of witchcraft is the one that people say one can go to a witch doctor and then ask them to do certain concoctions in order to alter somebody's life. For example, if someone wants to be dead, they will not come to me physically. They will simply go to a witch doctor instruct him what they want, and the witch doctor's going to mix whatever he has there. And while I'm here, I may simply witness something strange maybe just falling to the ground or a strange hammer just hitting my head, or If I have a business and it is prospering, that person can just tell the witch doctor will to make sure that my business should not be working or even my marriage or even my work. So yeah, in general for most people, they think that witchcraft is when you are using these traditional concoctions [00:08:00] to alter somebody's life.
    [00:08:02] Josh Hutchinson: In your TED talk, you talked about a question you used to ask as a younger person, ' what evidence is there that witchcraft exists?'
    [00:08:15] Wonderful Mkhutche: That's one of the questions that I used to have even when I was young. And that question came back when I was trying to discuss issues of religion before I left. That yes we do believe in witchcraft, but where's the evidence? What, You are simply surrounded with the society that is telling you, everyone in the society is telling you about witchcraft. Like for example, in my own story, I heard about witchcraft from my uncles, from my cousins. They would simply tell stories about what is happening in the village concerning witchcraft.
    [00:08:50] Wonderful Mkhutche: So those stories, they act like the evidence. You grow up around the those narratives, and then you conclude that witchcraft is there. [00:09:00] And then, while after listening to those stories, you can spend maybe 10 to 15 years or even 20 years without even, uh, witnessing something that is close to the witchcraft description in your life.
    [00:09:12] Wonderful Mkhutche: And then for me, I started wondering that I believe in witchcraft. But then where's the evidence? fRom that time, I remember engaging with people on the social media, witchcraft and the, they, we are not providing convincing responses. What happens is when you challenge the belief in witchcraft people simply try to threaten you to say something's going to happen to you and all that. If you are someone who is not mentally strong, you easily fall in. But for me, it was a moment where I was asking these tough questions, and people threatened me to say, 'something's going to happen to you, you are going to see and all that.'
    [00:09:54] Wonderful Mkhutche: This is close to 10 years ago, and for the past 10 years, I haven't seen [00:10:00] anything that these people. They keep on talking up to this very day. So in short, there's no evidence of witchcraft. What people consider to be evidence is just the mental narratives that they have. For example, if someone has died suddenly, maybe it could be because of hypertension and all that. The conclusion that some or most people are going to make now is that It was a witchcraft hammer that was sent to that person.
    [00:10:35] Wonderful Mkhutche: So for them that is enough evidence because how can a person simply die just like that? Because if a death has happened, then there must be a certain cause. So if we don't know that cause, then it should be witchcraft. But for a person like me, when such an event has happened, I don't use the witchcraft narratives to come to the [00:11:00] conclusion. What I would do is simply to ask questions. Maybe what sickness was the the person suffering from? What were the circumstances around the death? So from that information you simply make a conclusion that whenever people do not have enough information about an issue, they run to use witchcraft in order to answer that question.
    [00:11:24] Wonderful Mkhutche: But when you have abandoned that idea and you then begin to doubt that maybe it wasn't, when people have been given the information a about certain, a certain strange event that has happened. You start that they start now doubting their own narratives. And this is a challenge in this country because as already said most people are in poverty and that the information on knowledge that they need to have maybe about health conditions, they do not have. When something strange has [00:12:00] happened, they simply use the witchcraft to answer that. But for a person like me, I look into an issue from all angles. I ask questions that people are not answering. So after that information has been given, you start doubting if the witchcraft is indeed there.
    [00:12:20] Wonderful Mkhutche: But from my experience for the past years, I can conclude a hundred percent that the belief only exists when people do not have enough information or knowledge about a certain event in their lives.
    [00:12:34] Sarah Jack: I thought it was interesting when you mentioned that the, it was, there was even fear around questioning the evidence or questioning witchcraft may not be true. That's the first harmful practice around accusations is not wanting people to question it because it could bring
    [00:12:57] Wonderful Mkhutche: Yeah. Witchcraft is shielded in me [00:13:00] secrecy, uh, in a darkness. The narrative of witchcraft that we have here is it happens only during the night. That is when the the witches or the wizards meet at the graveyard or wherever they meet, and then they do anything that they want to do.
    [00:13:17] Wonderful Mkhutche: So that idea alone simply tells it that you do not have to question the issues that are happening during the night. So if you come out and then start saying witchcraft doesn't exist, and all that, then that's a dark world. And if you do that, then something's going to happen to you. And it is the fears that we are given from an early age. People grow around these fears into their adulthood. So whenever they hear someone trying to question these issues, they are afraid that something is [00:14:00] going to happen to that person, or if they are connected to that person in any kind of way, if something happens to that person, then it may also reach to them.
    [00:14:09] Wonderful Mkhutche: That's the the level of the situation that we have. But as already said before, me in the past 10 years, when I have, I started questioning these things, nothing has happened to me, even though there have been those kind of accidents.
    [00:14:29] Sarah Jack: And I heard you just talk about night and darkness being a big element of this. That really made me think about some of the historic witch hunting that happened in other countries earlier in history where there might not have been a lot of light available at night. Is Malawi a very dark place at night for lack of lights? I wondered if that is part of it, because I know [00:15:00] that did play into some of the fear here in the American colonies.
    [00:15:06] Wonderful Mkhutche: But in the context, it is not as prominent as to that extent. Yes, of course, we do not have adequate elec electricity connectivity here, because it's only 18% of the country that is connected to the national grid. Most parts of the country dark during the night. But I think associated witchcraft to do the night or darkness is just the part of the human history. It may also happen in countries where they do have enough electricity and all that. And that even extends to to animals that usually active during the night, like the owls. People associated them with the witchcraft a lot. If the an owl comes at your house, people will simply conclude that something bad is going to happen in that house.
    [00:15:59] Wonderful Mkhutche: [00:16:00] And this is a belief most people have in this country. So you can see, an owl is just an innocent animal uh, that naturally is active during the night. But simply because of that, people associate it with the witchcraft. Or even talking of animals like the hyena. They are usually active during the night. So when people are going to the witch doctors, they want to do their concoctions, it's mostly the hyena that is used for for their for their medicine. So you can see whatever happens during the night is associated with the uh, sca.
    [00:16:31] Josh Hutchinson: And how did you come to get involved in the witch hunting at anti witch hunting advocacy?
    [00:16:39] Wonderful Mkhutche: I still remember clearly the issue that's brought me into this. After a few years of questioning the existence of witchcraft, something happened in general in 2016 in a place district called Neno. It's also in southern Malawi. It's one of the. high. And usually, uh, This is one of the [00:17:00] hottest spots when it comes to the belief in witchcraft. So in January 2016, four grannies from the same family were killed by the grandchildren of that very same family, uh, because they accused them that they were responsible for the death of one of the young family members.
    [00:17:21] Wonderful Mkhutche: So these young family members went, and they gathered these four grannies, made them sit somewhere in the village, and they took panga knives, stones, sticks. They beat them to death, four of them. The issue was reported in the media. People were shocked as the how could do something as a terrible that happened to them.
    [00:17:47] Wonderful Mkhutche: So when I saw that I remember going to a certain gentleman called Georgie Tidwell. By then he was famously involved in uh, uh, uh, uh, anti-witchcraft belief and issues, so I [00:18:00] went there and I told him that for the past three years, I have been doubting the existence of witchcraft, but I feel that doubt is not enough. Looking at what has happened in Inenu, I wish I can get involved in this, these issues in one way or another. So by then he was concluding a project.
    [00:18:24] Wonderful Mkhutche: In this project he was freeing people who were in prisons across the country that were in prison because they were suspected to be witches. Not that the laws of this country do imprison people when they are said to be witches. No. Actually, the law that we have currently says that witchcraft doesn't exist, and it is against the law to accuse anyone of witchcraft, but what happens is when people are accused in their communities, uh, their communities do not want them to be around. And we do not have elderly homes [00:19:00] or good social services where they can go for them to live.
    [00:19:04] Wonderful Mkhutche: So what happens is the police simply comes to the communities to get them and keep them in prisons, because that is where they can be. But it is not a good situation because most of those who are accused the elderly. And among the elderly, it is mostly women. Imagine a woman who is 80 years old, is not wanted by the community, who cannot be anywhere else, and then they are being kept in a prison. So this was the project that George Tidwell was the uh, uh, by then the organization was called the Association for Secular Humanism. So he tried to work with the government to make sure that these people are out of prisons and that they are taken back into their communities, and it was one of the most successful projects by them.
    [00:19:51] Wonderful Mkhutche: So I offered myself. The project was going into completion. So I promised him that what I know is [00:20:00] writing, so I will use my writing knowledge or skills to make sure that I talk about these issues. And since that time from around 2015, 2016, I have been doing that to this day. I do write on the issues, and I also do talk about the issues in the media houses.
    [00:20:22] Wonderful Mkhutche: SInce it is the mostly only me who is public about these issues, I have a good relationship with the the media here and they are doing a good job. Whenever something related to the to witchcraft-based violence has happened, they do contact me for a comment, and that provides a platform where we are trying to civic educate the masses on issues to do with the the beliefs.
    [00:20:49] Sarah Jack: What is the status of accused being in prison today?
    [00:20:53] Wonderful Mkhutche: To this day, there's no one who is in prison because they were accused of witchcraft.[00:21:00] The general public, the attitude seems to have changed when we are looking at how it was in 2015, uh, to now. So what happens is whenever an issue has happened and that the community doesn't want that individual, temporarily they are taken to the police cells, uh, where they are kept in order to look for a lasting solution.
    [00:21:21] Wonderful Mkhutche: So it is the police and the also other organizations, including us, who are involved in the making sure that we negotiate with the community, especially through the tradition of our leaders, to talk the issues with the family and to make sure that the person goes back to the community. But of course it is still a threat because if the community thinks that someone is a witch, it's an idea that they have in their minds. They may change it simply because the police have negotiated the issue, but it still remains there. So anything can happen to that [00:22:00] person. To this extent, I have two examples.
    [00:22:03] Wonderful Mkhutche: Last year, a similar thing happened in the Muranji. It is a district. Two grannies from one family were taken to to be beaten to death, because they were thought to be behind the death of a certain young family member. The good thing is the police the, uh, rushed to to the scene. They managed to save these two grannies. They were taken to the police cell for around two weeks. So one of the police officers contacted us. We tried to gather little things that we had, bags of maize, soap and the, anything as basic as possible for their own welfare.
    [00:22:44] Wonderful Mkhutche: So we went there with the police, we met the two grannies. After we came back, I remember one of the police officers called me and said that the people in the community, they do not want to see you [00:23:00] again visiting those two grannies. Because if you visit them, you are giving them food items, it will encourage them to bewitch even more community members. So I simply wanted to to take home the point that even though they are back in the community, but they are, their lives are not as safe as they should be.
    [00:23:20] Wonderful Mkhutche: Just two months ago, something similar happened in the same Neno district. Which I said earlier on that it is one of the hot spots for this belief. Young family members wanted to beat their grandfather, who is around 80 years old. They accused them to be behind the death of another young family member. The good thing is that he was rescued and he was taken to to a police station for a week, and after the media reported that issue, he was lucky to be taken into an elderly home. In Livongo. That elderly home is [00:24:00] being run by a certain young lady. All the So the first of this kind were All the people being looked after. So after that situation she volunteered to take that old man into the home. And just a few weeks ago I was there by we donated a few items. To the elderly home, and I happened to meet that old man from Neno. So he narrated his audio. He was saying that he simply accepted it that he was about to be killed only to be saved. I went there, I met him he narrated his audio. So he said he simply accepted me that it was called to be, wanted to be served. And he doesn't think that he will go back to his own home anytime soon. And I remember when I was leaving, he pleaded with me that we should go to his village to talk to the community to convince them about the issues of witchcraft. Because from his experience, he doesn't want anything like that to happen to anyone else.
    [00:24:56] Sarah Jack: Yes. I was wondering you had mentioned earlier [00:25:00] in the conversation that individuals will go and ask for a witchcraft concoction. Are those people, do they get accused, if you go and ask for a concoction, or are the accused only folks that are not actually going to natural doctor?
    [00:25:23] Wonderful Mkhutche: Yeah. For those individuals who go to the witch doctors, they do it in secret. You don't even know that someone went to a witch doctor to ask people for concoctions. It's a secret meeting between them and the witch doctor. What happens is when they meet there they say the witch doctor produces a TV screen that shows whatever, uh, an accused person wanted to do to other people, and when that person goes back to the community that is when they start spreading that rumor that they visited the witch doctor and the witch doctor told them that another individual is the one who is behind Thanks. Thanks. certain things that have been happening in the family or the community. It's not something that people do highly necessarily that they visited a witch doctor. Actually when certain things have happened in a family, it is the general agreement that we have to go to the witch doctor.
    [00:25:34] Wonderful Mkhutche: So it's it's public information in sometimes that they go there and they, when they are back, they report whatever was told to them. But in some instances, it is private, them and the witch doctor. Only that after that meeting, whatever has transpired between the two is not kept in secret as well. It is brought to the public, whatever the witch doctor said. That it's,
    [00:25:34] Wonderful Mkhutche: The meetings between people and the witch doctor, sometimes they happen in secret. People don't announce that they're going there. But whatever transpires there is communicated to everyone in the family or the community that I went to the witch doctor, and the witch doctor told me this and that. But sometimes it's an open secret where if something happening in a family. the family agrees to go to the [00:26:00] witch doctor. So they go there as a family, and then whatever they are told, uh, they come to it even to the community. So these meetings are sometimes while everyone is knowing.
    [00:26:11] Josh Hutchinson: How can listeners support you in your advocacy?
    [00:26:16] Wonderful Mkhutche: Yeah For us to be effective, we do need resources. In terms of money and resources. Of course, the challenge of the belief as it comes from several different angles. The first one I have talked about the witch doctors, but now we also have another emerging challenge with the Pentecostal, Christian Pentecostal preachers. They are using religion to act as the uh, witch so Whenever people are meeting misfortunes, they go there to the to the preachers or the prophets, they that's what they call themselves. So the prophets what they brought about is called the prophecies, so they will simply say you are meeting these misfortunes because a certain aunt in your family went to a witch doctor and the she doesn't want to see you prospering. That's one of the [00:27:00] major issues.
    [00:27:01] Wonderful Mkhutche: So the people who visit the witch doctors are mostly those in the rural areas. And people who mostly visit the prophets, most of those in the the urban areas. You can see how wide the challenge is. If I Come out and then start saying, a witch doctor doesn't exist, I'm not only creating a wall with the witch doctors, no, but even with the prophets themselves.
    [00:27:29] Wonderful Mkhutche: So they use the religion in order to threaten me, to say I shouldn't be talking about those, so they talk about, God is going to curse me. Sometimes they even do phone calls or even send me just anonymous texts to say, I should stop doing about that. One day God is going to visit you and do this and that, so it's a deep rooted problem, which needs serious kind of advocacy [00:28:00] in the media to talk about the issues, and the resources will also be needed to go to places where the an an issue has happened, because most of what happens now is due to lack of resources.
    [00:28:13] Wonderful Mkhutche: An issue may happen. In the Moorland, for example. Uh, What we only do is to make sure we alert the police when that issue has happened. So if we are able to work with the community to talk to them about witchcraft issues, I'm sure a huge difference. But for now, we are simply operating from from afar, and it's not as effective. Of course, We also targeted the youth, because for the older people they already made their conclusions about witchcraft but the youth, they present a certain interesting perspective about the issues. They may believe in the issues of a witchcraft but they them. And I have seen this with my own eyes, and the experience. When you engage the youth in this matters, they are ready to give it a doubt about the [00:29:00] existence of witchcraft, because I think with the modern age, they're they have new information, the lack of it in the past is not the same as today.
    [00:29:09] Wonderful Mkhutche: So to target the youth, we do say events. Like this weekend we'll be at the University of Malawi, where students are going to be debating the issues of in the country. So using that to change that people have. So these are some of the advocacy areas that we need using the media to visit work with the police, traditional leadership to make sure we directly engage with the the communities.
    [00:29:35] Sarah Jack: I have a question. Wonderful. When it comes to any campaigns or organizations or advocates that are working on general violence against women and children in Malawi, does that include violence from witchcraft accusations? Is that recognized as part of the discussion?
    [00:29:55] Wonderful Mkhutche: Actually I have always been talking with the human rights [00:30:00] organizations that are working in the gender area. When it comes to witchcraft based violence it doesn't come out in organizations that are doing with the women's rights issues. Actually, that's one of the major talking points that I have whenever I meet an organization that is into promoting gender or women's rights. We say yes we may need the women to get involved economically or in agriculture, but then there's also this issue of that. So it doesn't come out in as far as I understand the Malawian con context.
    [00:30:36] Wonderful Mkhutche: When I talk to the organizations, they do admit that indeed they overlook the issue. In as far as the Malawian context is concerned, it is only Humanist Malawi, which is in the forefront talking about witchcraft.
    [00:30:50] Wonderful Mkhutche: That's look after the welfare of the elderly. And other organizations, of course, they do get involved in the the witchcraft based violence. But the challenging part is that for them their approach [00:31:00] is saying that witchcraft does exist. They are simply dealing away with the violence and not the belief, even though we look at them as colleagues, but this is a major point of difference, because you cannot do away with the belief, if you still recognize witchcraft does exist.
    [00:31:24] Wonderful Mkhutche: Actually about a year ago, there was a huge concern because the the we have an organisation called the Malawi Law Commission, which is mandated to propose that the Common Law Commission was proposing that we have to change the way as a rats to do things. Thank you. That if we then are going to worsen the situation, the Mai Law Commission suggested change in the witchcraft law. The present law was the established. So now,
    [00:31:24] Sarah Jack: If you want to talk about the Witchcraft Act.
    [00:31:24] Wonderful Mkhutche: The currently, witchcraft law that we have was maybe 1911 by the British colonial government. So the law, as I said it, say it says, wish anyone, uh, who. Has broken the law and the is unanswerable, but the Malawi Law Commission last year suggested for us to change the existence of witchcraft involved in all advocacy areas that we could,
    [00:31:24] Wonderful Mkhutche: , The current witchcraft law says that witchcraft doesn't exist, and anyone who accuses another that they are practicing witchcraft or they are a witch, they are answerable to the law. So this law was, established by the British Colonial government in 1911. But last year the Malawi Law Commission suggested a change in this law. So they wanted the law to change from saying witchcraft doesn't exist to start saying witchcraft exists. So as a Humanist Malawi, we. [00:32:00] we were involved in all advocacy in the media to say that if we change the law to start recognizing the existence of a witchcraft, then we are going to take the witchcraft based violence to its worst. Because for now people have an excuse to say if the law says witchcraft is there then indeed we do have witches among us. That is going to be used for them to victimize other people. It is only Humanist Malawi that was saying that we do not have to change the law, while all other organizations are saying that we have to to change the law, in order to save the situation about witchcraft based violence.
    [00:32:41] Wonderful Mkhutche: So that's one of the uh, major point of differences. For the other organizations, we do recognize their good work, but in terms of the witchcraft law, I feel that we still have to advocate for the law not to change, because if it changes, then it's going to put [00:33:00] so many people's lives at risk of accusation.
    [00:33:04] Sarah Jack: Yes. Because one of the things that I was thinking about when you were talking about the prophets and the witch doctors, let's, the situation, there's the belief of the witchcraft is there, but they need to, I apologize if you guys just heard a, Notification, that doesn't usually happen. they need to not advocate for the violence, and it doesn't seem like there's a distinction there, that if the witchcraft is real, then they have to do the hunt, is what it sounds like. Where, you know,
    [00:33:24] Wonderful Mkhutche: yeah. Yeah Of course they, for the witch doctors and for the prophets, they do not directly advocate for the violence. But for them simply to tell someone that your misfortunes are because of this person in your family, that's enough to advocate for the violence. Because what else do we expect that person to do when they go back to the family or the community? And yeah. A month ago, we had this similar incident that I'm talking about happening. Family members destroyed property, they fought each other simply [00:34:00] because the prophet had you told them that their misfortunes are due to a certain family member? And unfortunately these prophets are not answerable. I haven't heard anything to do with the maybe witch doctor or a prophet being arrested or answerable simply because they passed that message on an individual. What the law or the law enforcers, they simply focus on the violence that has happened. People are just arrested because of destruction of property or even destruction of a life. But the accusation part, I haven't heard the law touching that part. So it simply confirms that even the law enforcers, they believe that witchcraft is there, but then they simply rush to the situation in order to deal with the destruction of property and the life and not the accusation [00:35:00] itself.
    [00:35:01] Sarah Jack: Thank you so much. Do you have any last words or comments that you would like to make? That's
    [00:35:08] Wonderful Mkhutche: Yeah, for my last word, I will simply use this opportunity to say that there's a lot that needs to be done in order for us to change the situation. As a Humanist Malawi, it's almost on a daily basis that an incident to do with witchcraft based violence is reported. Of course, some issues do not involve the violence. Some people, some issues involve the violence. But due to lack of resources, we simply operate from afar. From our experience, I feel if we continue doing the interventions by and by to change. Of course, it's going to take a long time. But what we have to [00:36:00] do now convince, uh, people in, the. The circle of in order for them to directly get involved. Because we haven't had for example, an issue had happened, we haven't had even the president talking about it, even the ministers talking about it. They run away from the issue because if they come out in the public to criticize the violence or even say that witchcraft doesn't exist, then they are going to lose their votes, so because of that, they ran away from talking about the issues, but with the good advocacy as we are doing, as what we will be doing when we get enough resources, I believe the message going to reach these people, uh, for them to also involved in one way or another, in order to fasten the change that we are looking for.
    [00:36:48] Sarah Jack: And now for a minute with Mary.
    [00:36:50] Mary-Louise Bingham: Dr. Dinesh Mishra, an ophthalmologist by trade and an advocate to end witch hunts. Dr. Mishra has helped [00:37:00] hundreds of women who were brutally beaten and ostracized by their communities after being accused as dayans, the local term for witchcraft used in Chhattisgarh, India. Dr. Mishra has self funded services for women to be rehabilitated into society by personally offering them financial and legal assistance, as well as helping them find employment, particularly in the health field. These actions helped empower the women to move forward in their lives with confidence. Thank you, Dr. Mishra, for this and the many other ways you continue to advocate to help women in need.
    [00:37:41] Mary-Louise Bingham: Please follow Dr. Mishra on Facebook. You will find he updates his page on a regular basis. Thank you.
    [00:37:49] Sarah Jack: Thank you, Mary.
    [00:37:51] Josh Hutchinson: Now here's Sarah with End Witch Hunts News.
    [00:37:54] Sarah Jack: End Witch Hunts urges collective action to end witch hunting practices worldwide. [00:38:00] A witch hunt can happen in any community. At End Witch Hunts, we're dedicated to amplifying the voices of witch hunt victims and educators. Won't you join us? It is up to all of us to speak up about modern efforts to end witchcraft accusation violence.
    [00:38:15] Sarah Jack: A witch hunt can happen in any community. Listen to, talk about, and use your influence to share our advocacy episodes and the advocate websites. It's an easy thing to do. Witchcraft accusations remain destructive and common. The world is filled with metaphorical and literal witch hunts rooted in unfounded fear of others, leading to crimes against innocent individuals every day.
    [00:38:40] Sarah Jack: You are the key to raising awareness, building social momentum against such violence, and disseminating education about historical, contemporary, and ongoing witch hunting. A witch hunt can happen in any community. Purposely take up for the vulnerable. Call on others to do the same. Doubt the fear, not the [00:39:00] humans.
    [00:39:00] Sarah Jack: It's easy to be a part of the Massachusetts Witch Hunt Justice Project. Sign and share the exoneration petition at change.org/witchtrials. Massachusetts residents, engage your representatives, and if you're a voting member of the Massachusetts General Court, lead or collaborate on the amendment effort to secure formal apologies for the accused witches of Massachusetts.
    [00:39:23] Sarah Jack: Witch hunt memorials and commemorations now take many forms and serve as enduring, tangible reminders. On September 16th, 2023 in North Pownal, Vermont, the community dedicated the Legends and Lore Witch Trial Marker to accused witch Margaret Krieger. The event, made possible by Vermont Folklife Center and William C. Pomeroy Foundation, had support from Bennington Museum and Pownall Historical Society.
    [00:39:47] Sarah Jack: Explore Margaret Krieger's history at Bennington Museum's Haunted Vermont Exhibit until the end of this year. The display features the Witch Trial, Vampires, Bennington Triangle, and author Shirley Jackson, [00:40:00] the renowned horror writer, and her first edition books and belongings, including a self playing music box and the table where she wrote her last novel.
    [00:40:09] Sarah Jack: We are thrilled to announce that on the December 28th Thou Shalt Not Suffer episode, you will hear from Jamie Franklin, the esteemed curator of the Haunted Vermont Exhibit at Bennington Museum. He was a vital member of the research team securing the new memorial marker for Margaret Krieger. Jamie promises a delightful discourse on the museum, Vermont's history, and the intriguing witch trial lore of Pownal. The December 28th episode will be the final episode release for the year, but also the final episode released for Thou Shalt Not Suffer: The Witch Trial Podcast, because Thou Shalt Not Suffer becomes Witch Hunt, January 1st.
    [00:40:43] Sarah Jack: Thank you for supporting our podcast. Your financial contribution empowers our education and advocacy efforts. During this holiday season, include End Witch Hunts in your charitable gifts. We thank you. Visit endwitchhunts.org to contribute and help bring an end to the dark history of witch hunting [00:41:00] practices.
    [00:41:01] Josh Hutchinson: Thank you, Sarah.
    [00:41:02] Sarah Jack: You're welcome.
    [00:41:04] Josh Hutchinson: And thank you for listening to Thou Shalt Not Suffer: The Witch Trial Podcast.
    [00:41:09] Sarah Jack: Join us next week.
    [00:41:11] Josh Hutchinson: Subscribe wherever you get podcasts
    [00:41:14] Sarah Jack: Visit thoushaltnotsuffer.com.
    [00:41:17] Josh Hutchinson: And remember to tell all your friends our name is changing to Witch Hunt on January 1st.
    [00:41:23] Sarah Jack: Support our efforts to end witch hunts. Visit endwitchhunts.org to learn more.
    [00:41:28] Josh Hutchinson: Have a great today and a beautiful tomorrow.
  • Dr. Leo Igwe on the Deadly Witch-Hunts of the 21st Century

    https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/2045153.rss

    Show Notes

    Dr. Leo Igwe, activist and Director of the Advocacy for Alleged Witches gives a gripping update about the witch hunt crisis in Nigeria and other African Nations. Leo teaches us the historical and societal patterns and parallels of witch hunts past with modern day witchcraft accusations. We discuss the urgency of immediate interventions and how the landmark witch trial exenteration legislation in Connecticut resonates to the rest of the world. This episode is a call for worldwide collective action against witch fear, a call to create safe communities for the vulnerable citizens in our world communities and a plea for you to spread the word with transformative conversations using your social reach.

    Support Us! Shop Our Book Shop

    Advocacy for Alleged Witches, Nigeria

    Stop Sorcery Violence in PNG

    Buy Witches and Witch-Hunts: A Global History, By Wolfgang Behringer

    Write a Stratford, CT Town Council MemberResolution Concerning Certain Witchcraft Convictions in Colonial Connecticut

    Purchase a Witch Trial White Rose Memorial Button

    Support Us! Sign up as a Super Listener!

    End Witch Hunts Movement 

    Thou Shalt Not Suffer Podcast Book Store

    Support Us! Buy Witch Trial Merch!

    Support Us! Buy Podcast Merch!

    Join us on Discord to share your ideas and feedback.

    Fact Sheet for Connecticut Witch Trial History

    Website

    Twitter

    Facebook

    Instagram

    Pinterest

    LinkedIn

    YouTube

    TikTok

    Discord

    Buzzsprout

    Mailchimp

    Donate

    Transcript

    [00:00:20] Josh Hutchinson: Welcome to Thou Shalt Not Suffer: The Witch Trial Podcast. I'm Josh Hutchinson.
    [00:00:26] Sarah Jack: And I'm Sarah Jack.
    [00:00:29] Josh Hutchinson: We recently got to spend a week with today's guest.
    [00:00:33] Sarah Jack: We toured historic witch trial locations in Massachusetts and Connecticut.
    [00:00:37] Josh Hutchinson: And he gave five talks in five days about modern witch hunts.
    [00:00:43] Sarah Jack: We had a wonderful time together in person. Be sure to check our social media for pictures.
    [00:00:48] Josh Hutchinson: And now Dr. Leo Igwe joins us from Morocco for an important episode about 21st century witch hunting.
    [00:00:57] Sarah Jack: We learn more about the current situation.
    [00:01:00] Josh Hutchinson: And how past and present witch hunts are connected.
    [00:01:03] Sarah Jack: Listen to the questions he asks us, the questions he's asking you.
    [00:01:08] Josh Hutchinson: Stay tuned to learn how you can help end the witch-hunt crisis.
    [00:01:12] Sarah Jack: Dr. Leo Igwe is director of Advocacy for Alleged Witches. He works tirelessly to end witch-hunting in the modern world. His organization supports the victims and works with authorities to respond to attacks on people accused of witchcraft. Listen carefully to what he is telling us about the situation and how we can help end the crisis by taking action together. 
    [00:01:32] Josh Hutchinson: Thank you so much for joining us today. We know you're super busy.
    [00:01:37] Leo Igwe: And thank you for having me as usual. And this is a special edition, I'm sure, cause this is a first edition we're having since the resolution passed.
    [00:01:45] Sarah Jack: So much has passed since we saw each other, since we talked, especially since the first time we recorded. This is exciting and special conversation.
    [00:01:56] Leo Igwe: That was before of course I visited and I was able to, I went to the Salem Witch Museum and all the memorials there and all that. First of all, I want to say congratulations to you all for what you've done and the efforts you've made, and that nothing has connected, nothing has really resonated with what I've been doing here than what you just achieved in Connecticut and generally what you are trying to do in terms of remembering these people and honoring them as victims.
    What applies at the moment is like people want to forget them. There's this kind of silence, there's this thing that, or some people use it for entertainment, or some people use it like the tourist thing. Okay. You take people around, showed people where people were murdered, people were hanged, tortured to death. And of course it's of tourist value. But these are human beings, for goodness sake. Yeah. Let's pause for a moment that these are human beings, and have we really paid the tribute we're supposed to pay? Yeah. Yes. What happened them is part of our history, no doubt about that. Fine. But have we really paid them the tribute, or we just talk about them like as in passing and use them to entertain people, use them to make money and that ends it and all that?
    It was very inspiring coming around and getting to see all that's been going on in terms of honoring the memory of the victims in Connecticut. And like I said, it is part of the goal. What you're doing there, it underlies what I'm trying to do here. Yeah, when people are tortured to death, we shouldn't just push that aside, there's a need to understand what happened, need to make sure that justice is done, yes. So it is that sense of justice. It is that sense that people should focus on the miscarriage of justice that has taken place, instead of trying to talk about it as something that maybe should be used either for entertainment or lectures or to understand how primitive people were in the past. I think that's what resonated. 
    And I'm looking forward to also see how we can continue to use this to educate people. Yeah. And like I said, I noted in my lecture, Americans should not think that witch-hunting is a thing of the past in America, because they tend to be speaking to a very tiny segment of America that belongs to the past, actually, not to the present. Because if we are to look at it today, it is important they translate the resolutions, the memorials into educational programs, enlightenment programs, with the message never again. Yeah. It belongs to our past, but we can have it today, because a lot of people are migrating from different cultures. 
    The demographic tapestry of America is changing every day, and a lot of people are coming from Africa and Asia, and they become American citizens, and they hold these beliefs. So a lot of witchcraft accusations that are going on, but even though one cannot say the extent of the abuse, but it's important that we understand that these things are not much in the past and that honoring the memory of the victims could be a way America could tactfully and strategically position itself to make sure that the right message is sent to anybody who could indulge in such in the present and also in its future.
    So that is on that side. Then on our side here is also, it resonates because for us, of course, I'm going to use it, or we are going to use it to also tell our lawmakers they need to do more. Yes, I was fascinated by the debate on the floor of the Parliament, State Assembly, as the case may be, how the parliamentarians were discussing and articulating this. For many parliamentarians in my own part of the world, they don't care. It, it sounds like something you are coming to disturb them. Yeah. So meanwhile, they should be abreast with this. So if it is something that is going to help us in my own part to begin to lobby the parliamentarians and say, "look at what is going on, look at how the lawmakers took a very great step to honor the memory of these people." But we're not actually talking about that yet. We're not there yet. We're even talking about taking steps to stop it, what is going on now? So that is why what has happened and what you are doing at your end of the world is very important today.
    And again, I will not get tired of saying and repeating it. Whatever happens in America resonates a lot. Yes. And it is important that that leadership that has been missing, yes, because what has been missing, because it has been that silence. Oh, it belongs to the past, and you should be silent about it, even in the present. That shouldn't be the case. Yes. So it is also a message that people should have to break the silence when it comes to these victims and what they go through. And we should not hide it, because I was at the Salem Witch Museum and I saw all these monuments and moldings of people who were being hanged, and I was imagining the real thing. I wasn't even looking at that. I was imagining what happened in real life. And I was imagining myself being in that position. I was asking myself, "what is this?" Okay. And to say that a lot of people are going through such today, it means that we have not done enough, and there should be no sense of complacency anyway.
    And that the memory, the tribute we are paying to the victims in the US, will not be complete until it includes and embraces the efforts to stop this, make sure that what these people suffered 300 years ago, over 300 years ago, thereabout, that people are not suffering this today, and that we should not end it there so that any area is going on, it should be something that we should include even in our lectures, in our education. And there's this idea that, yeah, while we remember those who were tortured, killed, murdered, executed 200 years ago, we should not forget those being tortured and executed today. 
     So doing, we bring this sense of globality. We bring a sense of universality. We bring a sense of connection. Because very often some people pride in saying, "oh yeah, it happens in my own part of the world." No, the world is more interconnected today than the way that the world was when this thing happened, so we cannot continue to use the idea of the world in the past to use it for today, and that we should begin to see this as, in quote, in this holistic form. So that, as we are going about remembering these people and honoring their memory and remember how they were tortured and what happened to them, we should also have somewhere remembering that in Malawi people are still being stoned to death and that elderly women are suffering the same thing, that in Nigeria, people are still tortured, set ablaze, suffering this, made to confess to crime they never committed, some will refuse till the time they get killed. And there are a lot of parallels, there's a lot of common pattern in terms of what people suffered so that this will help us send the message. And I think that this will be very valuable in our efforts to end witch persecution, let's say in Africa and in other places where these atrocities are still taking place.
    [00:09:45] Josh Hutchinson: Thank you so much for that. You mentioned the visit to Salem, and you were able to visit the memorials in Salem and Danvers. What was your experience like there? What were you feeling? What were you thinking about?
    [00:10:03] Leo Igwe: First of all, I was trying to imagine what happened 300 years ago. Yes. And because in the course of my scholarship trying to do the academic thing, the way they explain it is like, is a dead thing. For me, coming to this place is like reliving. It takes me back, and I was like imagining. I was like trying to imagine what transpired, trying to replay it in my mind based on the stories I've heard. Okay. So then I was like, another thing going on in my mind was like, still after 300 years, there are three descendants of these people feeling connected and feeling it as if this happened yesterday. Okay. It was inspiring to me, because I don't think that injustice has an expiration date. Because it happened 300 years ago. It's not, I can still relive it. 
    When I went to the museum, I saw the stone being pressed. That I think is a moment like that of the stone being pressed. I wasn't looking at something that was really turning to me, or I was looking at something that was, I was chilled. There was this kind of, I was stiff with the kind of pain and anger and worry at the barbarity, so I tried to, I reconnected with people ordinarily. Or with something ordinarily, I was meant to think, oh, it happened. When you amidst a lot of Westerners, when they talk about this witch hunting, they make hand like this, as if it's like a fly, oh this thing happened 300 years ago. Okay. 
    But they were human beings, flesh and blood, and they suffered it. And why it was very touching for me was that because I live in a world where people are going through the same thing. So it wasn't like old then, it was like I was seeing the man who was burned, I was seeing the woman who was set ablaze. I was seeing another woman who was being tortured to accept what she did not do. 
     They replayed the trial whereby somebody was acquitted. Then people would scream. Then the somebody was, the person, the same person was eventually convicted, and I recall in Malawi the judges will tell you that they don't want to acquit some people, because when they allow them to go home, they could be killed, so they sentence them to prison. That kind of thing. So all these things were going, emotions were all boiling in me, trying to, first of all, see how though it, how present something that people claim to be, something that happened in the past. That's one. 
    Number two, I was also moved by the fact that the descendants of these people are still there. And I could still see the emotion, because as an academic person, they try to tell you to be detached from things like this. And I'm not studying sticks, I'm not even studying stones or rocks. I'm studying human beings being killed and tortured. I'm studying human beings traumatized and pained and murdered, set ablaze, stoned to death.
     It gave me an opportunity for the first time to really express myself. So, for instance, when we went to that memorial, I think that should be in Salem. Yeah. Where I paid tribute for the first time. I got there so close, and that's the closest I have been in my life. And that's the point I have really openly a little, I broke down, and tears came, because these tears have been there. I weep all the time they give me this news, but I've never had that space to really shed the tears. So it was like letting it out. 
    At the point it came, I was not prepared, but it just came, so I could now connect with these people who ordinarily, like now many of them being stoned, like they send me pictures, a woman being dragged and being stoned, I feel like crying immediately. But sometime you don't cry, start calling the police officers. Start calling, "okay, what are you doing?" Those things. I'm just, I was just pretending. I feel like crying. That's the first thing I wanted to do. But I will not cry. I'll be calling police officers, disturbing them. "Could you get to the venue? Could you make arrest?" And all that. So somehow as I was going, I was not, I had this opportunity to really express, and all that, yes, knowing that this wasn't actually taking place, but bearing in mind that this actually took place. In other words, it's part of our history as human beings. So that was the emotions that was going on in my mind. 
    And again, I was somehow was so happy that circumstances had made it possible for me to connect these histories. Which ordinarily, as an academic person, I should go back to any part in Africa or Nigeria or somewhere and be still be talking about the same people, sending researchers to go and be interviewing the same people, study how they are, how they're feeling, and coming back to classroom to earn money. Very important they are, but that's not my goal. This is a tragic situation. Yes. And it is a humanitarian crisis. I was happy to make these connections, and I'm hoping to use it in trying to help solve the problem, minimize the problem, reduce it, or if possible, bring it to an end.
    [00:15:30] Sarah Jack: Do you wanna talk about the solving part or do you wanna talk more about your experience? Like with looking at the documents, do you want us to ask you a question about looking at the documents or Winthrop or anything?
    [00:15:43] Leo Igwe: I think that one of the things also, I was happy with getting to understand the roles politicians played. That was another issue. Because there's always this idea, how did it end? And of course, they tell you this thing like, as if it's a little story, you know, a flip of paper, pen, they tell, oh, it ended. But this is a tragic situation. Stoning people, torturing them, pressing stone on them, a tragic situation that ended, so the role politicians played, and that's why I said I was very inspired when they told me about John Winthrop, Jr. And there's a need for us to challenge our politicians, yes. And I think, like I did when we made a presentation at the Capitol, I think that there's a need for us to tell the politicians that they're in positions to do better. They're in a position to take decisions that can benefit others, that can save lives. Yes. Let me just put it literally that way.
    And that is why it is important. We will continue to celebrate the memory or the life or the interventions of John Winthrop, Jr. So that we also use that to inspire and get politicians that there's something they can actually do, because oftentimes they tend to be helpless or they think, oh yeah, it's the people. No, there's something they can actually do. So I was very inspired by that, and I may exploring ways of how I can use that story also to inspire politicians here and make them understand that we need more of John Winthrop, Jr. I told Senator Anwar and Representative Jane, I told them that you can be, and they have become that. They just stepped into the shoes. So I want to see how I can take that story beyond Connecticut to other places. And I tell politicians, you can also step into the shoes of Rep. Jane and Senator Anwar. Okay, so it is important. 
    So there are so many aspects of what transpired within my visit. There's a takeaway, and I'm hoping that I'm going to use that. And it must not always be politicians, decision-makers, wherever they find themselves, judges, police officers, they can all step into the shoes, because I know very well that if they are ready to do their work, we can see these atrocities, they will end, or they will drastically reduce. It becomes something like when you do it, it's just like when you committed crime, the whole society goes as a, it's not like the whole society resigns to it or want to sweep that under the carpet. So I was inspired by the role the governor, John Winthrop, Jr., played in ending that, and I hope that I'm gonna use it also as an inspiration or a way to lobby politicians, decision-makers, chiefs, and people in authority that there's actually something they can do.
    Let me tell you what I found inspiring was that somebody was accused, and I think she instructed a person who went down. Was hidden, the person has to hide or, I think either the person's supposed to be punished or something like that. But there was a kind of try to protect the person from either being harmed or being punished. So there was a kind of a story, I don't know the best, I don't know, maybe you can help me with the story again, but try to protect the person.
    So it's not just all about the law and decision-making. You can actually take personal interests and tell the person, "come and hide. Come and hide in my house until the tension comes down." So there's a lot we can do. Yes. Because one of the things that led me to this work is that when you interview people, they try to say, "yeah, what do we, what can we do?"
    The mob, who are the mob? They're human beings, so if people feel that there's little they can, there's a lot they can do. These people can run to your place. You can hide them for some time. I've hidden them. For some you not, you're start engaging the people, and from there you can now save a life. 
    So what I'm trying to say is that going through this and understanding some of these dynamics as to what played out during that era and how it ended, was a great source of inspiration to me and how I hope I'll use that to see how I can rally a lot of people who ordinarily are resigning or who think they cannot do much to do this, to know that they can do something, and from that we could start hoping, seeing an end to this tragic situation.
    [00:20:02] Josh Hutchinson: That was the story of Katherine Harrison from Connecticut. She was convicted of witchcraft. They overturned the conviction. She had to move to New York, and as soon as she got there, people tried to run her out of town. So a man took her in and housed her. And yeah. And you're saying that's symbolic of the type of action that people can take.
    [00:20:30] Leo Igwe: But could take. Yes, could take.
    [00:20:33] Josh Hutchinson: So what kind of action can listeners take if they're hearing this right now?
    [00:20:39] Leo Igwe: Let me tell you the joy of today's world, cause we might all be thinking about all the dangers we face and all the risk we roll and all that. Let me tell the joy of today's world. You can do something from wherever you are. Yes. We are continent apart as we speak now, no, but we are putting together a program. People are going to listen without knowing that we are continents apart. We are hours and hours ahead or behind each other. Okay? So we have in our hands facilities like telephone or our phones and things like that. Now drawing attention, some relevant authorities, and they're there, there are a lot of, there are a lot of organizations, let's say, in different parts of the world that you can use to, "Hey, I don't like this. What is going on?"
    Or provide platforms. Because one of the challenges actually we have, for instance, in my own part of the world is that a lot of people don't even want you to talk about it. A school owner told me, "Leo, come here and teach us critical thinking, but don't come here and tell us that witches don't exist," or something like that. Sometimes there's even this prohibition. They don't want you to talk about it. 
    Okay, so first of all, you can help begin the conversation, yes, somewhere. Now there are a whole lot of Africa-related issues coming up. I know that whenever Africa comes up, there's always this stereotype about it, but we can open these spaces to looking at, okay, it happened there, it's happening here, making some comparison, and also looking at some of also universal trend, misogyny, patriarchy. This is an not peculiar traffic. These are things you find embedded in some of these issues. 
    We can bring a perspective using witchcraft. Others can bring a perspective using some other thing happening. But it is patriarchy, it is misogyny that is being played out, miscarriage of justice, mob violence, these things can take dimensions. What I'm trying to say here is that if you really feel pained by what's going on, and if you really think that we need to end this, we also have to be very creative about what we do, yes, in terms of how we integrate it. Though there's a lot going on in the world today, you can really draw attention to it, so it has so many dimensions. It has a human rights dimension. It has a women rights dimension. It has a children's right dimension. It has a policing dimension. It has a security dimension. It has a rural development dimension, urban development dimensions. But the fact there is that, what I've noticed is that same idea that it doesn't matter, that idea of minimizing it, that idea of trying to wish it away. It has also been institutionalized so that people find it difficult to mainstream this.
    Imagine the situation whereby we have conferences on development in Africa and we have a section and looking at the intersection between development and witch-hunting and witch persecution. But of course, you will still see the people in authority wish them away. Meanwhile, the person who is covering it or trying to brush that aside, people are being persecuted and killed in the person's villages back in Africa.
    So that is the tragedy. The thing there is that we really need to wake up. We need to change our orientation. We really need to admit that this is part of our history and confront it. Because if we don't confront it, it will remain there. And because a lot of people, when I was traveling around and speaking, I keep hearing, "oh, I don't know that this thing is taking place." and, okay, if you don't know, what did you go to school to do? So if you don't dunno, what is your internet do? Because I want to tell you, put this online and put witch hunt in Malawi. You will see terrible pictures, and you know they will not give you the news. Internet will give you images. Okay? So how can you say you know a lot, you don't know that this happening? There's always a way I feel when people tell me, "ah, but I don't know about this." Like, where are you coming from? Where have you been living? Okay.
    The fact is that many people don't know. Yeah, that's a fact. And I don't think that all these people I met in different parts of the US are lying. They're not. They were not lying. Ok. Many people don't know. So the first is that we have to know. What you can do is that, please, you need to know wherever you are. Please go online and try to see what is going on. And from there, begin to figure out what we can do and let that mainstream.
    Like now, I went for a conference, African studies conference in Cologne. Yeah. Because of my travel arrangements, I couldn't submit any abstract on witchcraft persecution and things like that. There was no talk about it at all. Instead, they were talking about, some anthropological African sense of engineering, some very, queer, somewhat interesting kind of thing. All this idea of, oh, Africa has this little sense of engineering. They'll not be going into the villages and thinking about certain things. Nobody will even replicate anywhere. Okay. So you see a lot. Being people overlooking it, people pushing the matter aside, not even for grounding, not even bringing it. And because of that, a lot of people will finish going to the university. They say they don't know. 
    So please what you can, the world needs to know, you can help us from wherever you are to inform the world. Because you know why? If people are informed, and I think they'll be in a better position to take action, so that one of the reasons why people are not taking appropriate action is that people are not informed or being informed. And again, don't wait to be informed. After listening to this, go online, and again, after getting informed, inform another person. From there, it start growing. And action can now come from different angles and different dimensions, because I want to tell you, I want to get partners. I want to get people who can help me. Like now they're burying people alive in Zambia. I cannot be in Zambia. They're burying people are alive in Nigeria. I cannot be in Zambia, I cannot be in Nigeria. They are burying people are alive in Cรดte d'Ivoire and some other places, they told me. I cannot be there. Burkina Faso. So the problem is huge. I need a lot of people to get involved, and people can really get involved when they get informed. So if what you can do is to help us inform the world, you are helping us a lot. If whatever you can do is to help us mainstream it in conferences and programs and discussions and workshops and all that, you are doing a lot, because I think that immediately we win the information war. In other words, get people more informed. I think that it will put us in a better position to address the problem. Cause I don't want to come back, let's say in the next visit America again. I'll be going around in the next two years and people, are still telling me, oh, "I dunno what is going on. I dunno what this is going on." Please, if you're listening to this program, please inform people it is there. So that what I want to be hearing is that, "what can we do? This is my suggestion. Can we get this done here? Can we issue press release? Can we send a letter to this president, this parliament? This is action oriented?" So for now, between now, the next time I'm visiting is information. We have to win the information war. We have to get people informed. Then after that, we now take the action phase. And hopefully that will help us see how we can begin to contain and end these horrific abuses.
    [00:28:00] Sarah Jack: One of the things that it brings to mind is Americans tend to make light of when they figure something out. There's a meme or a joke that goes around that says, I was this many days old when I found out there were witch hunts or I was this many days old when I found out how to open this. It's like like a joke in a sense. And I hope that people start to understand that.
    I don't think that right now Americans are surprised when they learn things about history that they didn't know you. You mentioned people are educated yet there's some significant holes in the education and then it's on the person to fill those holes. And I think we're in a phase as a culture, some of us are, where we're realizing, oh, we have these holes in our understanding to fill. This is something that is greatly impacted by that and other injustices and vulnerable people who suffered because of what was happening and then we don't know about it still. So this, what you're speaking to right here is extremely significant, obviously, to our modern victims, but to helping the citizens of the United States and of the world understand how critical it is that we do know, that we are getting to that next phase where we're taking action and asking which action shall we be taking? Not, oh wow, this is still so surprising. We have to get past the, this is surprising.
    [00:29:41] Leo Igwe: Yeah. We need to, because, we have all the facilities not to. Not be, keep telling us This is surprising again. Yeah. Because it'll not be looked differently as if, okay, you it that this person really doesn't want to take the necessary steps. And that's why I said, there's a need for us to go through, past that phase and understand why we are still using that this is surprise, or this is not, I've not known this, I don't know this, I didn't get to know this. We need to find out a reason for that and address those reasons so that we can make progress, because we just need to make progress in this. 
    And I want to tell you that when I announced this program in 2020, when I announced it, some of the journalists were like, they were thinking that, "oh yeah, this is like a pipedream." So there's this idea that yeah, this program, even if you engage in this, nothing is not going to come out. So it is not something that you should bother about. Yeah. Okay. So the silence has turned to inaction and despair and you other feelings that, so you don't, you, people just don't want to get into it, okay?
    Now, I would like us to see what we can do to overcome that, because that's exactly the mentality. Where will you get the resources for this? Whom are you going to work with? Who will support you? There are so many questions that they ask that border on "why get into this? People have forgotten this, or people don't want to pay attention to this. Why not allow this to continue the way it is?" So we really need to send that message that it is no longer going to be business as usual. And that's exactly what you did in Connecticut. You, you said, the message said, "no, we're going to remember these people. Sorry. These people are this, these people are that." And like the little I know, if I'm wrong, you correct me. The attempt somebody made in the past some years ago did not succeed and these were not succeeded in such way as if they just kept the votes, maybe the successful votes in the past and now added a few more to it. And they now passed the resolution right away.
    What am I trying to say? Let us start very small, because we have a problem. It is clear. We have a problem. Okay. And like I said, the woman murdered by witch hunters in Cross River in southern Nigeria, the daughter lives in the U.S. And from the immigration pattern, the daughter will end up being an American, if not she's American already. They're gonna have children. In other words, the grandchildren are Americans. Okay? This thing is not as distant. And the attitude of I don't know, or it's surprising is bordering on, we're being negligent. We're really failing to do or know or understand or address a problem we should be addressing. And like I said, we can start now, before it becomes something that will now involve human resources and the, and all kinds of issues and all that. It gets more complicated, so what I'm saying there is that it is important that we change our attitude towards this. Yes. 
    And what has happened in Connecticut is that this can be done. All of a sudden people took it seriously, and it resonated with them and it passed. And that we can take that sense of optimism, that sense of the fact that we can really change the attitude, towards other sectors. So that, because you know what I was thinking when I was coming, when I was returning from the United States, I was like thinking the next 50 years, the next hundred years, people may not even remember the individual actors who contributed. People will not ask, oh, were there oppositions? Were there setbacks? Were there people who didn't want to vote? People will be with the questions that, okay, what did you do? You did, you helped something, you helped another memory of this. That's only thing they want. And that's it. So they won't bother. How long did you go, the letters you wrote? How many times? Sarah flew from Denver to Connecticut. Did you come by road to do for this hearing? What did they tell you at the hearing? Some of these tiny bits, which we feel through this, a bit frustrating or something, in the course of this. What happens that, oh, what did you do? You worked together and honored the memory of these people, period. So what I'm trying to say that a hundred years from now or something, people may not ask, "okay, Leo what you're doing? Did you get support from Sarah or Josh or End Witch Hunt organization?" The question is that this thing ended.
    And maybe if properly documented, they will not be reading the tiny bits of how they came together. And so what I'm saying is that we're in the position to do this now. Let's not stop. Let us not allow anything to stop us from leaving a legacy that people will look back tomorrow and draw inspiration from. Yes. So let us not make excuses because the generations coming will blame us. Yeah. They may not blame us individually and all that, but they will look at it as just like we're looking at the people who were pressing stones on human beings who were, we're looking at them and said, ah, yeah, these people, they didn't do well, as they say in Nigeria. That's the way they say it in Nigeria, "these people didn't do well." Okay. You'll say that. Yeah. So we have opportunity to do better. We have opportunity to do some good, and the next generation will be happy. 
    They won't ask, "how did you do it? Did you get the resources from outside or inside? From white or black or yellow or green or in between?" No. They just want to hear that this problem, you have, you did something and it ended it. So what am I trying to say? The world is changing and we have a problem, and we may not know the kind of world that will be coming of less in the next 20, 50 years. It might be world whereby if you said, "oh, because I'm in America, we didn't do this" to stop it in Malawi, they will not, I don't know. They will, should I say pass your memory or cause I know that they will not be happy with you. Okay. 
    So it is important we understand this and look to the future and understand that if we're in a position to stop this, somewhere else, if we're in a position to use what we're doing in one part of the world to help end this in another part of the world, let's do it. You may never know, like I said it, nobody knew that I would ever get connected with what happen in Salem. Nobody. Yes, and this John Winthrop, Jr., I know in his widest imagination, he may not know that there's somebody like me, who looks like me, who might be talking about him today, and I want to let you know that the same thing applies to all of us listening to this. You may never know who might be there tomorrow thinking about this, honoring the efforts we are being made today. So let's make the efforts, if we can. Let's stop this, because we might actually be doing something that might resonate with us, whether we are in the U.S., whether in America or in Africa or in Europe.
    [00:36:32] Josh Hutchinson: Is there more that politicians in the United States and internationally can be doing right now?
    [00:36:40] Leo Igwe: Yes. I wish that they could do more. Yes, because I know that politicians getting them to do things is really hard. But of course, when, when they decide to do it, yes, it gets done at least a good one. As we saw in Connecticut.
    I want them, if they can, to take this resolution a bit further. Yeah, take it beyond the states, because I want us to put this on record. Witch-hunting is not a thing of the past in the United States. Yes, any politician. Because the next thing you're going to hear in the next few years when maybe cases start coming up, "oh, I didn't know. We didn't know this was going on." I'm telling you now. Listen to this program and understand now that witch-hunting is taking place in the US as we speak. And that politicians, they have demanded to help in putting place mechanisms that can save lives, protect the people, and guarantee a better and safer living of people in the communities. And they can do well if they can take this up and use it to send a very clear message, like I said. Yeah, I know they have done it at the state level. If they can take it a bit further, it'll very appreciative, because it'll keep sending the same message which they have sent in Connecticut, which is, "America, this belongs to our past." Yes. And whatever migration ways we get, it belongs to our past. Okay. And that can be a measure that can save America maybe millions or billions of dollars.
    Time to start investigating and start getting into a necessary debate that might border on racism, neocolonialism, and all that, because it might be affecting migrants. So let's have politicians who think ahead, that's a question. So politicians should not just only think back to understand what happened. They should also think ahead and put in place mechanisms that can also make sure that this doesn't repeat or if it is going on, it just fizzles, it just fits away. So they can do more. They can do more. And again, politicians are not operating in islands. 
    I'm attending a conference organized by Interparliamentary Union, IPU. Okay, so parliamentarians are here. Yeah. But they're organizing something on interfaith dialogue, and they're inviting humanists for the first time. So I am still trying to understand what so I don't want to rock the boat on my first invitation. So I'm coming down just to understand the landscape, because I will really bring this issue, but I don't want to bring it and get disinvited, and I'm again representing the humanist association. So I'm trying to understand this. 
    So parliamentarians work together. Politicians work together so they can use their network to also send a message to their colleagues and said, "what is going on? Do you need help? We can help you." So they can use their network to also address the problem. 
    The thing that, like I said, is that there's always this feeling that there's nothing we can do about it. Or even if we do something, it will not be effective. And this has made us to live with a situation, with a problem that we can solve, and this will made us to be ignorant of something we should know about. So there's a need for us to change this attitude. Politicians have to change this attitude. And it is only by changing this attitude, it's only by understanding that today politics is not just local. Politics is also global. And there's a lot we can do by tapping into those global mechanisms and dynamics to address problems like this, which are problems that could, may end up affecting us sometime. Yes. 
    Like I noted in one of my presentations, the migrant communities in the UK have recorded cases of witch-hunting, because many of them came with their churches, and these are witch-hunting churches, witch-exorcising churches. And from there, the whole thing started rolling in and of course the government went into it. They started an, in fact, they started a particular program, all sorts of things. Their metropolitan police, everybody got involved. Like I said, if they had acknowledged this and begin to address it, and all of that, I don't think it would've gotten to that. 
     Let's face the reality as it is, and I think that is how we can begin to address this problem in the 21st century manner. Yes. In a manner that suits this century with all the dynamics playing out today in the world.
    [00:41:42] Sarah Jack: I was wondering what does memorialization for modern victims, what should that look like? What should that be doing?
    [00:41:52] Leo Igwe: Is a question I've asked and of course I'm trying to get an answer first. Now, let me tell you the challenge we have. Like myself, I have not been able even to visit the sites of many of the modern victims, because it's always tense, because people might attack you, because they think you are behind the police officers, they're prosecution. Because when I'm moving police into those places, it becomes very tense. 
    I've not been able actually to go to pay personal tribute to these people to see their gravesite. The closest I have gone is the one I did in the US. So just to let you know how what happened in the US you know how I got connected, because many of those places when they happen, I move in with, I bring in the police, and the place become tense, so we cannot actually go in. In fact, some places, police officers could not go in. It was as bad as that. Not to talk of the person who is responsible for bringing the police officers. So first of all is that we have to create an environment where we can actually memorialize these people. That is the first step.
    Okay. Now doing that sends a message. Okay, because that's exactly one of the things I saw I'm going to be doing anywhere we are able to be sure it'll be safe or won't be able to do something there that when you finish it in the night, they will come and scatter it or destroy it and things like that. We will do it, because it sends a message, a very clear message, but sometimes there'll be resistance.
    Cause a lot of people don't want that message that this person should be honored, that this person, is like when you do it, like in my organization, they say you're encouraging it. Yes, you are supporting it, or you are one of them. Yeah. So many misconceptions will be rolling, in which mind, if you don't manage them very well, it turn to, it'll turn to violence. Memorializing, honoring their memory is something very important because of the messages we send, but we are still yet to get a clear one, because like now most of them, either the cases are in court, people are running away. If you come around there, you're a stranger, people run away, or people might harm you, or waylay you on the roads, attack you or kill you or things like that. So it is always very dangerous. 
    So it's something that we have to allow some time before we can begin that process. I'm also looking at something like having maybe a Memorial Day, something like that, whereby we could just meet in the city and invite family members. Okay. To come around and we talk about the people that passed away and what they're doing. So I'm thinking, like I said, it is still something I'm struggling to do. For now what is very likely is having something like a day or an event where we remember them. 
    Last year, we tried doing something like that, but we didn't call it memorial. We call it honoring our heroes. A lot of people, whistleblowers, people who tell us, who draw our attention to that. So we gave them a kind of an award, just incentivize so that people, when these things are happening, they'll be able to either to inform us or tell us. So that's a bit of what we did. And some of the victims we brought them, too. Some of the survivors, they now told us what they went through, what they passed through. So that's what we, that was. 
    We might bring in a layer of memorializing it, though just one day, whereby we might also get people from those families. The challenge we usually have is that people have so much trauma after this, because the direct descendant children are the people there, and sometimes they want to forget. They want to get over. They don't want to be recalling what their mother went through and all that. And I also don't want to be instrumental to getting them to relive what they feel they want to forget. So you can see the whole thing playing out now.
    I want to get my society to move fast to where you are now, but you know, It's gonna, it's not gonna be very easy, and all that. Again, I also would of course not create a situation that will make people traumatizing them more and all that if they want to forget it. We also, we always allow the family members to decide what to do. Yeah. If they don't want to come, that's fine. If they want to come, we give them the space, incentivize, and make them feel very good.
    So the memorial thing is something we will have to think of about carefully, but it'll help in sending a message, especially to the wider public, messages of deterrence, messages that, ah, don't do this thing. This is and all that. An indirect way of telling people, stop this. Yes. Without really going to there to tell them that. So it is something we have to think of carefully, think about carefully and plan in such a way that we can use it as a resource of education and a resource also of sending a message to the whole society. 
    [00:47:01] Josh Hutchinson: I think the delicateness that you're talking about, you have to be so sensitive to all these issues itself helps to bring alive how real this problem is and how it's not just in the past, because this is a very fresh wound, and new wounds are being added daily, unfortunately. So I think for, as an American who has that, this was 300 years ago mentality, that's impactful to me to know just how fresh these wounds are, how the tears are not dry.
    [00:47:50] Leo Igwe: Like I said, I'll think about it carefully and because many families of victims, they're always happy that people are honoring them or providing them the psychosocial support. They were, they're always very happy. But I'm trying to make sure we do it so we don't impose it on them. It's not like it's sound imposition, it is actually something that could help their healing. Yeah. So I'm always out of ideas when I meet them. Cause I don't know whether to cry. I don't know. I know what to, whenever I meet them, it is like, what do you want? I take them sometimes. So that, okay, you want me, I can put them out in a hotel for some days, just try to see how I can get them back to the normal all this day, because they're always very traumatized.
    So what I'm trying to say is that, yeah it is something that I will have to think about creatively and see how we can do it as part of an effort to provide them support, not necessarily against their will, get them to be reliving their trauma. Okay. Uhhuh. Yes. So it is, like I said, it's something I have to think about and and also we have to also do it in such a way that of course it doesn't provoke the situation.
    We move it away to a venue where we can bring them there, and we talk and we do our thing, and in fact, make sure it serves the goal. Which is to provide them some kind of closure, to provide them with some kind of support, and then send the message of deterrence to the wider community. I think for me, this is what I could see when it comes to this memorial thing, but we have to really plan it out very well to make sure that it achieves that goal.
    [00:49:30] Sarah Jack: That's very good. There's some similar dimensions when you look at the exoneration effort in Connecticut or any of the ones that have occurred in the United States. Some descendants, it's so traumatic and raw for, they really can't get involved, but they want to see it happen. So like after HJ 34 passed, we heard from so many descendants who were just, they were healing, because they saw that their ancestor, their name was made right. But they needed to do it outside of the action. They personally couldn't do more, because of how they were coping with that history. There's just all those different layers for different people. It's not the same. But I understand, I've learned from hearing from people that the trials have really affected descendants in different ways. Of course, living family members in Nigeria who are literally having their life and family torn apart from it, that is real life happening right now. But I see that over the timeline, over the world, these have really caused deep wounds and everybody comes to face it in a different way and heal. 
    [00:50:54] Leo Igwe: Everybody faces in a different way, and what we try to do is try to identify if anybody that is facing this in a way that connects with us at our campaign, and we try also to process it in a way that we don't hurt somebody else who is a process it differently. Yeah. So that is, is a delicate balancing we try to do, because sometimes even from the point of view, when it happens, immediately happens, let's say what I mean by when it happens is that, oh, somebody's killed. Sometimes some family members don't want, because whatever you're going to do will not bring the dead person to life, okay?
    But of course we tell them sometimes you can get a person to send a message that was, that's invaluable. Okay. But some of them cannot connect with that. Yes. Yeah, some of them cannot connect with that. So sometimes we might get one person, there was a particular family is only one person, and the lady who connected what we're doing, and we were able to provide a lot of help.
    So in fact this man was beaten, they wounded him, I think broke his arm or something, because of witch-hunting, and I wanted to capture his story. Okay. So he said he wasn't interested. He said he wasn't interested, that he has handed everything over to God, that God should be the one to pursue it. It pains me, but that's how he, that was how he wanted it. So that was how we stopped on that case.
    Another man came all the way to our event and sat very early before we even arrived at the event and was there, recounted his own story of what happened? He of course, his own, he was, it was the son that wanted to attack him and beat him and all that. So he was able to resist the son, and there was this kind of fight and the villagers came. So the son went and smashed the windscreen, the car, tried to vandalize and all that. So he came and narrated it and we were able to support him and just use that to send a message like we're saying, but that's what we used that for. But sometimes some people can't connect with that.
    And that's also is also hampering our ability sometimes to send a message to the wider public. Cause if we don't get these people to work with us, if we don't get these people to tell us the story, or even come out to tell the world their story. Because what happens there is that we hear the accusers. We hear them, the accusers. Very often we, we don't hear the accused. And even when you're hearing from the accuser, you will be hearing from a third party, "oh that woman said." Now the woman now be so traumatized to come out openly and tell the word, look at what happened. It takes a lot, sometimes even years before the person can be in the form to, even if, I mean you are calling the press, many of them get apprehensive. They think that you might be worsening their situation. So what I'm saying, I'm just confirming the fact that people relate with this differently, and we are also trying to navigate that. 
    Bear in the mind that we want to help these people. We don't want to harm them for that. Yeah. So we don't want to go about it in a way that we get them to feel hurt, so all, so what, that's why we have, I said we have to be very creative about it. Those who are ready to connect with us, we take them, we use their memory, we try to see what we can do. We use their stories. We go to the media, hoping that the message will keep going out.
    Then why we allow others to make sense of it, find closure in a way they want, so that we will not be like, maybe try end up maybe further traumatizing or interfering. Some of them feel that you are coming to interfere in what is actually their family thing, or they think that's something you want to make out of it. You want to use it for your own goal or I realize a particular thing. 
    So all these are complications. But what happens is that at the end of the day, a lot of people are appreciative of our intervention. They want the support, but sometimes how they relate with how we do, how we take that further, is different. And we always allow them to determine when they want us to stop, we stop and all that. But when those who want to continue with us, we'll continue, because we need them to tell the story in a way that a lot of people will connect better than when we actually tell their story on their behalf.
    [00:55:25] Josh Hutchinson: As we wrap up, is there anything in particular you wanted to be able to say today? Is there another message you have for our listeners?
    [00:55:36] Leo Igwe: The, I understand that, I mean our listeners mainly in the US I guess anything online, anybody can listen to it. So let me not be an old school kind of thing and say, because this is a podcast in the US it's going to be American listeners only. But what I'm trying to say is that we need to sit up, we need to see what we can do to address this problem, and we need to change our attitude, and you can do something.
    Just like we heard about the person who was accused or at a point acquitted and somebody had to take her in and protect her. Just hid her for some time or something like that. You can do something personal there that might change the trajectory when it comes to life, because witchcraft accusation is a life or death issue.
    You can do something there. Yes. And like I said, it might be something you take for granted, but it makes a whole lot of difference. Yes. You can share even the link, this very link, you can put it somewhere, you can share it in your apartment, there might be a conference coming up. You just put it out there.
    What am I saying? If you can help us send this message. I want people to now tell me, oh, I know that this is taking place. I want people to stop telling me I didn't know it's taking place. Now we have the internet. Now you can listen to this. So share the link.
    Let people get to know that it's taking place. So let's cross that, that this aspect, let's get over it and begin to say, okay, now it's taking place. What do we do? So that is one thing, I want our listeners to, see how, what they can do when it comes to that. We need to win this information war, and we need awareness war. So let everybody know that this is taking place.
    Now. But if you're also in the position of drawing attention of other departments, organizations, because a whole lot of organizations are doing all sorts of things in terms of development, in terms of human rights, in terms of education, in terms of women's rights and all that. Anything that has some, because witch hunt has so many connections, has connections with security, it has connections with law, it has connections with education. Cause when you look at it, when you go out and listen and watch this video, there must be an aspect of it that you feel connected. Do something about connection. Just do something, this is my message, is do something. Because you can do something, you can share this link, you can draw an attention of somebody, you can connect. 
    Like when I went to the the Salem Witch Museum? They told me the story. They told the story and ended up with McCarthy, some American thing like that. I was like, oh, hi guys. I don't get this. You're American. You know witch McCarthy, some kind of witch hunting stuff. I'm talking about real real thing. They're talking about politics. You know the thing, the witch hunting story ended up with something like politics. No, I couldn't connect. Immediately, it stopped being what it is in my own world. I couldn't connect with that. So I'm not saying that they should not do it, but let them restrict that as an American one and let them bring in what is going on that place. Let them mention it. You may not have the details, but mention it, because that it was totally absent in the museum.
    How do you expect people who get educated there to know that it's taking place today? So we still have work to do. So what I'm trying to draw attention is that there's a need for us to win this information war, this awareness war, this knowledge war, so that when we know this, we can now begin to look at tiny, little ways and actions we can take to begin to address it.
    Because there is still this sense people get, no matter how they divided the world, maybe, no matter how people talk about racism and all that, there is still that sense of human connection. And there's this sense I see in the face of a lot of people whom I don't know,. Sometimes I send them money either for medical bills after they're persecuted or I send them money to their relocation. You, when you meet some of them, you still see that connection. And I want to let you know that there are a lot of people who will appreciate whatever you do to help them out of what is actually a life and death situation. And some of the things you could do are actually things you might even take for granted, but which will resonate invaluably, which will change somebody's life in a way you could not imagine.
    So this is again, how the world as it is today puts us in a position to make a significant change in the life of somebody somewhere with something that my might appear so significant to us. This is our chance, this is our opportunity, and let's seize it. And just like the senators, the lawmakers in Connecticut, they seize this opportunity and passed the bill and passed the resolution and sent that clear message, overwhelmingly, when those campaigning were like a little worried that it may not happen. You can also create surprises in a way that will even maybe, I may not even, that will be beyond my expectation. By putting together efforts that can send a message that will resonate not only with victims, but also a lot of people who think that nothing can be done to significantly change what is going on in Africa and other parts of the world where witch-hunting is still an everyday reality.
    [01:01:26] Sarah Jack: So important, leo, thank you so much. One of the early things that I learned from you, from reading about you before I met you and our first episode where we met you and interviewed you was one of the things that you have just said how you cannot tell the victim stories like they can. And I, so early realized we cannot, I cannot, the podcast cannot tell the story of what's happening in your country and other parts of the world like you can, and you have done that. And I hope that we can keep giving you that opportunity. I hope that this conversation does go on to that next phase of information, the action phase. It needs to. And I think about how, even a year ago, so much, so many people were very unaware that Connecticut had witch trials. 
    And for the most part, now we aren't, we are not hearing as much, "they had witch trials?" Instead we're hearing, "oh, I want more information," "oh, my family lived in that town," "oh yes." We got over a hump. I know there are still people learning and figuring it out, but we definitely saw a transition in the education and I know that you are going to, that we are all going to see that with this global issue of the witch-hunt, too. I know we are.
    [01:02:55] Leo Igwe: And again, like I said this podcast may also sound like maybe something like a platform you just do it and put it out there. Is also important you understand that it's providing also a mechanism, a facility, of information. A lot of people might get to know what they never knew or might get to hear about what they never heard, or may we get to understand the urgency of something they take very lightly, and all that through this. So it, this is also serving, a very important function. And of course I will, I'll thank you Sarah. I thank you Josh for coming together and putting this putting this podcast together and providing this platform and doing this connection. I've said many times, there's always this disconnect. It's like we're talking about different things. That's what they tell us in the academic thing. They think we're talking about different things, and my mind is telling me we're not talking about different things, but they will tell you, okay, we're talking about different things. Explain it differently so that you get scholarship, you get funding, you get this thing when you say it's the same thing and all that, oh, and all that.
    So a lot of people keep struggling, misrepresenting situations and all that. From there, they make a profession out of misrepresenting the situation. Okay? We are talking about similar experiences. Yes, it may happen to people 300 years ago, but I'm not interested in those year argument. I'm interested that it happened and that people suffered this thing and are still suffering it today and that we should treat it with that same urgency, with that same pain and all that we relate to the one that happened there. 
    So what am I trying to say is that your podcast has also helped in giving me that sense of connection. I never found it in the lecture room. I never found it doing my research and all that, because I'm told to see Africa as unique and explain it that way and see how things are functioning for them and all that. But I decided to rebel against that and do it my thing the way I understand, and luckily I have you people now who can see how things are really coming together, and it is like giving me some sense of fulfillment and some sense of hope that at least I'm on track or we are on track at least towards containing this problem and drawing from the world's resources, because I told people the resources are there. There's a way you present a situation, you deny yourself of available resources that would've been there. So I am happy that at least we can pull resources together. We not be addressing the same thing the same way, but we may be addressing the same thing differently. But what is important? What will they ask us a hundred years from now? We don't know how the world will be. Whether the whole world will just be on one phone. If you're on phone, bam, you can talk to anybody like the way you talk to any, you know, and all that. They would say, this thing ended, and let them hear that we did our best. We didn't misrepresent the situation and refuse to use the resources that we have available to address a problem. I know that people when they understand that we tried to present this problem the way it is and use whatever we could east, west, north, and south to address this, and all that. And that we did not celebrate the memory of some people in some part of the world different from others, and all that. Yes, it is a collective memorization and that's a project I think, and I hope that you're going to send the right message, and that is why, once again I'm grateful for you people, for what you're doing and for giving me this platform and also for being very supportive.
    [01:06:22] Josh Hutchinson: Thank you so much for joining us.
    [01:06:24] Sarah Jack: And now for a minute with Mary. 
     
    [01:06:35] Mary Bingham: It was an amazing gift to spend an entire day with Dr. Leo Igwe last May. Listening to his stories regarding how he and his organization help people brutally targeted for unfounded accusations of witchcraft have made a life-giving impact for me. I consider Dr. Igwe's enthusiasm to end witch hunts very infectious. I have made it my mission to continue to follow his mission and spread information regarding ongoing, real witch hunts on all of my social media platforms, hopefully furthering this education on my own, as well as through the organization of which I am a part. That will help Dr. Igwe to save lives from the hands of those who maliciously track people down, beat and murder these innocent women, children, and men.
    Another activist I hope to meet someday is Monica Paulus. Monica grew up no stranger to violence in Simbu province of New Guinea. After discovering she in fact had rights as a human being, Monica challenged herself by moving forth to eventually defend women and children who suffered abuse due to accusations of sorcery. Monica knew how to get involved to get things done. Her involvement with certain groups led to the government to allocate 3 million Papua New Guinea kinas to set up committees. That amount is equal to about 842,000 US dollars. These committees were to address sorcery-related violence. 
    Monica's life has been threatened many times. Threats have even come from her own family members. She was told to move many times or else get killed. But Monica soldiered on to save others. In Monica's own words, she says, and I quote, "we really need each other at all levels. Human rights is everyone's business," end quote. On the ground, Monica has taken women and children accused of sorcery-related acts into her home for their safety, providing food, clothing, and shelter, even when she did not have much of those items to offer. Monica also helps to bring their accusers to justice in some cases. 
    To learn more about this extraordinary woman, visit stopsorceryviolence.org. In addition, please visit allegedwitches.law.blog to read more about Advocacy for Alleged Witches, the organization founded by Dr. Leo Igwe. Also I, along with Josh and Sarah, strongly encourage the listeners to visit endwitchhunts.org, the organization of which we three are a part. Any donation or purchase you would make could help to save a life. Thank you.
     
    [01:09:46] Sarah Jack: Thank you, Mary.
    [01:09:48] Josh Hutchinson: Here's Sarah with End Witch Hunts News. 
     
    [01:10:08] Sarah Jack: End Witch Hunts is a nonprofit 501(c)(3). Here's our weekly news update.
    Here's a course that introduces the study of beliefs and practices past and present associated with magic, witchcraft, spirituality, magical realism, and religion. It's called Witches, Bruxas, and Black Magic. These topics are discussed and include ritual, symbolism, mythology, altered states of consciousness, and healing, as well as syncretism, change, and the social roles of these beliefs and practices. 
    Stay tuned to where you can enroll for this online class.
    On May 25th, 2023, the Connecticut General Assembly passed House Joint Resolution 34, Resolution Concerning Certain Witchcraft Convictions in Colonial Connecticut. This legislation cleared the names of the innocent accused witches of Connecticut Colony. This milestone resolution passed when the majority of the House, 80%, voted yes on May 10th to pass it to the Senate. Then on the 25th, the Connecticut Senate voted almost unanimously yes, only one senator voted no, completing the passage of HJ 34.
    This resolution was successful due to years of collective attempts and efforts from many, many local politicians and residents, witch trial descendants, and advocates from across the United States and the globe. It took every layer of efforts to get this done. Many individuals started it, many carried it, and many finished it. 
    So, since efforts for witch trial exoneration in Connecticut over the past decades were blocked at every turn, why did the renewed efforts in 2022 move so swiftly? Why did the witch trial victims officially receive state acknowledgement as innocent now within a year? How did this landmark legislation acknowledging innocence of Connecticut Colony's indicted and hanged accused witches gain wide legislative support?
    Because a collective group of bipartisan legislators stood together against the witch-hunt mentality. The leaders of the state of Connecticut took a stand together for historic social justice. The mentality that targets vulnerable people, often women and children for the unprovable crime of causing harm and mischief through witchcraft . Not one case of such witchcraft accusation has ever been true, yet thousands and thousands have been punished and killed for it. Yes, annually thousands and thousands continue to be punished and killed for it in over 60 countries. 
    You have been transformed by the teaching of witch trial history, and you realize now how witch hunts happen is not a mystery. Why vulnerable people are hunted is not confusing. You may have realized the cause of witch-hunt mentality through research, reading, listening to podcasts and hearing academic presentations. There are ample trusted records that teach us about the societal stresses that press a community and influence panic and uproar around devastations that turn into witch targeting.
    Remember the university class I announced at the opening of the weekly news update, WGS 4301 Special Topics: Witches, Bruxas, and Black Magic? It's actually no longer available. Fearful alumni of Texas Tech University reacted with moral panic to the offering of this type of common academic sociology and history curriculum on witchcraft-related topics. This Texas Tech course was erased from the online catalog because of the uproar of alumni. To be clear, this class is not an initiation into witchcraft practices that are feared to cause harm and misfortune.
    History is record and sociology is science. We need academics to include both so that we act with knowledge, not fear, around witch trial and witchcraft topics. The modern crisis of witch attacks can only be faced and solved when we understand our history and our societal beliefs collectively. Banning this class is a moral panic that perpetuates the fears that cause violence against alleged witches. 
    Stand up for social science. Stand up for the vulnerable. Look into what you don't know and seek to understand from what we should know about history. 
    Today you were reminded about the ongoing mob witch hunts that are killing and violently abusing extensive numbers of women, men, and children in dozens of countries now. There are more victims now than ever before in the history of humanity. You are aware of the urgency. You understand the pressing demand for immediate interventions. Respond to the call for worldwide collective action against which fear. State Representative Jane Garibay is quoted as rightly saying, quote, "people working together achieve great success." Join the ones who are working to create safety for the vulnerable citizens in our world communities. You raise awareness with transformative conversations through the power of your social reach. Engaging in, quote, "the study of beliefs and practices past and present" is history and sociology. It is academic.
    Thou Shalt Not Suffer podcast supports the global efforts to end modern witch hunts. Get involved. Financially support our nonprofit initiatives to educate and intervene. Visit endwitchhunts.org to make a tax-deductible contribution. You can also support us by purchasing books from our bookshop, merch from our Zazzle shop, or subscribing as a Thou Shalt Not Suffer podcast Super Listener for as little as $3 a month at thoushaltnotsuffer.com. 
     
    [01:15:32] Josh Hutchinson: Thank you, Sarah.
    [01:15:34] Sarah Jack: You're welcome.
    [01:15:36] Josh Hutchinson: And thank you for listening to this important episode of Thou Shalt Not Suffer.
    [01:15:41] Sarah Jack: Take action to end witch hunts.
    [01:15:44] Josh Hutchinson: Start by telling your friends about what you heard today.
    [01:15:48] Sarah Jack: And go back and listen to episode 16, Leo Igwe on Witch Hunts in Nigeria.
    [01:15:54] Josh Hutchinson: Thank you for taking action this week.
    [01:15:57] Sarah Jack: Support our efforts to End Witch Hunts. Visit endwitchhunts.org to learn more.
    [01:16:02] Josh Hutchinson: Have a productive today and an impactful tomorrow. 
     
    
  • Witchcraft Accusations in Nigeria with Dr. Leo Igwe

    https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/2045153.rss

    Show Notes

    Dr. Leo Igwe, activist and advocate of the Advocacy for Alleged Witches, speaks with us about the witch hunt crisis in Nigeria. Leo teaches us the historical, societal, and cultural implications leading us to this modern day situation and calls for specific support. We discuss the urgency of immediate interventions and ways of building up Nigerians to be able to address and implement their own solutions. This episode is a call to action for all people worldwide to take action against witch fear and to create safe communities for the vulnerable citizens in our world communities.
    Links

    Advocacy for Alleged Witches

    Please sign the petition to exonerate those accused of witchcraft in Connecticut

    Connecticut Witch Trial Exoneration Project

    End Witch Hunts Movement

    Donate to Support the Podcast

    Join us on Discord to share your ideas and feedback.

    Support the show

    Transcript

    [00:00:00] 
    Josh Hutchinson: Welcome to an eye-opening, profound, life-changing episode of Thou Shalt Not Suffer: The Witch Trial Podcast. I'm Josh Hutchinson. 
    Sarah Jack: And I'm Sarah Jack.
    Josh Hutchinson: Today we speak with Leo Igwe, an activist in Nigeria, about modern day witchcraft persecution in West Africa.
    Content warning. We're talking about real-life events. The things that human beings do to each other. We caution you to listen at your own discretion.
    Sarah Jack: All of it's discussed very tastefully. It's just horrific.[00:01:00] 
    Josh Hutchinson: We're just discussing what are the facts on the ground. 
    Sarah Jack: After you listen to Leo's stories, you'll understand what's happening there. 
    Josh Hutchinson: It's a nasty situation, but Leo's here to help change things.
    Sarah Jack: We asked him questions that we thought you would want answered. 
    Josh Hutchinson: Leo gives us a good background on what the situation is, what events are happening, how they're happening, who's involved, who needs to step up to the plate and take action.
    Sarah Jack: You will hear the urgency and come to understand the urgency. If you're wondering if this episode is for you, it is.
    Josh Hutchinson: There's so much we could say about this, but let's hear it from the man himself, Leo Igwe.
    Thank you so much [00:02:00] for joining us. It's an honor. 
    Leo Igwe: Thank you for giving me this platform. It's not common. A lot of people, we've been longing to be given platforms so that we can bring in our own side of the story.
    Josh Hutchinson: We wanna start with some questions about the background of what is actually happening in West Africa with these witchcraft accusations. Is the fear that's driving the allegations coming from the traditional religion or the colonized religions, or is it a mix of both?
    Leo Igwe: Well, witchcraft accusation predates colonialism. It predates contact with the West or contact with non-African cultures and religions. What happens is that, of course, I learned from my father, who learned from the grandfather, who were traditional religionists, that people try to [00:03:00] make sense of life, using whatever they can materially, material, spiritual, natural, supernatural, ritualistic, whatever they can do to really provide a solution to their problems, they did, and they were doing this before they got in contact with other cultures and other religions, but of course other religions somehow reinforced aspects of many preexisting practices and conceptions.
    For instance, Christianity came as a better religion. They told Africans, "your traditional religion is primitive. Now take a better look at the better religion." That's Christianity. And of course, it's not only because they made a case for better religion. They use violence in terms of colonialism, forceful acquisition of these cultures. They use their school, they use health institutions [00:04:00] to still send a message that Christianity was better. But of course, many people, in the course of embracing this religion, discovered within Christianity, witchcraft narratives, supernatural narratives, faith-healing narratives, which now reinforced preexisting notions and practices.
    So this is how what you can call the colonial religions intersected with preexisting notions. And the same thing with Islam. Islam also came as a better religion. And of course, they made Africans to understand that what they were worshiping, were actually spirits, not God, were deities, the divinities. So they made them to embrace what they think is a real God. And of course, in embracing this, it also came with your own supernatural narratives, including narratives of healing, narratives of making sense of misfortune.
    And it is within this universe of supernatural solutions and narratives [00:05:00] that witchcraft notions exist. And this is how what we are seeing today is an intersection, is a fusion, is a kind of practices going on, in spite of, or in addition to, or in connection with what you can call the colonial religions.
    Sarah Jack: What laws are on the books in Nigeria and other African nations, and how long have they been there? Are they a response to what you just shared about?
    Leo Igwe: Yeah, we have of course, we have regulations even before, you know, we got the state formations with laws and constitutions as embedded in Western form of state or political system. And of course, let me go to the traditional laws. Traditional laws, of course, they have their regulations as what do you do if you are convicted?
    Theft, acquisition, forceful acquisition of other people's [00:06:00] property, or what do they call, you know, or killing or murder, and other offenses within the community. But, of course, in trying to decide who is guilty or who is innocent, sometimes they involve the traditional priests or traditional diviners who, you know, especially when such incidents is assumed to involve some supernatural.
    Now, when the colonialists came with their own laws and state formation systems, they introduced another way of rules of money or how to make sense of offenses. And of course, it was the, you can call them the post-enlightenment Europeans that came here. So they had gone through this issue of witch-hunting, and they had al, they already done with it, and within their law books, they, they criminalized witchcraft accusation. And they now introduced the similar [00:07:00] laws here to checkmate, to regulate, to restrain accusations and attendant abuses. 
    Now these laws, so in Nigeria for instance, we have provisions in the criminal code against witchcraft accusations. But of course, like every other thing, or many of the things introduced during the colonial era, they were in the statutes book. They were on paper, not in practice, because these laws originated from cultures, non-African cultures, that had their time evolution in terms of its own making, but only superimposed on a culture that has not gone through similar processes, in terms of the witch-hunting, the Renaissance, the reformation of law. Law did not come here as a result of reformation by the people. Laws were introduced as imposition by those who feel that their own idea of state formation is superior to traditional formations. So what we have now in [00:08:00] after independence, when Africans took over this, first of all, they need to satisfy, of course, the former colonialists that, "oh yeah, we are continuing the state formation."
    So we are going to, they now just put in play those laws. They just cut and paste all these laws, and they now had independence, but they were still on paper. Even myself growing up, I never knew that witchcraft accusation was a crime. It was only when I started fighting these allegations and I was looking for mechanisms to help me do that, that I just looked at the law. I said, " Leo, look at it there, is even clear in our statutes book." Why? Because one thing goes on in the law or in the on paper of the law, but another thing goes on in practice. So because culture, religion, or, are very often are involved in, when it comes to cases like this.
    So we have the laws, but the question is that these laws are not being enforced. These laws are not being [00:09:00] enforced because, first of all, of the fact that these laws sometimes conflict with local, traditional beliefs and then state, the state is weak. So that who, who enforces the law is, is a matter of who is offended. If you are rich and powerful, of course you can enforce the law, but if you, if you are poor, and, uh, and, uh, you cannot, you don't have the wherewithal, you cannot even, you know, enforce the law even when the law is on your side. So what we have is a situation whereby people affected are always elderly women, children, people with disabilities, and people who are not in the position or with the power and the resources to enforce the law in a situation where the, the state is very weak, and the state is ineffective, and state presence is just limited, and state instrument is just a matter of who can afford to use this instrument to protect himself or herself. So this is [00:10:00] why, you know, we have this kind of situation going on today. . 
    Josh Hutchinson: Thank you for that. That really clarified a lot. How common are witchcraft accusations? 
    Leo Igwe: Well, witchcraft accusation is, I will say we have to take it in layers. Witchcraft suspicion is pervasive, perverse in the sense that when things happen to people, using witchcraft is one of the ways they try to make sense of it. There was an accident, some people could say, "hmm, but is really an accident, you know, couldn't there be something behind this?" A kind of why me or why this person at this time?
    So what happens is that witchcraft narrative is just now one of those ways people try to make sense of it, but sometimes they suppress their suspicion, especially when they're afraid that the other party could take them [00:11:00] to court, because the law is on the side of the accused. So when they're afraid that they could be taken to court by the other party or the other party's educated, empowered, exposed, understand his or her right enough, they will suppress the allegation, and they may resort to other subtle and covert means to get back at the person that's suspected.
    Now. So what happens there is, is that it is very common, but because of the fear that the accused or the person being suspected might actually take the other person to court and get the person convicted, is only those whom they think they could overpower, they could overwhelm, the poor, the aged, the elderly ones, women. These are usually the people who are now at the extreme end, who are the receiving end of the punishment. 
    So, witchcraft accusation is pervasive. Why? Also [00:12:00] because religion, Christianity, Islam. All these religions, they accommodate witchcraft, suspicion. They may say they are not, but they reinforce it, either because they also endorse supernatural interpretation of the problems and supernatural solution of the problems. So as long as we have this, it is difficult to separate witchcraft, allegations and suspicion from people's religion. So religion is pervasive. Africa is almost the religious capital of the world, in terms of Islam, in terms of Christianity. So within this religious capitalality locks witchcraft suspicion, witchcraft beliefs.
    So it is very common, but what happens is that it is difficult to enforce, it's difficult to take on whom you are suspecting, because of fear that the person could go to court and get this person suspecting, the person accusing to go to prison or to suffer some [00:13:00] penalty.
    Sarah Jack: So I'm really hearing you talk about the powerful versus those without power. Is that geographical at all? Do you find accusations happening in rural, more rural or both rural and urban? Does the power part play into that? 
    Leo Igwe: Yeah. You see urban areas are often where the elite, the educated, those who work with the government, the politicians where they live. So, and urban areas are areas where sometimes people live in a way that they don't actually know their neighbors. They are, they're not connected with their neighbors, so they don't know what is going on in the other apartment or in the other person's life. Okay. 
    So, but in the rural areas, people will live in a way that they know each other, they understand each other. Sometimes they share [00:14:00] apartments, land, they have a lot of things in common, unlike in rural areas where very often you only deal with the state or you deal with your landlords or the person directly. So, um, the accusations are more in rural areas or people who are living in slums, and slums, these are areas in the cities where people are not actually living a way that, you know, they actually live within apartments. They live in open spaces. They make use of open, uh, either pumps or common, they share things in common, so, so we see that more often happening in rural areas. 
    Now, another reason why it happens in rural areas is that there's limited presence of the state. Oftentimes, we have a police stations with about three or five police officers in a community of a hundred to 300 people, and sometimes the police stations are kilometers away from some of the communities. [00:15:00] So those communities are managed by traditional rulers, who use customs, more of customs than the laws, and who use local enforcement mechanisms than the police. Is only when a rich member of the society who is affected, the person could not bring in the police to overwhelm the local traditional system.
    So it is more of, again, where the weak, the poor, the socially vulnerable, where they live. This is where you have it more, because in the rural areas where you have the politicians and who have the rich and the elite who live in their, you know, very skyscrapers or live in posh houses, luxurious homes with, uh, a lot of security people around them and all that. We don't get a lot of these accusations, but we get it more in rural, squalid neighborhoods, you know, where people are, poor people live and where they cannot [00:16:00] sometimes afford to go to hospital or access medical care, and they only go to prophets, prophetesses. They go to mallams, or they go to clerics when they're sick or when they need their job, and all that. And many of them are not well educated, so they are vulnerable, they live in a lot of uncertainty, and they are not well skilled, and they don't have well skilled jobs. So these are usually where you have more of them, and a lot of people who are well skilled either they live in the city or they migrate to Europe or America for better jobs. So the, the circle of people who are really vulnerable and who are prone to suffering accusations continue to widen, as the elite continue to move to the urban areas or migrate to Europe and America and others. So leaving Africa now with, you know, a growing army of vulnerable people, people who are likely to be accused, attacked, or killed in the name of witchcraft.
    Josh Hutchinson: These accusations, [00:17:00] when they're made, are they taken to the traditional leader in the community, or are they handled independently? 
    Leo Igwe: No, they're usually taken to the traditional ruler. But what happens is that if the family, first of all, if they suspect, if they make their suspicion, sometimes they secretly go to some of the traditional healers or priests or Christian pastors or prophets, you know, prayer houses, spiritual home, because there are all sorts of places they go these days. Sometimes it's a mix of traditional and Christian, traditional and Islam, just a place you can find solution. And we have always people who use all sorts of religious Christian just to make sure that they make sense of people's problems. So they go to these places. And when these places, when the divine are there, the cleric there, the so-called expert [00:18:00] there, or you can call the person the witch doctor, if that is what you know, what is best.
    When the person now tells them that, okay, actually this is a case of witchcraft, and somebody in your family is responsible, the person now comes back emboldened with a lot of force and anger and reports the matter now to the chief. And that puts the chief sometimes in a very difficult position, because the chiefs always know that they must have gone to certify who the witch is before coming to them. So sometimes the chief might recommend that they should go to another for another reconfirmation. Sometimes they might refuse, or they want the chief to use the result of their own consultation or confirmation. So sometimes he puts the chief in a difficult position, the chief might yield and go with it, or he might prevail on the accusing party to go to another place.
    Or he might [00:19:00] also invite the police. It depends on where the chief is living, how close the next police station is, and how effective, you know, bringing in external party, in terms of the police, into the matter. So chiefs always find themselves in very difficult position, and very often they yield to the mob, because if they don't do that, they themselves could also be killed, or they could be lynched, because they could be seen as a party to the witchcraft.
    And they could also, you know, put their, they could put themselves in danger and even their legitimacy, you know, could be taken as having been compromised, because they are seen as, their role is to protect the community, not just protecting them physically, but also protecting them metaphysically. So when somebody feels metaphysically assaulted and the chief seems not to be taking effective measures, the chief is believed to have compromised their positions.
    Sarah Jack: And [00:20:00] the person that would be first consulting with a spiritual leader and then going to the chief, is that individual usually a male or a leader within a family or a person with some social power within his circle? Or could just like a teenage daughter go and ask for consultation on it? 
    Leo Igwe: Now, yes, a very good question. Our society is patriarchal, so male dominates, male rule, male direct, male control. We have male control society, so that is usually the male members, especially the elderly ones or the ones who claim to be in position of power are usually the ones who will go to consult and very often in many parts of, of the region, the person that also going to consult also going to be a male person. There are female diviners, but they're just in the minority. And of course, because they're in [00:21:00] the minority, they also are, they're afraid of also making divinations that could change the power equation in terms of patriarchy, male domination.
    So you will still see the female diviners, you know, also making divinations, you know, along that line, which is of course indicting women and elderly women. So it's usually the male that will go out to consult very often male diviners or traditional priests or prophets. Occasionally, of course there are cases of prophetesses, female diviners, or or female traditional priests, but they are usually in the minority, very, very minority.
    Josh Hutchinson: And why do they make the witchcraft allegation? Is there something specific that's happening to trigger an accusation of witchcraft? 
    Leo Igwe: There are many triggers. Very often these triggers are usually [00:22:00] misfortunes. For instance, we have a case in October. A young man in rural, in a rural area was traveling on a motorbike. He had no headlight. Yeah, there was no light. And he was traveling in the night. So he was involved in a crash, and he died. And the family now said, "oh no, this wasn't an ordinary death." 
    There's always this notion of ordinary and extraordinary death. When it's a young person, when it's just somebody, new couple, when is, when it happens in a way that people think, "yeah, this is not a case of ordinary death." They will now go to diviners, who will now tell them who might be or who could be responsible for, for that. So this is, this is usually the pattern. Whenever some misfortune happens and some people think it's not an ordinary misfortune, [00:23:00] that there must be something extraordinary, they would go there.
    So that was what happened in that case. They went to a diviner who now, identified that there were children initiated into the witchcraft world. So they came and took some of these children, and I think they must have tortured them, but eventually they started confessing and started telling them other women in the community who were involved in witchcraft. And that was how they went, mentioned the name of some women. They brought them to the shrine, tortured them, and eventually they killed them in the process and buried them in the forest. So this is how some misfortune considered to be extraordinary, not normal, how it now gets one into that slippery slope that leads to accusation, killing, murder, the suspected Witch. 
    Sarah Jack: And you mentioned that some of the consequences of [00:24:00] allegations are torture and murder, people naming other people. Are there other consequences that we need to know about from allegations? 
    Leo Igwe: Well, first of all is that people are dispossessed. Sometimes accusations happens to widows who inherited a lot of property from the late husband. Okay. And sometimes when, let's say somebody in the family, a relative, when he is sick, the person will now assume that, oh yeah, this woman also wants to kill me or something. So they, they could make allegations to dispossess, but dispossess the accused.
    They could make allegations that will lead to the banishment of the accused. The accused, in, in the north of Ghana, they have a [00:25:00] whole place, makeshift shelters, they call them witch camps. And these are places that people run to, accused people run to. Either, they actually tell them, "go." They actually, you know, come and force them to leave their community and go to these places. And when they go, they're dispossessed of their house, their land, and their property. 
    So the consequences are not just only torture, trial by ordeal, mob violence, lynching. It could also be dispossession of their property. They could also be banished and they now have to spend the rest of their life, sometimes as, uh, moving along the streets. There was a case in Nigeria, where the person was living on the streets, and one day the woman decided to come back in the night. They went and abducted her and stoned her to death. So a lot of people will be banished. They don't have a place to [00:26:00] go, and sometimes many of them end up dying on the streets, you know?
    So there are so many consequences apart from torture and murder of the accused, all sorts of abuses, you know, are visited on them. Both the ones we can track and the ones we cannot track.
    Josh Hutchinson: We've also heard you speak about prisons in certain nations where they keep the accused for their own safety. Can you tell us about that? 
    Leo Igwe: Yes. What happens is that you see, there's always this attitude by the police or state officials. They'll say, okay, they call it protective custody. So they come up with a name to actually justify what is clearly an abuse, because there's nothing like protective custody, because people who are making accusations are the ones against the law. They're the ones who's supposed to be in custody. They're only supposed to be in prison.
    But what [00:27:00] happens here is that we have a situation where police will say they keep some people in custody, because if they don't do that, they could be attacked and killed. So we have that in Chad. We have had cases of protective custody in Chad, even in Nigeria and a few other African countries where the courts or the police will decide to keep these people in detention. We also have it in Malawi, and they are claiming that because if they release them, they could be killed. 
    Because very often, the accusers, especially when the bewitched is late, in quotes, the alleged "bewitched" person died or is no more, they want to revenge, the accusers want to revenge. So what the police or the court will do is to put the person in what they call protective custody, waiting for maybe a time after the tension had gone down. [00:28:00] But the people they put in custody, sometimes elderly women, and our prison are not the best of places, because they don't care for these people. They starve them till they die. Very often they give them little or no food. So we have cases like that where the state officials will get these people imprisoned for their sake, just to protect them and ensure that they don't go back to the society, where they could be killed.
    And this is quite unfortunate, and this is part of the reason why our advocacy campaign exists and will continue to get the state to understand that the people who's supposed to be in custody are the accusers that the people supposed to be in jail, that the people who's supposed to be taken to prison and that people who are the accused are people who supposed to be freed. Their rights should be protected, because the law is on their side. So we have that, we have such cases, you know, in some countries in the region.[00:29:00] 
    Sarah Jack: Just to like visualize this, how many accused are we talking that could be in a prison? 
    Leo Igwe: What happens is that like a recent report made it clear we have problem of statistics. In a matter like this, I don't want to underestimate so that it might be reducing or minimizing what is actually a greivous issue. And I want to let you know that some years ago I went to Malawi and I didn't know that about 20, 30, over that number of women, were kept in prison for their sake, I didn't know.
    So what happens is that many of these things are going on in a lot of places without information, unless we try to really allow countries to open up and let us know. But what we know I can tell you today is that we have a lot of accused people in protective custodies across the country. We have a challenge, [00:30:00] because very often this information is not released to the public. That is part of the challenge we are facing, because we really need to have this information and put them out there and begin the process of getting the state officials to do what they're supposed to do. Release these people. 
    It was a campaign, we were at in Malawi that led to the release of many of these women. I went to Malawi, and I saw women in protective custody, and I was shocked on seeing that. And we did a campaign, but we know that there are cases in Chad, even in Congo and all that, but the number of these women is difficult to say. And that is part of the frustration. That is part of what is really hampering our advocacy campaign in many countries. Limited statistics, limited data on how the victims are being treated and maltreated across the region.
    Josh Hutchinson: The accusations, [00:31:00] do they usually come from within your own family or are they you accusing a neighbor? 
    Leo Igwe: Accusations, like I said, because they take place in rural communities where people live as families, kindreds and all that, it usually comes from within the family. Yes, it comes from within the family. We have what they called extended family. It could also come, like yesterday it was reported that somebody murdered the uncle. Yes. What happened? The son of this person informed him that the granduncle initiated him into witchcraft, because that's all this kind of narrative here that somebody is initiated, that the granduncle gave , this boy, allegedly gave this boy a piece of meat, and they said that with this, after eating this meat that he got [00:32:00] initiated and that part of the instruction was that he should kill his father. 
    So the father now did not wait for the son to kill him. He now went and confronted the uncle who is accused of initiating his son. And in the process he attacked the man, beat him down, beat him with a stick. He fell down, he now dragged the body into the hut or the house and set the house ablaze. This happened some days ago in Bauchi State in northern Nigeria. 
    So it is too often a family issue is too often a way families sometimes try to resolve cases of misfortune or cases of some suspicion of occult forces being involved in their day-to-day life. So yes, it happens more within families. It happens more among relatives. 
    Sarah Jack: [00:33:00] I have a question about this. So with like banishment and then you have this inner family accusing and violence, is there still a component where, if there's been witchcraft in your family, it makes things difficult for the rest of the family, or is that not really happening because these families are dividing over witchcraft?
    Because I believe in some other countries, once somebody has been killed as a witch in your family, then sometimes that whole family is banished or they have to seek refuge away from where they're known. Is that happening? 
    Leo Igwe: Yeah, the theory is this, because it happens within families, so you have an accusing section, you have the accused section, and uh, just like, of course, some [00:34:00] anthropologists have noted, accusation witchcraft is a flip side of kinship. So what happens is that the whole sense of family solidarity flips, you know? So very often you'll find the accused alone, or you find the accused being supported by other family members but from a distance. Yes. So it divides the family. So we have some on the side of the accused. We also have some who might not really support the alleged witchcraft, but will be providing support to the accused because the sup, the person is their mother or their sister. They will not want that person to come and live with them, but they may want to provide assistance for the person to be sent elsewhere.
    So it is really a very [00:35:00] complex situation and development, especially when people are accused. Now, when the accusation comes from, for instance, outside the family, outside the family here might be extended family, the person might be told, if it is a man or a woman, might be told to go with the family, because the belief is that you can pass, you must have passed it on.
    Yes, because there is a belief that you can inherit it, you can contract it. So it depends on the nature of the allegation and it depends on the family's response to it. So if it is intrafamily, it divides the family into two, those for the accused, those against the accused. And sometimes the removal of the accused person reduces the tension, especially when it is not seen as something that has entangled other [00:36:00] family members.
    But there are instances, especially when there is open, clear support for the accused and the chief now is in support of the accusers, the chief may order both the accused and the family members to leave the community for the sake of peace. Yes. So it doesn't follow a very strict pattern. It depends on how was the reaction of the family members to the allegation, the nature of the allegation, or what is the reaction of non-family members like the chief to the allegation? There are cases when the whole community rises against the accused. So sometimes they will tell the accused to leave with the family members. 
    So it doesn't follow a particular pattern. It can, there are a lot of variables that will determine who lives and who doesn't live when accusations happen. 
    Sarah Jack: [00:37:00] I appreciate what you're teaching us, because it really even shows me what kind of questions I have and how those need to change. So thank you.
    Josh Hutchinson: This has been very informative and eye-opening. Now we'd like to know more about your organization. What would you like to tell us about Advocacy for Alleged Witches? 
    Leo Igwe: Well, Advocacy for Alleged Witches is actually a protest advocacy, let me tell you, protest on so many grounds. First of all, I have been unsatisfied with the work being done by organization and NGOs very often based, connected with Western NGOs doing this work. Because what they do is that they so much dictate and policed the way to advocate against witch persecution. [00:38:00] And I found that unhelpful. I found that ineffective. I found that patronizing. I found that counterproductive. So they're just papering over the problem. 
    And what happens is that many of the NGOs here cannot actually do what they would've ordinarily want to do. They first of all have to look out and say, "okay, what do they want us to do? Okay, we need to have a conference." They will have a conference. After that, they go to sleep. So there isn't a grounded, solid, robust, home-based organization that responds to this problem as they want, not as they are told to do. So what we have here are NGOs who are just fronting for Western NGOs and doing it as they want. And of course they send them the money, and they do it.
    Now, I wanted an advocacy campaign that is rooted on our own feeling and our [00:39:00] own reality and as we see things. So I didn't want to be police. I don't want somebody to be dictating what I do from London or from New York and all that. Many of them are far from the scene. Many of them are not on ground, and they will be there telling you sometimes not to intervene when you supposed to intervene. They will tell you not to issue press releases. Before you issue press releases, they have to read it in New York, and sometimes they're on vacation. Okay? You cannot issue press, by the time you want to issue a press release, the matter is over. 
    I found this frustrating. So I said, look, this problem is not happening in New York. It's not happening in London. It's happening right here in Nigeria, right here in Malawi. We must be at the forefront of this advocacy. We know the problem, we know the actors, we know what to tell them, and that those who want to support us do it this way should support us. 
    As I'm speaking to you, I have just finished a meeting with local [00:40:00] stakeholders. Now, ordinarily, before you do this kind of meeting, you write a proposal, and sometimes they will tell you, oh, sorry, there's no budget for your meeting this year. Then you go and sleep till there is a budget, and sometimes if there is never a budget, you are not gonna do anything. So I just ask myself. I said, "no, no, no, no, no." Germans we say, "das geht nicht." "No, no, no. That's not possible. I will not do this." Okay. 
    So I will have to put in place a mechanism like yesterday the news came that there was an incident of witch killing in Bauchi in northern Nigeria. Right there and then I called the police commissioner. I called them, and I told them what to do, and I told them, "we're gonna work. By Monday, we're gonna put a force together and protect the child who allegedly confessed and all that, put resources to support the child." Now, for many NGOs here, you need to send a proposal to your secretariat, to your office in London or New York and [00:41:00] tell them, "okay, there is a case in, uh, Bauchi, what do we do?" They say, "but sorry, it's not in our budget this year." So what you do, you leave intervening in a situation where you could have made a difference, because it is not in the budget of an organization far away that has nothing to do with the problem going on on ground. 
    So I started this as a protest, because as it's happening, I want to intervene. I issue press releases in the night, sometimes even when I'm in the bathroom. When I'm in the toilet, I have to call people. I said, "you can't do this." You get it. And I, I don't need to get permission from anybody to do it. So this is one reason why we started the Advocacy for the Alleged Witches. 
    Again, the narrative of witchcraft in the West and the narrative of witchcraft in Africa is different. Now, the West has gone through the witch hunt, and today we have the pagans who identify as witches. Now, when we say advocacy and we campaign [00:42:00] against witchcraft, pagans are joining us in this debate, and I keep telling them, look guys, we are not talking to you. We are talking to those who claim they could disappear in the night and go and make people ill. Are you among those people? They will say, "no." I say, "look, fine. We are discussing an African-specific narrative and understanding of witchcraft, that is a problematic, that is being used to kill and mame."
    We advocate for the right of people to identify themselves as witches or freedom of worship and religion, however they want to make sense of it. But too often, because of the culture, because of the way things happen in the West, they always try to confuse issues. Here, we're not confused. Today, I had a meeting, we had a discussion on this. We know what we are talking about, but when we try to have it sometimes with people from Europe, they try to bring in the Wiccan kind of religion. [00:43:00] Look, we are not, we don't have issues with the Wiccans. No, actually, I want them to understand, they need to support us so that we can go through this phase, just like Europe did and we, and so that people who openly identify as witches or as with the Wiccan religion can practice their religion freely, just like Christians and Muslims and Hindus and Baha'i but too often those who have these kind of, uh, Wiccan belief and all that. They try to join the debate we are doing here by absorbing and misrepresenting it. So that's why I'm saying this is a protest. We are a protest advocacy, and I hope that it can take hold and it can take the continent through this process so that after some time we can now come into, uh, the same field, on the same level with the Americans and all that.
    And we've had have people here identify themselves as witches or do practice their Wiccan religion in just like they do in the West. But we are [00:44:00] still in early modern Europe. Yeah, that's where we are. And if, if, uh, other parts of the world could envision this, they would know where we are today, and here in Nigeria, in the region, there is no confusion regarding what we are trying to achieve. There is no confusion at all. But too often confusion comes when those from Europe or America try to bring in some kind of their own experiences in a way that now minimizes what people are going through here, because here, witchcraft problem comes as a result of allegation, not necessarily as a result of self-identification. No, as a result of allegation.
    Somebody has a problem. You wake up in the night, you have a dream, you go and knock at somebody's else and said, ah, I saw you in my dream. You are responsible for my problem. The next thing, the person is attacked, then the next, he is killed. So witchcraft here comes as a result of allegation, not as self-identification or as a religion.
    So, and we need the help of other people who [00:45:00] understand this as in early modern Europe, and the problem that it cause, in order for us to get rid of this problem and then come to the same level with Europe and America in terms of freedom of religion and belief, which includes freedom for people to practice and identify themselves as witches or as those who belong to the Wiccan religion.
    Josh Hutchinson: That was very powerful. How can people outside of Africa help? 
    Leo Igwe: Yeah. Yeah. This is a very interesting question and the thing is that there are so many ways you can help, and I want to let you know that what you are doing right here now is a form of help. Yes. Because I know that when people talk about help, of course people talk about money, which I want to tell you is very important, okay? But we have also more important things. Provide us the platform. Yes. Provide us the platform. Very often [00:46:00] people don't give us a platform because they want to speak for us. Sometimes, like now, when you read some of the texts by European scholars, they'll be conflating African religion, African traditional religion and witchcraft.
    It's not the case. Yes, we understand what African religion is. We understand it. Allow us to speak regarding these problems. Support us. Don't do it for us. Do it with us. Like now we are having a conversation. Yes, you are giving me a platform to explain this. Come behind us. The problem is affecting us. It's affecting our family members, affecting our parents, affecting our relatives, affecting our fellow citizens. 
    What is going on? They want to speak for us. That's a problem. Yes. They want to tell us, you know, those days, you know, Europe, and Europe and America, they will send people to Africa, "ah. How are those people? Who are they? Can you please tell us about Africans?" That era has gone. [00:47:00] Sarah, that era has gone. Josh, that era has gone .Tell your countrymen and women that the era of sending somebody to come and be speaking for us. I can speak for myself. My English might not be as good as yours, but I can communicate and tell you how we feel. Stop speaking for us. So that is a problem. Immediately, we stop this. The problem is half-solved. Work with us, come behind us, so that we begin to explain this thing from our own perspective, not from your perspective. What happens is that somebody, an American perspective of African witchcraft, I mean, see even the length of that expression is enough to discourage you.
    I'm here, I'm, I'm presenting the perspective. Nobody is presenting the perspective of Leo's perspective or come on, you know, so what am I trying to say? We need to begin to allow Africans to tell us about what is going on. Tell us about what they're doing. Support them to do that. Yes. Like [00:48:00] now we need resources.
    Yes. When events happen, invite us, because immediately you continue to provide platform for us. You are sending a message back to the community. Yes. Immediately, our voices, they get out there. People are hearing it. Look, today we have social media. When Europeans came here, we didn't have social media. We didn't have this kind of communication. So, so it is not difficult to get me to speak and let the world know what is going on. Yes. So we have to remove all these people who are, who are in between. Who, who, who want to tell you guys, okay, look at what Africans are doing. No, no, no, no, no. They have done enough. They have never done enough damage. They can go, we, we want to retire them. At the Advocacy for Alleged Witches, we want to retire some of these Europeans and Americans who want to tell you guys how we think. No, I will tell you how I think, and I'll tell you how I believe. So if you want to support us, give us the platform, give us the resources.
    And [00:49:00] sometimes we may tell you, you know, inviting us overseas. Look at the challenge we have. Sometimes they, they will spend a lot of money to invite you to overseas. Now you don't have the money to go to the next community for an intervention, and it is sometimes a fraction of the money. But they will spend thousands of dollars because they want an Africa face at the UN so that they will tell you, okay, we are doing, yeah, we are in Africa, we are active in Africa. They want an African face.
    Now you come back home here, you don't have transport money to go to the next community to support an alleged witch. You don't have transport money to go to Bauchi state like now and provide the support for this child, who is being treated as a child witch. You get it. So, but now they satisfy it, and you guys clap for them. Oh, these are our people, they're on ground. They're telling us what is going on in this native land among these Africans. But here nothing. They are not on ground. They're just doing tokenism. They're just doing PR for you guys, and you guys accept them. So, what am I trying to [00:50:00] say? What you can do for us is bring this campaign into the 21st century. Yes. Now you can reach out to me. I can take you to places I can speak from the scene, things happening. So you don't need all those people in between. That's one. 
    Two, the resources. Let them go directly to the people on ground. They waste a lot of money on visa, only I don't want to come to America to come and talk about witchcraft. I want to be here. Give me the resources. Let me stay here in Nigeria. Let me go to Malawi. Let me go to South Africa. Let me go to Liberia. Let me go to Zambia and Zimbabwe and sit with the people and begin the process of addressing this problem. Enough of this tokenism. Enough of this PR. Enough of this superficial campaign. Enough of this patronizing approach.
    You trying to tell us how Africans should do it. I know what to do. I know the problem. I know the people. I know what to do. Stop making it seem as if I don't, I'm not intelligent enough, [00:51:00] you know how to solve my problem. I know it. I need the means. I need the tools. Support me. Don't do it for me.
    Josh Hutchinson: Are there other organizations like yours in other nations? 
    Leo Igwe: Well, there are organizations working on this. There are organizations trying to address this problem, but I want to let you know our approach is different. Yes. Very often they will call them human rights organization, so you wouldn't even know that they're addressing the problem. And they don't want to send the message that they're also addressing the problem, because, like now, my organization, whenever we have meetings, they'll be coming. They say, "are you what? Who are you? Are you, are you guys witches? Or what are you people really doing?" So there is always that challenge. Many organizations want to kind of play down on it and do it in a very subtle and covert manner. [00:52:00] And by so doing, they won't be achieving clear results. Yes. "Oh, we are addressing the elderly, the rights of the elderly." Then they will now put witchcraft inside, and they will not talk about it a lot. Oh, it's human rights they're addressing. 
    But that's why I came. Advocacy for Alleged Witches. Take it or leave it. Let's talk about it. Okay. So we have not had a campaign that comes, crisp and clear, precise, running it this way. But there are other organizations, women rights organizations, gender-based violence organizations, human rights organizations, child rights organizations, addressing this problem in a very subtle manner.
    And I worked with them and I'm always frustrated. Do you know why? Let me give you an example. I was working with one of them some years ago. We were addressing the problem of, you know, witchcraft, and we were just having some rest, trying to get some food in the village. So one of them asked me, "ah, [00:53:00] look, Leo, are you saying that witches don't exist?" I was like, "okay." 
    Now, get me right when I say this, I'm not saying that members or Wiccans who answer witches don't exist. I want to get this clear, because, Sarah, Josh, I have to be clear. Whenever I'm discussing with Westerners where this issue comes, I'm not saying that Wiccans don't exist. When we say witches in Africa, we mean people who fly out at night and go and suck blood on the roadside. That's what we mean. And when we say do witches exist, that's what we are addressing. 
    So for us at our organization, it is a myth. Nobody flies out at night while others are sleeping to go and sock blood on the roadside. Nobody flies out at night to go and poison people and kill them spiritually and all that. Now for you to ask me this question, when we are doing the campaign against witchcraft accusation means that you didn't even understand the campaign we're doing. So when this guy, when this [00:54:00] is a, is actually a lady that asked me this question, I was so demoralized.
    Now, number two, there is also another organization, they call them child rights organization. They were doing this campaign. And we appeared before a TV program, and the anchor person asked me, " can they, can children and adults be witches?" I said, "no, children and adults cannot be witches, because they cannot fly out at night and suck blood or turn into birds and all that and all that. They cannot." This is my answer. 
    Now, a colleague of mine who came from UK, you know, because when you come from UK and America, they give you a lot of respect here, even when you are talking rubbish, they keep respecting, you know? So they prefer to respect American or European who talks rubbish to an African who talks sense. Now let me give you how, let tell you what happened. So they asked this guy, "can children and adults be witches?" He said, "children cannot be witches, but adults could be." So we literally contradicted ourselves at [00:55:00] the TV. So the anchor person now, know, just faced me and said, "okay, look at what your colleague is saying."
    So there is this kind of falsification. There's this kind of, neither here nor there, things people are doing. So there are organization doing it, but sometimes they don't have very clear, concise philosophy and positions on these issues. Now, I attended a UNICEF seminar in Nigeria, and now one of the judges who was at that seminar, you know, he said this, that, "look, children cannot be witches, but I believe there are witches and wizard." I told him, I said, "my Lord, this is under contradiction." He said, "oh, you have a, you know is your right. You can object, you can you, is your view and order." So there is always this kind of neither here nor there. 
    UNICEF has released money. You know, you see UNICEF in New York will release money to address the problem of witchcraft accusation. The people who will attend the seminar will be strong believers in, in this distance, and they will [00:56:00] distribute their money and go home and continue their belief. What a nonsense, what a nonsense. While UNICEF will now tell you guys in their report how they have been addressing the problem of witchcraft accusation in Nigeria and the Africa. And when you read it, you say, "yay, they're doing wonderful work." But those who attend the seminars will come and tell you that they believe strongly in what UNICEF is campaigning against that, you know, and all that. 
    So what am I trying to say is that there are organizations doing this work, but some of them are neither here nor there. They're doing it because they have been paid, they have released some money for them. They need to justify this money they're giving them, and they'll come and say something, even though they don't believe in it, they don't do it. Shallow, superficial campaign, they're running. 
    And that is why I said at the beginning, Advocacy for Alleged Witche s is a protest organization, is a protest campaign. And this is what I continue to wage until we get a critical mass of Africans that can help us free this continent from this nonsense [00:57:00] and make sure that this vicious phenomenon, you know, is put in the dustbin, the same dustbin where the European Witch hunt is. Thank you. 
    Sarah Jack: It is a vicious phenomenon. One of the things that Josh and I were chatting about before we met with you was about are cultures defined by superstitions? Do you find your world friends outside of your continent defining you by their own superstitions, by their, what they perceive as African superstitions? What do you do with the superstition part and culture part and perceptions of that?
    Leo Igwe:  You see, culture is a whole pack of things. Like now you're saying superstition, religion, myth and all that, all this, but, you know, the real, real challenge when that superstition becomes a reason for an abuse. [00:58:00] Like now some people will tell you that women are weaker because women was created from the rib of Adam and Eve. That's Christians, now they use something for me that was mythical, because if for me, going by little I know, actually man came out of the woman, not the other way around. That's, that's my, that's what I think, you know? Cause that's what goes on. I don't know what went on many millions of years ago, but at least that's what I'm seeing today. You know, I was born of a woman. It's woman that gave birth to me. So what is this counterintuitive thing you're telling me? You know, uh, that, that women came out of a, of a man's rib or something like that. Okay. 
    Now, when cultural claims or conceptions or narratives are being used to justify abuse, that is when I have issue with it. There are so many things people have, because it's not everything that we can really explain. And we have been, you know, so there are certain things [00:59:00] in cultures that you can say these are mythical or superstitious, cause not all that we know. But when it becomes the basis to justify the abuse of women, the abuse of children, the abuse of homosexuals, or the abuse of anybody at all.
    Let me, let me not just be calling that, or Africans. Some people will tell you that, in order to, you know, we are Lot, you know, Africans and from Lot, they just come up with one biblical narrative to explain why we are black, and we know that there are scientific explanations in terms of the sun, in terms of genetics and all that. Now they will leave that. So we are using it to justify the degradation of human being. That's my issue. 
    So, because culture is a whole pack of things, myth, superstition, religion, name them, science, all these you can bring in into that context. Now. Now let me also say this. The people who came to Africa had their superstitions, they had their religion, but you know what the made us here [01:00:00] to understand their own superstition was better than our own. Okay? And over the years, they drummed this in in their schools, in their health, over the radio, and of course the media, what they show us. 
    So at the end of the day, a lot of Africans have this sense of inferiority, even when it comes to traditional superstition. But you see, they have that sense of inferiority when you're writing, not in practice. When they have problem, they resort to these superstitions. Cause that's actually what resonates more with them. Okay? So there is this complexity whereby people see that as primitive or barbaric, according to how they have been socialized by the colonial religions and those who adopted it. But in practice, they find a way of mixing it, especially since it sometimes helps them in making sense of their world. 
    So for me, superstition is universal. You find it across cultures and you, and, but what [01:01:00] happens is this, for me, as a humanist or as a, as a skeptic, as a rationalist, I'm always looking at the intersection between superstition and human rights abuses. And that's where I say it stops. There has to be a limit. Okay? So I bring in limiting factors.
    When it's intersects or when it tries to undermine certain basic values like human rights, like dignity of persons and all that, which sometimes, some of these superstitions are being used to justify. So that's exactly my take on it, yes, they're embedded in cultures, but when they try to justify abuses, then that's, for me, where I come with limiting positions and limiting sentiments. 
    Josh Hutchinson: How do you go about changing a culture to remove those harmful beliefs that lead to the abuses? 
    Leo Igwe: Yes. Tough one. Even [01:02:00] we discussed it today. Of course, they will always tell me, "ah, but you know, it takes time." I say, "how long does it take?" Sarah and Josh, look, how long did it take Africans to adopt sim card, all these cell phones, laptops? I mean, they announce it in the US, iPad or iPhone. Within weeks or months is here in Nigeria. We have many Nigerians. You manufacture cars, and within months, the cars are here.
    Now, stop killing your parents and relatives in the name of witchcraft. They say, "ah, but you know, it takes time." I say, "how long did it take you to adopt the cell phone? How long did it take you to adopt the cars, and how long did it take you to start having virtual conferences, virtual internet websites, and things like that?"
    So yes, I hear about this culture thing and changing it, but I also don't [01:03:00] want to hear, because in one sense, people change at a snap. Immediately something comes out there in your country, is right here within the next aircraft coming to Lagos or Abuja, has that very thing in it. Okay, good. Now, in another sense, somebody says, "oh yeah, but we need to, you know, it takes time."
    No, it's an excuse. I dunno how they say it in English, it cop out something you are trying to use, in order not to follow the same rhythm you are following in other sectors of life. So what I'm saying is this, no. If we can connect on the internet and nobody says, "okay, please can we wait for another century before we can do this, we can go virtual and connect with people?" No, they don't do that. WhatsApp messages, WhatsApp code, they are doing it. Okay? Then when it comes to other issues, he said, "oh yeah, but you know, our cultures are different." 
    Somebody was asking me yesterday, [01:04:00] "don't you know about African culture?" I said, "I don't know what you mean by African culture. You need to explain it to me. If African culture means believing in nonsense, I I'm not African, count me out, and if you think it has to be gradual, I'll tell you no, no, no. It will not be gradual. I did not, I did not ask that we take a gradual approach to doing this virtual meeting. Otherwise won't do it today. We may not even do it this year.
    Okay, so why should we introduce the gradualism when it comes to other cases? When I want us to move very fast? I want Africans and Nigerians to join Europeans and Americans in post-witch-hunt phase of life. And somebody is telling me it's gradual. Okay? If it is gradual, please take the same approach in adopting the cell phones. After all, we shouldn't actually be using cell phones by now, because it had to be gradual also. So let up, in fact, lemme come with this. You know what, Josh, let make everything gradual. So the, the time we adopt the cell phones, then that's the time we'll also [01:05:00] adopt and stop witch-hunting, because they want to adopt one immediately. Another one, they say, "oh, it has to be gradual." Why? Why does it have to be gradual? 
    So, what am I trying to say? Cultures change. Cultures are dynamic, but it is important that there should be people who push the boundaries. Yes. And that's what I want to do. Yes. That's what I want to use my doctorate. That's what I want to use my life. That's what I want to use my expertise to do, because people are dying. 
    A woman, they, they killed a woman, cut open the tummy, put stick inside the vagina, private part, because they accused her of witchcraft, in October in Nigeria. In Malawi, some days ago, they pushed another woman inside the grave trying to bury her with the person, the alleged bewitched.
    So how can we be gradual about this, Josh? How can we be gradual about this? I told them, lock these people up. Let that gradual thing, [01:06:00] let them be taking it in prison. It'll be gradual when they're locked up, when they're put in jail, not gradual we allow this people to be walking the streets freely. If somebody has now murdered the uncle just about a few days ago in Bauchi State, how are we going to treat it as gradual? And you ask him, he said, "you initiated my son." How? How do you initiate somebody into witchcraft? It's nonsense. Tell the person it's nonsense, and put the person in jail so the person gradually will live. Please. I agree. Let us go gradually, but let those people be in jail first. Okay. 
    And let the people making this argument go back to the analog phone. They shouldn't actually use the phone by now, because it's going to be gradual. So that is it. So what am I trying to say? Are we using gradual to keep condoning atrocities? Are we using that argument to still allow witch-hunters to be going on our streets, criminals, murderers, to be given license to continue their murder? No, I disagree with that sense of [01:07:00] cultural gradual growth or development. No. Those people. No, I have moved on. I'm an African, like I tell them, but I have moved on, and I'm ready to adopt what I think is good and dignifying about life, whether it comes from outside or comes from inside, and move on.
    I'm not part of the gradual thing that will want witch-hunters, because this is exactly part of the thing. They will tell us, oh yeah, but Africans are not Europe. We are. The same blood flowing in you is the same blood as flowing in me. I have the same sense of shock when people are killed or tortured, the way you do.
    So it is sometimes even Africans use this to internalize their own racism, to be racist among themselves. "Oh yeah, but we are not Europeans." And you are what? Are you not a human being, but you fly the same European airlines. Why do you do that? Why not go with the witchcraft planes? I'm sure you people know that Africans, they believe in witchcraft planes, right? Witchcraft planes that are always on the ground. You can't see it [01:08:00] fly an inch above the ground. We don't need gradual approach to that. They should either make it fly, or they should put it in the dustbin of history. That's where it belongs.
    Sarah Jack: You said you're ready to adopt what makes life good, and that's why people quickly adopt technology and are ready to take on the things that make their life better and good. So to stop the gradual effort they have, it has to be seen as something that is going to immediately make a personal goodness occur for them. And I was thinking about how you are working to get critical thinking to the students, to the young students of your country. And that's, that's a way.
    Leo Igwe: You know what I have done over the years, I've been thinking how do I also put in place a mechanism that will weaken the grip of what you can call superstition, [01:09:00] especially superstition translated into action that harm other citizens. Okay. You can decide. For instance, I went to the U.S. They said they don't have a thirteenth floor. Okay? Yeah. In the U.S., they said they don't have a thirteenth floor. I was like, what? I tried looking for the thirteenth floor. I could not find it. I was like, okay, something is going on here, but it doesn't harm me. Does it? It doesn't. Okay. Yeah. They have it and you laugh about it and things like that. I don't have issues with that. 
    But it's also important for people to understand that when you don't have a thirteenth, you have twelfth, fourteenth floor, you have to ask a question, what happened to the 13th floor? And you need a reason. You need a reason. And when they tell you something that sounds stupid or nonsensical, you tell the person, okay, yeah, you don't have a 13th floor, but you don't have a good reason for that, period. So what am I trying to say is that I was asking myself, "how do I also begin the process of weakening the grip of this superstition in America?" 
    [01:10:00] Because the grip is so fierce that people respond in a snap, they have killed somebody, they have murdered somebody, with impunity. 
    So I said, okay, it is important that I begin the introduction of the subject of critical thinking. Okay, so what did I, what did I do? How actually do you define this becomes a problem.
    So now after going through. Do some research online and trying to understand how to approach it. Because here they teach you critical thinking at the university level. And I want to tell you, Sarah and Josh at the university level, people's minds are formed if people want to get certificate and go and get a job or marry and start family. People are so busy with some other things, they're not really interested in learning, per se. Okay. Yeah. So I said, "no, the approach is wrong. Can we begin a process to introduce this subject from primary schools?" Which is my focus at the moment, and I want you to go [01:11:00] hand in hand with the efforts to tackle harmful superstitions, because one of the elements here is this kind of dogmatism. 
    I was in a car yesterday, somebody was telling me fiercely that they have a charm, anti-bullet charm, that they can use it on my body. I said, "don't use it on my body. Use it on your own. And then you later tell me how it has worked."
    He was defending anti-bullet charm and was telling me that, "look, somebody can shoot you with a bullet, and it will not penetrate." I said, "the person did not shoot you, or he didn't shoot you with a bullet, maybe with water cannons or something like that. I don't know." So what am I trying to say? People are so dogmatic in their superstition, so how do you weaken it, their critical thinking, but how do you deliver critical thinking to primary schools in a way that they will also accept, like science in schools? So that was how I operationalized it. I came up with the idea of rewarded for [01:12:00] generating questions from in all areas of human endeavor. So there isn't something like a right question, wrong question, no. They are rewarded for generating questions based on what they see, what they thought, what they feel, what they taste, and all that. So we started with it, and it's going on pretty well. 
    The critical thinking is an effort to respond in a popular way to this wave of superstition, dogmatism, authoritarianism. So that if people, if from primary schools, pupils are encouraged to question ideas, they're rewarded for questioning ideas, it will predispose them to not blindly accept what people say or what they are taught.
    So that is what I'm doing in the area of critical thinking. It's still challenging, because we still need to translate that [01:13:00] into resources. We still lack the resources, because very often, when they're supporting you from the West, they want to dictate to the minute details what you do. I tell them, "no, give me some liberty to innovate. Give me some liberty to adapt program to suit the environment. Don't dictate as if I don't have a brain." Okay. That's exactly the challenge. So we are discussing ways that we can have that critical thinking to be adapted to suit the needs of Nigerians and Africans. Then non-Africans could draw from it insights, which they could also adapt to enrich their own critical thinking programs.
    So this is part and parcel of what I'm doing. Apart from campaigning against witch persecution, we are also trying to put in place critical thinking programs, training teachers on critical thinking, and also having pilot schools where we do these programs, hoping that at the end of the day, a more critical thinking society [01:14:00] will be less disposed to persecute people in the name of witchcraft. They'll be less disposed to make accusations, and of course they'll be less disposed to take extreme actions like killing and maming of relatives in the name of witchcraft.
    Josh Hutchinson: Thank you to Leo for speaking to the issues occurring in his country and other countries right now. Thank you for coming on our podcast. We hope that we're able to give you some kind of a platform to the best of our ability, and we hope that you find more platforms to get your message out there while you're still where you are needed and doing what you are doing.
    We came out of our conversation with Leo changed, and one of those ways that I changed [01:15:00] is that I have more hope and believe that change can happen quickly, more quickly than I thought was possible. 
    Sarah Jack: And he's, I'm telling you there's a need. Listen to me say that. Listen to me say there's a need and I have the plan. Support me. I heard him, that's what changed. I heard him say that. 
    Josh Hutchinson: It's about hearing Leo and others and it's about getting behind them with the support that they ask for, because Leo knows what he needs. Other leaders in the area know what they need. They don't need people coming in telling them, do this and do that. They just need backing. They need some change to happen in the power structure in their countries to understand the urgency of the situation and to act [01:16:00] as befits that.
    What I got from Leo was just, be bold. Be bold. Change can happen now. You don't have to wait for a culture to change for harmful practices to end.
    Leo needs a voice. Give him your platform if you have one. If you don't, use your social media, use your power of conversation.
    Do like Sarah's been calling us all to act. For four months, she's been calling us to use our social media to share these messages, to amplify these voices, to get out the word that needs to get out. And one of these days, that message will get to the people that need to hear it. And we're hoping that your voices will be part of that. 
    Sarah Jack: And if you're doing that, we will see it and it'll get shared further, because every day we [01:17:00] are messaging and tweeting and putting posts out there. We want them shared and we wanna share what we find, and we look to see what's being said.
    Josh Hutchinson: And follow Leo Igwe on Twitter and Facebook, you can find the Advocacy for Alleged Witches social media, and on Twitter follow @LeoIgwe, @LEOIGWE, as Sarah's been encouraging us all to do. 
    The people in the affected regions should be the primary voices on this. Don't just listen to us, listen to Leo, listen to others like Leo. 
    Sarah Jack: Help us amplify what they're saying. The more we amplify his message, the more time he can spend in person advocating. 
    Josh Hutchinson: Help [01:18:00] us to give him a platform. If you have a platform that can expose Leo's voice and message to more listeners or viewers, we want you to reach out to him and his advocacy and give him a voice in the world. 
    Sarah Jack: When you do that, you're giving a little bit of power back to the children and to the women that are being harmed.
    Josh Hutchinson: We want to challenge all of you listening to just do what you can. Listen to what Leo has to say and then get him on your television show. Get him in your documentary. Get him on your radio station. Get him on your podcast, in your newspaper. Speak with him directly. Let him speak for himself. He's been directly [01:19:00] involved in trying to resolve these cases of violence against alleged witches, and he needs to continue to be involved and gathering other people like himself. More action can be taken directly in the locations where action is needed. Just elevate his voice.
    Remember to tell your friends, colleagues, and everyone you meet about what you heard from Leo today. 
    Sarah Jack: Support Leo's efforts and the efforts for the Advocacy for Alleged Witches.
    Josh Hutchinson: Take action today and have a beautiful tomorrow. 
    [01:20:00] [01:21:00] 
    
  • Witch-Hunting in Modern South Africa with Damon Leff

    https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/2045153.rss

    Show Notes

    Learn with us! Damon Leff of the South African Pagan Rights Alliance Advocacy Against Witch Hunts shares about South Africaโ€™s alleged witch situation. We learn about South Africaโ€™s belief in the occult, magic, witchcraft and muti. This interview considers the common denominators and differences between past and present witchcraft hunts. We discuss how interventions must recognize regional and cultural nuances and the discriminative risks of law reform. โ€œIn South Africa, in almost all cases of accusation of witchcraft, the accused will:
    a. not be offered access to legal defense against the accusations,
    b. not be considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law,
    c. be driven from their communities,
    d. lose their homes as a result of arson,
    e. be forcibly separated from their families, loved ones and friends,
    f. be placed in custody by the South African Police Services, ostensibly for their own safety, spending at least one night in a prison cell to avoid being attacked by members of their own community,
    g. may never return to their homes and communities of birth, and
    h. be forced into unwilling exile in unofficial and unacknowledged refugee camps.โ€
    Links
    Advocacy Against Witch Hunts, South Africa
    Project 135: Review of the Witchcraft Suppression Act 3 of 1957
    Witchcraft Suppression Act 3 of 1957
    Please sign the petition to exonerate those accused of witchcraft in Connecticut
    Connecticut Witch Trial Exoneration Project
    End Witch Hunts Movement
    Join us on Discord to share your ideas and feedback.

    Website
    Twitter
    Facebook
    Instagram
    LinkedIn
    YouTube
    TikTok
    Discord
    Buzzsprout
    Mailchimp
    Support the show

    Transcript

    [00:00:00] 
    Josh Hutchinson: This is Thou Shalt Not Suffer: The Witch Trial Podcast. Happy New Year, and welcome to our first episode of 2023. I'm Josh Hutchinson. 
    Sarah Jack: And I'm Sarah Jack. 
    Josh Hutchinson: Today's guest is Damon Leff of the South African Pagan Rights Alliance. We're going to be speaking with him about their project Advocacy Against Witch Hunts. 
    Sarah Jack: Because you like the show and our guests, please share with your friends, family, and followers.
    Josh Hutchinson: I hope you're all enjoying a nice 2023 and had festive holiday [00:01:00] season and aren't too cold.
    Sarah Jack: We're barely into the year, and I've already had a birthday, Josh. 
    Josh Hutchinson: Wow. Happy birthday, Sarah. 
    Sarah Jack: Thank you. 
    Josh Hutchinson: Sarah's our very own New Year's baby.
    In this new year, we're bringing to you a new subject. You've heard Sarah speak in her news reports about the crisis in South Africa and other nations around the world, and today we focus on modern-day witchcraft accusations and violence in South Africa. 
    Sarah Jack: We're able to start talking about this with you. Damon reached out to us after the launch of our podcast. After hearing our interest in sharing world witch-hunt news, he introduced himself to us and started sharing his [00:02:00] background and some powerful things that have been happening over there, and we are just so glad that we heard from him. Damon is helping us look through a new lens at his country.
    Josh Hutchinson: Our conversations with Damon have been instrumental in the formation of our nonprofit, End Witch Hunts, which aims, through education of witch-hunts, both historical and modern-day, to curb the current crisis of accusations and violence against those alleged to have committed witchcraft. We hope through our group that we can amplify voices like Damon's, like Leo Igwe's, these other activists in the countries most affected by the witchcraft accusations. 
    Sarah Jack: Our [00:03:00] conversation with Damon is always an open door. At any time I have a question, he is willing to give me information and support. So this is the type of collaboration that is going to power the currents that are making the changes. Each of these countries have their own specific struggles around stopping Witch Hunts or improving their response for alleged witches who have been through horrible circumstances, but talking and sharing and teaching builds creative solutions. It brings experiences from different communities. End Witch Hunts wants to hear voices like Leo [00:04:00] and Damon, who are actively experiencing the witch accusation atmosphere of their country and looking for solutions.
    Josh Hutchinson: Conversations like the one we have with Damon today are so critical in helping those of us who are not in the countries affected by witchcraft accusations to understand what the situation is and what needs to be done. It's important for us to echo their voices and amplify their message and support them in whatever way they need us to or want us to ask us to. We want to, stand with them against this activity, but it's important to let those [00:05:00] in the affected nations do what they need to do without getting in their way and trying to tell them what to do from the outside. They're on the ground. They've got the experience. They know the cultures, they know the language, they know the situation, they know the people involved, and they know how to get things done. So we want to just give them a platform for their voice to be heard and just stand behind them as they do this important work. 
    Sarah Jack: In this episode, you're going to hear from Damon the action that he and his alliance have been taking to make progress and get important things done for their community.
    Josh Hutchinson: You're going to learn some of the history of the [00:06:00] Witchcraft Suppression Act that's on the books right now. You're going to learn the background and some details about how the accusations are made, why they're made, who makes them, what the result is when the accusations are made, and you're also going to learn the hopeful side of things from Damon, that voices are being heard speaking out against witchcraft accusations and change is likely. He has told us that witchcraft accusations are declining in South Africa.
    Sarah Jack: When you're hearing about some of the situations, the common denominators really pop out. Listen to those, think about how what you're hearing may be reminiscent of [00:07:00] historical witch-hunts in New England and what does that mean for what we need to do for the communities and countries that aren't able to move forward right now against witchcraft violence.
    Josh Hutchinson: Many in these nations are motivated by fear the same way that those involved in historic witchcraft accusations were motivated by fear. Knowing the modern-day situation gives you insight into the past, and knowing the past gives you insight into the present. And that's why we believe strongly in witch trial education. We believe it's important to understand what's happened before and what's happening now, so that we can eliminate these harmful practices related to witchcraft accusations [00:08:00] and prevent similar injustice from occurring in our own countries and elsewhere in the world. 
    Sarah Jack: And now Josh is going to share background information on this episode's topic.
    Josh Hutchinson: Before we talk to Damon, I wanna give you a little background on a couple of the things that we'll be talking about. First, I'll describe the history of the Witchcraft Suppression Act, and then I'm going to tell you about the Occult Related Crimes Unit of the South African Police Service.
    The history of the Witchcraft Suppression Act goes back to the British Witchcraft Act of 1735, which prohibited witch-hunts and executions, but also outlawed pretending, in the words of the law, to use supernatural or occult powers. [00:09:00] Between 1604, when a previous witchcraft act was passed which encouraged witch-hunting and 1735, sentiments towards witch-hunting had changed enough that the authorities believed that more harm was caused by fraudulent magical practitioners preying upon the poor and selling them a false bill of goods. And so they got rid of the killing of alleged witches and decided to focus on fraud .
    That law, the Witchcraft Act of 1735, took effect in parts of southern Africa when the British occupied the Cape of Good Hope in 1795, and that law applied during subsequent British occupations [00:10:00] and remained in place following the 1814 ceding of the Cape of Good Hope from Netherlands to Britain. In 1886, the law was succeeded by the Native Territories' Penal Code, which prohibited witchcraft accusations, witch-finding, employing so-called "witch doctors," using harmful magic, and using medicines with the intent to injure.
    The 1886 law was then replaced by the Witchcraft Suppression Act of 1895, which was much the same, but also deemed all payment for witchcraft services to have been the result of fraud. In 1957, the Union of South Africa passed a new Witchcraft Suppression Act, which maintained prohibitions on witchcraft accusations, witch-finding, and harmful [00:11:00] witchcraft practices, while adding provisions outlawing identifying as a witch or taking money to pretend, in the language of the law, to use supernatural or occult powers.
    That law has been irregularly enforced over time, with the police sometimes being able to act on witchcraft accusations and witch finding, but other times being behind the ball. And that act, through its provision to outlaw identifying as a witch, does not permit persons practicing Wicca or other pagan faiths to identify as witches.
    In 1992, the South African Police Service established an Occult Related Crimes Unit. This outfit was [00:12:00] initially led by Dr. Kobus Jonker and was created in reaction to South Africa's Satanic Panic, being empowered to investigate crimes with supposed connections to occult or satanic activity. When Jonker retired, he was officially replaced by Attie Lamprecht but has apparently continued to serve. In 2006, Lamprecht announced that the unit was disbanded. However, later investigations revealed that the unit was merely reorganized and renamed the Harmful Religious Practices Unit and made up of officers trained in occult crime investigations by Jonker.
    We'll hear from Damon about how they're fighting the Witchcraft Suppression Act, trying to get it repealed. However, the South African Law Reform Commission is recommending that the current law be repealed but be [00:13:00] replaced with a new Prohibition of Harmful Practices and Unlawful Accusations of Harmful Witchcraft Practices Act, which would prohibit witchcraft accusations, witch-finding, crimes associated with harmful witchcraft, and muti killings, which are murders performed to make medicine from human body parts.
    The changes would be to eliminate the provisions outlawing self-identification as a witch and claims to possess supernatural powers or occult skills or knowledge, and to add the provision dealing with muti murder. As we'll hear from Damon, muti murder is a problem but can be dealt with in other ways than a new, basically a new Witchcraft Suppression Act. It's murder [00:14:00] for the sake of murder, and we'll talk to Damon about that. And it should be against the law against murder and against the law against trafficking human tissues, and Damon argues those laws that are currently on the books should be enough to deal with muti murder and other harmful actions committed peripherally to witchcraft. It's good that they'll still prohibit witchcraft accusations and witch-finding. They just need to enforce those elements of the law. 
    Sarah Jack: Josh, thank you for introducing important details that will be discussed in this episode. 
    Josh Hutchinson: You're welcome. I hope it's of some value to the listeners to clarify [00:15:00] the situation before we get into the details with Damon.
    Sarah Jack: I'm so happy to welcome Damon Leff of South African Pagan Rights Alliance and Advocacy Against Witch Hunts.
     It's been extremely enriching for us to start to grasp the context of what's going on there. My mind has really started doing a lot of things, so I know this conversation's gonna be really important to my knowledge.
    Josh Hutchinson: And to our audience. 
    Damon Leff: Hopefully, they can begin to piece connections between past events and current events and see similarities. I can already see similarities. The question that keeps being asked is what drives people to make accusations of witchcraft, and that's different for each context. Each place has its own unique variables that cause people to make accusations of witchcraft, but they are common denominators, [00:16:00] beginning to piece those together, which is why your podcasts have really helped do that.
    Sarah Jack: That's what we want. And consulting with so many different researchers and such a variety of individuals is so critical now. So we're really glad we started stepping down the path the way we did. 
    Damon Leff: Good. 
    Josh Hutchinson: What is the South African Pagan Rights Alliance?
    Damon Leff: The South African Pagan Rights Alliance is, at the moment, a paralegal advocacy organization. We started out as an informal gathering of like-minded individuals who realized that we needed some kind of organization that could help individual pagans challenge incidents of discrimination. And essentially we started out as an activist organization.
    Very few of us had actual any experience, nevermind running an organization, but dealing with issues of [00:17:00] prejudice and discrimination. So we learned what we needed as we went along. And of course, our real focus was learning how to use the voice, the activist's voice, to promote change. And the first way we did that was to challenge media bias against paganism, against witchcraft, as well in the media.
    To give you historical context before our interim constitution in 1994, which guaranteed the right to freedom of religion, and before the final constitution in 1996, there was no law on our statute book which protected the right to religious freedom. And although the Apartheid government did not exhibit any overt prejudice against non-Christian faiths, it was clearly a white Christian nationalist party that governed the country. And so their interests were very much focused on Christianity. [00:18:00] And unfortunately, it wasn't a friendly kind of Christianity. It wasn't an inviting Christianity. It was one that definitely had barriers between those who were in and those who were out.
    And so if you were not Christian, you were on the out camp. And so people who practiced non-normative religions, occultism, people who were involved in magical practices, witches, specifically, were definitely on the outside. And society didn't really cater for them in any way, but this gave an opportunity to people with prejudice within institutions, with instructional institutions in government to begin to promote things like the Satanic Panic, which of course America experienced before we did. But our Satanic panic really hit us in the seventies and the eighties. It became the reason for the Occult Crime Unit's establishment under Colonel Kobus Jonker, and he led faux [00:19:00] investigations into what he alleged were occult crimes. But in the process he and members of his unit, now you must remember that this unit was firmly entrenched within the South African Police Services, so it had the full authority and backing of government. And although there wasn't any law against the practice of non-normative faiths, and again, there was no protection for non-normative faiths, there, there wasn't any real legislative requirement for the South African police service to persecute, harass, discriminate against non-normative faiths.
    But they did that under the Occult Crime Unit, and the prejudice led to the publishing of a series of articles by members of the unit on alternate faiths, specifically on witchcraft, on the practice of occultism, the practice of magic. The content of these articles were not based on reality or fact. It wasn't as if they interviewed members of those faiths to find out what they believe or what they [00:20:00] practice. The approach was "Jesus is a salvation for all people who are not Christian. And these people are clearly worshiping the devil. They are satanists, and, therefore, they need to be saved." That was the philosophical motivation for the funding of the Occult Crime Unit. 
    So much of our first years, first 10 years of our existence we spent a lot of time browsing through media, published media and online media, and we began to challenge the ideology of the unit itself. We were partly safe because of the interim constitution. The 1994 Constitution gave us some kind of protection from persecution, direct persecution. So that's how we began the Alliance by challenging media prejudice. Eventually, we got to know a couple of the journalists, we got to know the editors of newspapers, and they began to see what we were saying about prejudice narrative. And they began to reject the prejudicial narratives, [00:21:00] because they were clearly not based in any kind of reality. This eventually led us to realize that we needed to get more involved in actual cases of discrimination.
    So I studied law in my late fifties. I started studying law and became a paralegal. And currently what we are doing is we are training members of the Pagan community in South Africa to become community paralegals. So giving them the tools and the skills that they need to actually directly challenge the incidents of discrimination within their communities. This way, it's far easier to respond to incidents of discrimination. We simply need to pick up a phone and say the person is having this problem with employer, family, police, and they can intervene. That's our goal. We would like to work toward that. We spent most of our existence challenging discrimination against, religious discrimination from Christians, and then we [00:22:00] focused our attention in 2007 on the repeal of the Witchcraft Suppression Act. 
    Josh Hutchinson: It was the first time I heard of the Occult Crimes Unit, and I find that detail fascinating.
    Damon Leff: I think they lost their reason to exist once the 1996 Constitution was enacted, because the Constitution expressly protects the right to religious freedom, belief, and opinion, and so they couldn't hold a partisan Christian position any longer. They certainly couldn't base any of their police activities on that partisan religious position. They needed to start looking at issues like equality, the right to dignity. So that certainly helped us, and eventually it took the steam out of the crime unit itself, because they no longer had any reason to exist. 
    Sarah Jack: What can you tell us about the current crisis? 
    Damon Leff: I'm happy [00:23:00] to say that in 2022 we haven't had one reported incident of a witch-hunt in our country, which is probably the first time since before two thousands, we started keeping records of incidents of witchcraft accusations that led to violent Witch Hunts in 2000 and every year we watched the numbers increase, decrease. It was sporadic. 
    Accusations of witchcraft in our country are sporadic, unlike in America where there were focused, targeted in specific areas, where law enforcement got involved, where there were actual trials. In South Africa, accusations of witchcraft are sporadic. They happen within communities across the country. And very often the accused is summarily killed, executed, whether stoned to death, killed with a machete, set on fire in a house, often with family members, long before the police even get involved. So the reports very often are post [00:24:00] event. 
    We've kept track of horrific incidents of accusations of witchcraft against mostly women. There have been exceptions of men. Thankfully, I can only recall one accusation against a child, unlike a Nigeria, where many accusations of child witchcraft occur. In South Africa, that doesn't seem to be a feature of accusations of witchcraft. 
    Listening to your podcast over the last couple of months has raised for me the issue of context and how certain witchcraft accusations happen in certain places around the world at certain times. Certainly we can see common denominators. In South Africa, it's difficult to find a common denominator between individual incidents other than people exhibiting emotional angst, moral panic because of unexplained illnesses, unexplained deaths. 
    [00:25:00] Sometimes these belief systems are culturally-based. For example, there are a number of incidences where, accusations of witchcraft were made against goats or crows. Odd animals. Animals that didn't necessarily belong in the village, that suddenly appeared randomly. One could say that those accusations were motivated by a cultural belief system, a folklore. In the most horrific cases, there were sudden deaths in a village, and an old woman who may not have been liked by that particular family was accused. 
    Now, most accusations are instantaneous. One family will accuse another family, and, of course, if one person in their family is accused, the entire family is implicated in the accusation, because in African traditional culture, there is a belief that witchcraft runs through the breast, which means that if the mother is a witch, her children will be a witch because of breastfeeding. [00:26:00] So the family doesn't escape the consequence of that accusation. 
    And in one particular incident, an old lady was accused of a major accident, in which the son of a neighboring woman was killed, and she was accused of having cast a spell on the road in which that accident occurred. And at the time of the accusation, the entire village surrounded her house. She was inside, her older daughter was inside, her older daughter's two children were inside. They were all killed. They were all murdered, one with machete, one was set alight. The two children were trapped in the house when the house was set alight. Horrific. 
    These are the incidents that nobody can intervene immediately to prevent, because they occur in communities in which nobody will question the narrative that one, their misfortune was caused by witchcraft, that therefore there must be a witch, a local, [00:27:00] somebody with whom you've possibly had an argument in the past, somebody with whom you've possibly not really gotten on. Perhaps that person came from a village outside recently and moved into your area. So it's a complicated phenomena. I wouldn't say that those same motivations occur in every instance of accusation, but that seems to be a common thread. They're random, sporadic moments of panic that lead to the death of someone.
    Thankfully, our police do intervene. In rare cases where, they are very rare, where a woman has been accused, she may in time or her family members may in time contact the local police, and the local police will then intervene. Unfortunately, the local police haven't really been trained ever to deal with these kinds of incidences, and so the only alternative for the police, the only action they can take is [00:28:00] to take that person outside of the village and put them in a prison cell for the evening for their own safety, which is horrific. To think that the accused must sit in a prison cell for her own safety for the evening. Almost all of those cases do end up in criminal courts. Thankfully, our criminal courts have looked very badly on accusations of witchcraft. Sentences haven't been as strong as they could have been.
    And more recently there was an incident in a case in court, in which the accused claimed as mitigation in sentencing, that he only did what he did because he believed that this woman was a Witch. He believed in witchcraft as a bad thing, and this was a cultural belief that he held, and the magistrate gave him a lesser sentence because of his mitigating circumstances, which of course we've criticized because we don't think that's [00:29:00] appropriate. If you want to discourage accusations of witchcraft, you need to increase sentencing, not take a belief in witchcraft as a mitigating factor.
    Josh Hutchinson: How do the local communities find the witch suspect? How do they determine who was the alleged? 
    Damon Leff: In South Africa, we call it witch-finding. And the legislators have been using that term in the Witchcraft Suppression Act. So that entails, if for example, you've made an accusation against the neighbor, but you are uncertain and you want some clarity, you will go to the local diviner. The local diviner is either called an insangoma. Sometimes the nyanga, the herbalist, will also act as a diviner, but usually it's a very specialist field. In traditional African religion the use of herbs to make medicine for healing and the aspect of divination are very often separated, but not always. So in this case, the family [00:30:00] would seek out the local diviner. The local diviner would then throw bones, speak to the ancestors and ask the ancestors to confirm or deny the suspicion. Ultimately, unfortunately, always there's a confirmation, and that will then automatically lead to an attack a concerted attack against the accused person.
    Customary history is a really tricky subject for anyone to pronounce factually about, because customary history is memory. It's a verbal and oral history. It hasn't really been written down. So experts in the field have been saying that prior to the arrival of European colonialists, African traditional belief systems dealt with accusations of witchcraft in a concerted way. When there was a suspicion, the diviner was called in to confirm the suspicion, a local tribal court would then be set up, the accused would be taken to the local [00:31:00] tribal court. The accused was not entitled to any kind of defense, so he or she had to defend themselves. An older family member may have assisted, but that would've been very dangerous, especially if the old family member would've insisted that person was innocent. They could very well have been implicated in the accusation as well. And then tribal courts would then mete out justice. I do know that, for example, if a husband accused his wife of witchcraft, the tribal court would then divorce them, separate them, and she would then be banished from the village. But in many cases, of course, she might equally have been killed.
    Now because these cultural rules were not uniform across South Africa, remember we have a vast array of different tribes, Zulu, Xhosa, Sepedi, each different group would've had their own variations on these cultural rules. They all believed in the general malevolence of witchcraft, so an accusation of witchcraft may have arisen [00:32:00] in any one of these places.
    With the arrival of colonialism, of course, we have a hybrid legal system. First the Dutch arrived, and they imposed Roman Dutch law. Now, amongst magistrates in Cape Town who imposed Roman Dutch law, and of course it was company law that was being imposed, essentially, accusations of witchcraft were not tolerated, so they were never heard, and they were summarily dismissed. 
    When the English arrived and took over the Cape Colony, English law acknowledged that accusations of witchcraft existed, because they had dealt with their own history of accusations of witchcraft. And they had heard cases of accusations of witchcraft, but they took a very dim view of the accusers. They did not in any way give credence to the notion that real witches existed or that such persons had power to affect the world through non-natural or supernatural means. [00:33:00] So the accuser, the maker of the accusation, was generally convicted and sentenced. 
    In 1957, we had just become a union, I think, and the 1957 Witchcraft Suppression Act was established. It was basically a copy of British witchcraft legislation, which on the one hand denied that one could be a witch or that witches had power. So therefore, making an accusation of witchcraft became a punishable offense. But at the same time, it made confessing to being a witch also a punishable offense. Under current law, Magistrate's Courts still often refer to the Witchcraft Suppression Act when dealing with accusations of witchcraft, and they apply the sentencing given in the Witchcraft Suppression Act for incidents.
    Sarah Jack: What effects do witch attacks have on the surviving [00:34:00] families? 
    Damon Leff: As I mentioned, the notion that witchcraft comes through the breast. When an individual in a family is accused, the entire family is suspect. Everybody in that immediate family is endangered. The potential accusation of witchcraft could be leveled against any one of them. So there is a hesitancy to defend the person who is accused, which is horrific. This immediately creates tension between members within a family. If a member of that family is accused and murdered, the entire family needs to leave. It's impossible for that family to continue to live in the same area. They will always be suspected of harboring this dark power of witchcraft. And so they need to leave the village that they live in. Very often, they would travel to a neighboring village, hopefully reaching that village [00:35:00] before news of the incident reaches that village. Because if the news of that incident reaches the village before they do, they would be denied entry to that village. 
     I remember, I think it was about 20 years ago, there was a documentary, Carte Blanche, a famous documentary. A film in SABC showed a couple, an old woman, an old lady, and her husband who had for a year been wandering from village to village, looking for a place where they could reestablish, because every time they arrived at a new place, there were family members of the previous village from which they had come. And so they couldn't stay there. 
    And that's the horrific part of it, the shame. And it isn't. We call it shame, because that's how these people feel, but it isn't really a shameful thing to be a victim of an accusation. The accuser should be shamed, but the shame, they carry that shame with them, [00:36:00] and probably they would carry that shame with them through generations, because we are never dealing with just husband and a wife. We're dealing with a husband and a wife who has, African families always live together, except in cities where there is some separation. In traditional communities, families live together. Grandmother, grandfather, daughter, husband, children, grandchildren, all live in the same place. So it's a literal move of an entire family, generations of a family. 
    But it doesn't just affect the family that's accused. It affects everybody in that village. The chaos unleashed by an accusation affects the youngest members of that entire village. That's traumatic. It has to be traumatic for young children to see this kind of violence and aggression, not completely to understand what's happening. And it will forever form a scar on that particular [00:37:00] group. I don't think that 10 years down the line, they could look back at what they did and feel okay with it. It's difficult for me to conceive that.
    Josh Hutchinson: In traditional African practices, are there actually people for whom it's appropriate to use the label "witch?"
    Damon Leff: A very good question, and it's one that we have discussed with traditional healers who joined us in our discussions on the repeal of the Witchcraft Suppression Act. In 2007, on behalf of the South African Pagan Rights Alliance, I initiated a review of the Witchcraft Suppression Act with the South African Law Reform Commission, and traditional healers were invited to join the discussion, pre-discussion, on whether or not that act should be repealed. And overall, the traditional healers felt that they agreed with us that the act should be repealed, but for very different reasons. 
    And in our first initial discussions, we were trying to find [00:38:00] common ground, and we did find a lot of common ground. As pagan witches and traditional healers and traditional African religion, we share an enormous amount of common belief systems. We could call them folk belief systems, but the differences were also as stark. Phephisile Maseko, who was at the time the national coordinator for the Traditional Healers Organisation, the THO's one of the largest organizations representing traditional healers in South Africa. She explained that, within her organization, they had specialists who dealt specifically with issues of witchcraft, who dealt specifically with defining around issues of witchcraft and then creating charms to counter witchcraft. 
    So for us, that would be, it reminds us of folk beliefs, folk magic used to counter negative witchcraft. And I asked, do you identify those people as [00:39:00] practitioners of magic, witchcraft? Definitely not, she said. Witchcraft is a negative word. Witchcraft means you harm someone using supernatural means. It never, ever means a positive. Nobody ever identifies as a witch, because it means you are admitting to harming other people.
    Now, there is a huge problem here in that we are speaking English and they speak Zulu and Suju and Xhosa, and they have their own terms for that specific practice. And perhaps in their mind it does actually accord with the idea of a folk magic practitioner who uses white magic to counter dark magic. But that didn't come through in our conversation, certainly not in our English conversation.
    So that's a question that still needs to be explored. [00:40:00] But as a rule, if you're a black African, you don't identify as a witch. What I've seen in a forum on Facebook for witches is that there are more and more younger black South Africans who are looking at paganism, European paganism. It's for them not unfamiliar because they see commonality between the traditional African religion, which their grandparents and mothers were raised. And they see a lot of commonalities, a lot of similarities, but they're more and more attracted to the archetype of the witch and witchcraft, the practice of witchcraft. And they're very open about it on the forum, but of course, we are mindful that they all live in very conservative families and that they actually are in danger. I don't think any of them admit to their parents that they have decided to become a witch, that they want to practice witchcraft. 
    So there still is definitely that fear around the word. And avoidance of [00:41:00] identifying the term with the term, using the term. In our review of the Witchcraft Suppression Act, for example, at one stage we made a point of reminding the commission that when dealing with accusations of witchcraft, they need to remember that we are self-identified witches. So we should be accorded the right to define what witchcraft means for us and our identification.
    Our definition of what witchcraft is or means for us should actually carry more weight than the definition of accusations or the definition of witchcraft that is, are used in accusations. I'll give you a simple example. X might accuse Y of summoning a Tokaloshe to steal the milk from her car. Now a Tokoloshe is a local variant of a gnome or an elf, [00:42:00] a nature spirit that is attached to a magic worker and that serves the magic worker as a slave. And the magic work can send the slave out cause harm or mischief. We see those stories in European folklore. We see it in American folklore. The question is, is the belief in a Tokoloshe less valid than the European belief in elves and fairies? But is the belief that all women who are witches evil less valid than the acknowledgement that people are not evil because of what they are, but because of what they do? 
    We've been trying to encourage them not to stereotype people simply because we've named them witches. And this is where traditional healerism and actual witches have found conflict, sources of conflict, because they don't want to give up their prejudicial [00:43:00] definition of what a witch is. For them it's a cultural belief system, and it's as important for them as our religious ideology and identity is for us. So there is source of conflict there. 
    Sarah Jack: Why is the targeted group mostly vulnerable people, especially women and elderly women in particular? 
    Damon Leff: I wish I could answer that question. I think their vulnerability makes them easy targets. I think their vulnerability means they don't have any influence over their community. They don't have any power. The power relationship is, they are useless, not important, negligible. I think essentially it comes down to that. In South Africa, we have an extremely epidemic level of gender-based violence against women, specifically by their male partners. And I think that is an aspect of it.
    Why older women [00:44:00] are often the targets of witchcraft accusation, and of course, it's not exclusively older women, but older women generally become, are more, more likely to become targets of witchcraft accusation, because of that power dynamic. Government has attempted to deal with gender-based violence by appealing to the conscience of men, and I'm not sure that's going to work. I don't see the same man who is behaving violently toward a woman waking up the following morning and thinking, "oh wow, I think I should become a better person." So I don't know how we reestablish the power balance between men and older women in traditional societies. Older, traditional African societies are patriarchal. They're governed by men, not by a woman. It's very rare that an older woman would have authority over the men in a village. So that is an important factor to consider.
    Josh Hutchinson: So is it [00:45:00] usually men who are making the accusations?
    Damon Leff: No. Both men and women make accusations of witchcraft. The incident I told you about, the old woman who was accused of casting a spell on the road that caused the accident, that accusation was made by the mother of the guy who was killed in the truck. No, the accusations can come from anybody. I haven't seen any accusations originating from children, but yeah, definitely men and women can make accusations of witchcraft. 
    We've also seen accusations of witchcraft being labeled at traditional healers, far fewer than one would think is the norm. But sometimes traditional healers will make accusations of witchcraft against other traditional healers, and that tells us that perhaps there is more economics at play. They're vying for the same commerce. 
    There was also an incident where a local priest who ran a small church in an urban area, there was a rumor going around that he [00:46:00] kept snakes in his church and that he used the snakes as charms against his petitioners, and his church was attacked, and they wanted to kill him, because he was now a witch. The association between snakes and witches is very common in Africa. In much of central and northern Africa, the snake is the power animal that gives the witch her or his power. Yeah, accusations of witchcraft are largely irrational in that they can come from anyone and affect anyone.
    Sarah Jack: What non legislative interventions are necessary to deal with harmful witchcraft practices?
    Damon Leff: I've always held that if we don't challenge the narratives that lead to accusations, we don't have any hope in any kinds of legislation preventing violence. It's the same with gender-based violence. If we don't teach men to honor the dignity of women,[00:47:00] no matter how many laws we pass to punish men for committing violence against women, I doubt very much if that violence is going to stop.
    Men need to begin to look at women in a different way. And likewise, people who make accusations of witchcraft need to begin to look at the subject in a different way. It's arrogant of me to suggest that we should impose a scientific way of thinking about the world on to African people who are still bound to their cultural beliefs about witchcraft, but I'm afraid that's the only way to do it. We need to challenge the narratives around witchcraft. The idea that a person can be born evil from birth, because there they're witches, whether they're male or female. That idea is contrary [00:48:00] to the notion of from the moment of birth, we have a right to dignity, that our birth doesn't determine who we become. It doesn't determine what we end up doing. We are not just because we've been accused of being a witch from birth automatically evil. We may be very good people. We may end up doing wonderful things for a lot of people. So we need to begin to challenge those narratives, and that can only be done on a very local level, on a grassroots level. That means that people who have trust, who have the power dynamic in those communities need to be the ones to have those conversations. Priests, traditional leaders, traditional healers themselves, need to begin to have those conversations. 
    Can we look, for example, at the cultural narrative that we've inherited from our ancestors about witchcraft? And can we [00:49:00] challenge it? Is it true? Is everything that our ancestors told us about witches true? Tricky because all of these communities are built on veneration of ancestors. The ancestors are perfect. What they did cannot be challenged, cannot be questioned. So that narrative needs to be challenged and questioned.
    That's the only way I see any kind of real change. I think by offering an alternative narrative on the subject generally does help, and it certainly has helped in attracting a younger audience to the study of magic and witchcraft generally. I don't know if that alternative narrative is going to actually get through to older generations, hopefully sufficiently so to make them stop and think, "my, my son has just died suddenly. Is it really witchcraft, or was there an underlying physiological cause for his illness?" [00:50:00] And that's gonna have to be a multifaceted approach to the subject. It's certainly not something that European witches can dictate. That would just be rude. 
    Josh Hutchinson: I think that's important what you said, that the traditional leaders in the communities need to inspire that change. And you've also talked about the legal side of it and how you got involved with the Law Reform Commission to review the Witchcraft Suppression Act of 1957. What can you tell us about the Witchcraft Suppression Act and the review that's going on?
    Damon Leff: The review, the initial request was in February 2007. In January 2016, the commission concluded that the Act's prohibition of identifying as a witch and practicing divinations were unconstitutional. Okay. And, essentially the commission has confirmed [00:51:00] that they are in favor of a repeal of the Witchcraft Suppression Act.
    Most of the organizations and individuals who submitted comment to the review process has supported a repeal of the act, most except for traditional healers. Traditional healers want the act to be repealed, but they want the act to be replaced with an act that will essentially give them the right to take accusations of witchcraft within their communities to a traditional court, which rings alarm bells in my ears, because it reminds me instantly of Salem. It reminds me instantly of cases of witchcraft being heard in a court, not by a court who's going to apply a skeptical approach to the subject, but by a court who is going to appeal to cultural authority, to ancestral authority to hear those cases. [00:52:00] So this is something that we felt we needed to object to, which we did. We did send you a copy of our draft objection. And we challenged the draft bull that the traditional healers presented and the commission published for comment by pointing out that the definition of the bold was called a Prohibition of Harmful Practices and Unlawful Accusations of Harmful Witchcraft practices bull.
    Now, the bull defines harmful witchcraft practice as invoking a claim to the ability to use non-natural or supernatural means, whether that involves the use of physical elements or not, to threaten or to cause death or injury or disease or disability or destruction or loss of damage to property of any kind or severe psychological distress or terror. On the face of it, the definition is a mouthful, but when you break it down, [00:53:00] essentially it is based on two terms, non-natural or supernatural means, and we've challenged those two as being irrational. Our courts need to present admissible evidence that is rational, that can be proven, and our opinion, we've never seen a court be able to prove non-natural or supernatural needs. There is no way to prove supernatural agency. So essentially, the definition of harmful witchcraft practice comes down to making a claim to have supernatural power or threatening someone with a claim that one has supernatural power and one can hurt, and neither of those claims can be supported, in essence, they're beliefs.
    Now the Constitution gives everybody the right to believe freely. It doesn't matter how irrational it is. Our constitutional court [00:54:00] has clearly stipulated that it doesn't matter if we think the belief is entirely irrational. People have the right to believe it, but it doesn't mean that a court should hear it as factual. All the court can prove, at the most, is that somebody believes this. A court cannot prove that somebody who believes in God is, ipso facto proof that God exists. There's a difference between proving that someone believes in a God and proving that the God exists. Allowing someone to bring an accusation of witchcraft to a court of law is ridiculous, because there is no way that anybody can prove the agency of witchcraft involved. We can prove that someone has made an accusation, but we can't prove there is any supernatural agency.
     The second part of that, of course, is that making a threat, threatening someone by saying that, "oh, I have supernatural power. I'm gonna curse you and your family," [00:55:00] essentially, is an act of intimidation. It's an ordinary act of intimidation. Since we can't prove any supernatural element or agency, we must simply assume that the person is attempting to intimidate the other person. Anybody can intimidate. One doesn't need to be a, a witch to be intimidating. Is there any difference, for example, if a pastor gets up on the pulpit on a Sunday and screams hell and hellfire and threatens people with hell if they don't do the right thing? Is that not intimidating? So our position is anybody can make an intimidation against anyone else. That doesn't necessarily mean that there is any supernatural agency. And if the commission really wants to deal with accusations of witchcraft as intimidation, then it needs to be dealt with in another way. There are common law remedies to intimidation common law remedies to intimidation should be used.
    We, for example, have criminal defamation, which could easily be used to open a criminal defamation [00:56:00] charge against someone who's made an accusation of witchcraft against you. You just need to go to a police station and say, "so-and-so has made an accusation of witchcraft. I want to open a criminal innuere charge." Court takes it further for you. 
    Sarah Jack: What is that shift that's gonna kick that into gear? Does that have to be legislated, push the witchcraft issues under the other laws? 
    Damon Leff: I think once we've gotten rid of the Witchcraft Suppression Act, a question I've often been asked is since we've got the Witchcraft Suppression Act, but actual witches are not being arrested by the police for claiming to have knowledge of witchcraft, which according to the act is illegal. So why do we need to even bother about the act? Clearly it's not targeted at us, but psychologically it is targeted at us, because it tells people generally whether they're consciously aware of it or not, that witchcraft is a taboo subject. Look, there's a law [00:57:00] against it. So therefore people who identify as witches are treated differently.
    Subconsciously, we are treated differently because there is a law against witchcraft. If we take that away, we remove the underpinnings of legitimacy that an accusation of witchcraft could have, for example, where the law supported it. If the law had said, look, we can't deal with these issues, because you have the right to believe whatever you choose to, then suddenly that suspicion disappears. Now, witches are ordinary members of society that can be treated like ordinary members of society. There isn't an unconscious bias already against them for being witches. That would be one step. 
    The question is, how then do we deal with future incidences of accusations of witchcraft? Do we need special legislation to deal with that? And I honestly don't believe that we do, because if we do, we'll end up just reinforcing the biases that we've been carrying with us all along. What we need to do is find [00:58:00] a different way to deal with accusations of witchcraft. 
    Firstly, it's a multi-pronged approach. We need the police to be more proactive. Police need to be trained to deal with incidences of civil violence like this, where one person has been accused unjustly or falsely accused. The police in the past may even have suspected that the accusation was valid and so didn't want to get involved. So police need to be sensitized towards the issues at stake.
    They need to be open to the accused when they come into a police station and to tell them that an accusation of which God has been made against them. They need to be sensitive to that person, not treat that person with suspicion. They need to provide that person with comfort and safety and security.
    There should be a counselor, at least, that person can sit down and talk to, to deal with their anxiety and the experiences that they've just gone through. They should be a social worker to [00:59:00] deal with the crisis that is unfolding within that immediate family. What is going to happen? Are they going to be able to live in the same house tomorrow? And if not, is there alternative accommodation until they can find alternative accommodation? 
    And then the process at the moment is for the accuser to be arrested, arraigned, and charged with offenses under the Witchcraft Suppression Act. In future, I foresee the accused bringing charges against the accuser directly through a common law process, an accusation of criminal innuere. Once the accusation has been made, the police and the court take over, and there is no requirement, there will not be any requirement on the accused person to get an attorney and launch a private action suit. So the state will still take care of it, just in a different way, without the intervention of the Witchcraft Suppression Act.
    Let the common law deal with it. A criminal innuere charge is quite a serious charge. The [01:00:00] penalty could also include imprisonment. I think that's a good way to start with it. Keep promoting wholesome integrative narratives in the media about the subject. Keep encouraging traditional healers and traditional leaders to engage with their communities in a positive way, to offer them alternative narratives, to question the motives of accusations, to find alternative ways to settle disputes within communities. So a process, certainly not an overnight one.
    Sarah Jack: Legislating a new law isn't a bandaid either.
    Damon Leff: No, it's never going to be. We've had the 1957 act for how many years, 50 years plus, and it hasn't prevented accusations of witchcraft. One authority, an academic, who submitted a paper when the review [01:01:00] process first began, suggested that the existence of the act itself motivates the accusations, which I touched on briefly. Having an act that says being a witch is illegal or making accusations is illegal kind of encourages people to make accusations. I don't think legislation will ever bring an end to crime. The best thing that legislation can ever hope to do is deal with the after effects of the criminal act, is to provide justice, social justice, a restorative justice to the victims. But it could never prevent those crimes from happening. 
    Sarah Jack: The supports you were talking about for the victims when they go in, having a counselor, having solutions, that sounds like the supports that have come to be important for victims of sexual assault. Do you guys have those in place for those types of crimes now? And then that can be a model for [01:02:00] supporting accused witches, because it's the same. It's that whole thing. It's that shameful stigma that is there, the trauma that's occurred to the innocent individual, and then the future. They're walking into the future now with these wounds. 
    Damon Leff: You're absolutely right. And yes, we do have a model that we can follow. Recently the Minister of Justice instituted child courts and courts that deal specifically with gender-based violence. Those courts are staffed, hopefully, with social workers, with somebody who can approach the victim on a real level, offer support, comfort.
     The victim doesn't simply want justice. They're suffering from psychological trauma. And there is no difference, as you say, in practice between a victim of rape and a victim of accusation of witchcraft, especially not after they've been beaten and threshed and maybe [01:03:00] lost a family member.
    The anxiety, the fear, the trauma, I don't think we sh we can compare the trauma, but I think the trauma is equal, so yes, hopefully that could become a model, or hopefully crimes targeted specifically at women, accusations of witchcraft crimes targeted a women could be dealt with in exactly the same way that victims of gender-based violence are dealt with. 
    Josh Hutchinson: When you were talking about how the commission wants to replace the existing Witchcraft Suppression Act with a new bill against witchcraft and you were talking about how ineffective the Witchcraft Suppression Act has been at dealing with the violence, reading the Commission's report, it seemed like they admitted that the existing law's been ineffective, but then they're still saying, we need a new law that's basically the same thing. So why do you think that is [01:04:00] that they're speaking out of both sides of their mouth? 
    Damon Leff: I think the commission is attempting to appease clearly two camps. There is the camp which includes us who agree that the Witchcraft Suppression Act should be repealed, who don't think that we need any other legislation to deal with issues that we are currently dealing with.
    Almost all of those people have also said, look, let the common law deal with it. We have common law remedies. They're quicker, they're more efficient, let them deal with it. But then there is definitely the other camp, the traditional healers, the Family Policy Institute, there were a couple of other smaller organizations.
    The gender commission insisted on including muti crimes under this new witchcraft bull. Now, muti crimes, I have to explain. These are violent incidences in which a traditional healer most often employs the use of thugs or criminals to kidnap, [01:05:00] mutilate and kill, in that order, kidnap, mutilate and kill persons, humans for body parts for later use in magic, let's say muti, which means medicine, but essentially it's negative folk magic. And the process has generally dealt with our courts as a crime, simple common law crime, murder and the illegal possession of human body parts. So there is no real need for additional legislation to deal with those crimes. They are heard in our criminal courts. Those responsible are convicted and sentenced to prison.
    The gender commission felt that, I think they were motivated more by the increasing violence against women in our society, and this muti murders is one particular way in which women in our society are brutalized, especially young girls because it's generally children who are targeted [01:06:00] for some reason. So they felt that it, perhaps it would be the opportune moment to get some kind of legislation against muti murders, because we've never had specific legislation against this kind of crime. As I said, because the common law deals with it already. 
    And so they included muti murders as a a harmful witchcraft practice, which is just laughable. And I'll explain why. I've looked at cases in our criminal courts involving muti murders and nowhere, not in any cases stretching back over 20 years, has any accused person in those cases identified as a witch. Nowhere has any person identified as being a practitioner of witchcraft. So why make murders a harmful witchcraft practice?
    Is the commission using the term harmful witchcraft practice as a convenient catch-all to deal [01:07:00] with all the other crimes that haven't actually been legislated against yet? Because that's our approach, that's our opinion. We clearly explain to the commission that witches are not responsible for muti murders. That witchcraft itself, the practice of witchcraft, is not involved in muti murders. Traditional healers, the traditional healers who were the initiators of these crimes or who were responsible, found guilty of purchasing human body parts for use later on, did not identify as witches. They certainly didn't identify what they were doing as witchcraft.
    So hopefully the commission will realize that this is not, this has nothing to do with witchcraft or witches. But to get back to your original question, I think the commission is attempting to appease both parties, not wanting to appear to be favoring witches against traditional healers, [01:08:00] especially in our society that is still really divided between white and black.
    So that may be one of the reasons why the commission agreed to include it as an option. But it does beg the question whether the commissioners who decided to include it realized in including it that it was an impossible piece of law, because it was based on a false premise. This idea of there being supernatural powers or that they could be proven in a court of law. I dunno, that's one of the mysteries. I think that we've, we will have successfully convinced the commission not to adopt the recommended bill. I think they only included it to appease the other, other side. 
    Sarah Jack: The definition of terms and the categorizing of behaviors is [01:09:00] been such a murky situation for decades and decades. And this new bill would still have the harmful witchcraft practices not clarified. 
    Damon Leff: But it possibly would help to identify what witchcraft is. And as you saw in the papers, the commission was hesitant to allow itself to define once and for all what witchcraft is, because witches define it in one way and traditional healers define it in exactly the opposite way. And again, it would require the commission to take side. And so it was convenient to just skip over that and not define it at all. But that creates a problem, because it allows the other side to continue to promote that narrative that witches are automatically evil and need to be killed before they harm your family.
    It would be helpful if the commission accepted, and we have a very broad definition of witchcraft. It's not a narrow religious view that [01:10:00] will exclude people who identify as witchcraft in other cultures, as witches in other cultures. We have a very broad definition of witchcraft, which we would like the commission to consider and it was actually included in the paper at some point, very briefly mentioned by them that we had submitted this definition, but then they glossed over it. I think, again, not wanting to offend traditional healers. 
    Sarah Jack: Do you wanna give us that definition?
    Damon Leff: The sympathetic practice of magic, herbalism, and divination, either within a religious context or within a folk magic practice context. And that's a very broad definition that would include all kinds, all forms of witchcraft, whether it was because in Hinduism there is a particular branch of Hinduism, which involves a practice of magic. So you have in India, you have actual witches, Hindu witches, who identify [01:11:00] themselves as witches, because their religion does afford them that kind of practice, that kind of belief system. And that wouldn't exclude them, because they practice a sympathetic form of magic within a religious context and they practice divination.
    Josh Hutchinson: That's very interesting. Wonder what legal challenges would also come up by them not defining the crime accurately. If they don't define witchcraft, how do you prosecute witchcraft? 
    Damon Leff: Precisely, exactly, the principle of legality, if you cannot clearly define a crime, there cannot be a crime. That has been the weakness of the Witchcraft Suppression Act since 1957. The act doesn't define witchcraft, and yet it criminalizes it. So it was convenient then for the word witchcraft to come to mean a whole lot of things, depending on who was dealing with it at the time, and that is the problem [01:12:00] we had historically with the word witchcraft. It means a vast array of different things to different people in different times. 
    Sarah Jack: Why did the commission feel that the European definitions of evil and witch and witchcraft didn't translate well ,because it, when our conversation first started, it sounded like malevolence and evil was a part of fears going way back in traditions.
    Damon Leff: I think the commission doesn't want to offend traditionalists within the African culture, who are attempting to promote African cultural belief systems, including those around witchcraft. Unless though the convention challenges them on the basis of evidence, on rationality, I don't think the commission will, I don't think the commission feels its place to challenge what a person believes. It, it has been very open toward [01:13:00] our approach. It has been very open and accommodating of us expressing who we are as pagan witches. So I think it is trying to show the same kind of dignity to traditional African beliefs that believe in things that aren't necessarily conducive to the rule of law.
    I think the job of challenging those indigenous belief systems belong to the tribal elders and the leaders within those communities. They need to re-look at what they believe in the context of witchcraft.
    Josh Hutchinson: The commission's report, they repeatedly used the word scourge to describe a scourge of harmful witchcraft practices. How do you think they determined that there is a scourge? 
    Damon Leff: The commission doesn't really list harmful witchcraft practices without of course [01:14:00] listing muti murders, which have nothing to do with witchcraft practices. I think that when the commission refers to the scourge of harmful witchcraft practices, they're actually referring to accusations of witchcraft, because they form the most obvious crimes that occur in the context of witchcraft in our country. Of course these are not harmful witchcraft crimes. These are harmful crimes perpetrated against persons falsely suspected of being witches. The commission is still stuck in that contextual frame, harmful witchcraft crimes, which implies that witches or people practicing witchcraft are responsible for those crimes. But perhaps they will shift their narrative once they receive our submission and look at it. 
    Sarah Jack: What would the impact be if they continue to regulate witchcraft?
    Damon Leff: I think it's highly unlikely given the constitution's protection of the right to belief. I think it's [01:15:00] very unlikely that the commission or parliament for that matter, would recommend that we need legislation against the belief in witchcraft or against witchcraft practice or against witches. I don't think that's ever going to happen. 
    The question is whether Parliament is going to accept that the Witchcraft Suppression Act should be repealed and that common law can replace the mechanism of current legislation to deal with accusations of witchcraft. 10 years ago, I would've said I'm doubtful, because of the high number of accusations of witchcraft we were reporting. Today I'm more hopeful, because we see less and less accusations. Part of that process of reducing the number of accusations is the communal effort by traditional leaders and traditional elders to try and minimize moments of conflict, tension [01:16:00] within families or communities where accusations of witchcraft arise.
    And that only came about as a result of the CRL Commission's intervention. That's the Commission for the Promotion of Cultural, Religious, and Linguistic Communities. We approached them to assist us in dealing with the issue of accusations of witchcraft. It was impossible for us to go directly to informal or traditional communities and engage with traditional healers and leaders and say, "look, you have to stop these accusations because we identify as witches."
    We don't have any credibility. We don't, we're not outsiders, we're not unbiased participants. The commission did that on our behalf. It organized a nationally inviso gathering, advised a traditional healers and leaders. Members of Parliament where there. It invited [01:17:00] local government leaders as well. And the commission raised the issue of witchcraft accusations, raised the issue of the harm, the real harms that witchcraft accusations cause, harm to the right to equality, harm to the right to dignity, harm to the right to belief and opinion. All of those issues were discussed over a couple of days. So I think that process began a shift. It began to shift narratives, and it's taken a while for that shift to begin to settle. That doesn't mean that accusations of witchcraft won't happen again. There's always an option. But hopefully that narrative has begun to shift.
    Josh Hutchinson: That would be great. In the Law Reform Commission's report, they seem to admit that the Witchcraft Act hasn't worked and that it's nearly impossible to enforce. So how would a new law be any different? How would it suddenly be enforceable?
    Damon Leff: I agree with you. [01:18:00] I don't think it would. For a start, you would have to get communities, local communities to become aware of a new law, which would prevent accusations of witchcraft, but it wouldn't really be a new law, because all along making accusations of witchcraft has been illegal. So I don't think any new law would have any effect whatsoever. No. 
    And as I said earlier, law doesn't prevent crime. The legislation won't prevent the crimes from occurring. The legislation is there to ensure that those who have been affected by crime can find redress.
    Sarah Jack: I'm very amazed. Not in a positive way, about the complexity of accusing witches. So you have the victims and their families and the community, how it's what they go through, but then how it ripples into the religious community, affecting your faith. In the United States, we talk about [01:19:00] "other" all the time, how our vulnerable "others" are treated like witches. There is this lining here where identifying people as evil has just extensive ramifications across the people. I was thinking about that. 
    Damon Leff: It removes their automatic right to dignity. When we "other" people, we say that those people are "other," they don't have any dignity, they don't need to be treated like us., They don't need to be given the same respect or the same consideration. And it's easy then to scapegoat them for the things that we wanna blame someone for. It's very easy not to take responsibility for our own actions, if we can scapegoat the "other." We are suffering misfortune, not because we are poor and the government is not giving us an opportunity to become wealthy or employed, we are poor because that woman [01:20:00] over there put a spell on us and that's keeping us poor. And we can make that accusation, because that woman isn't a woman, that woman is not part of us, she's not a human, she doesn't deserve the same kind of consideration. We don't even need to ask her. We can just make the accusation.
    So that's what "othering" tends to do. It demonizes and dehumanizes the "other." We can see the same thing happening in conflict between men and women and families where men automatically become abusive to their wives. There is a lack of consideration for the wive's feeling, her right to security, her right to dignity. It's the same pattern. .
    Josh Hutchinson: We've covered a lot of ground, and it's been a very rich and important discussion. What is the status currently of the new bill? Has that gone before the parliament? 
    Damon Leff: [01:21:00] So the bill was not drafted by Parliament. So traditionally for a bill to become legislation, it is drafted by a parliamentary portfolio committee. It is then discussed by the portfolio committee, and if they're happy with it, they will send it to the National Assembly.
    The National Assembly on the first reading is happy with it, it'll then get published in the government gazette for public comment and then will go through its process there. This bill was not, it's not a national assembly bill. It was not drafted by a parliamentary portfolio committee. It was drafted by, I think, traditional healers and given to the law reform commission, or it was drafted through the guidance of traditional healers by commissioners in the Law Reform Commission.
    So it wasn't published in the government gazette. It's not an official piece of legislation. It was simply a proposal. The Law Reform Commission's saying, "look, these people think that we need to replace this act with this bill. Here's an example of what [01:22:00] they mean." I think that's what it comes down to. So it isn't, doesn't have any weight.
    And even if, for example, the commission. Eventually says to parliament, "look, we think that you should repeal the act, the Witchcraft Suppression Act, and we think that you should replace it with this bull." Then that would begin from scratch. The parliamentary portfolio committee would take the suggestion and begin to look at motivation for drafting a new bull.
    But I don't think that's ever gonna happen at the moment. Parliament is overwhelmed by the amount of work it has, and I don't think they're going to want to include another bull dealing with something like witchcraft onto their plate. But we'll have to see. The commission is determined to resolve their investigation this year, hopefully by next year at the latest. We'll see how it goes.
    Josh Hutchinson: Is the commission still accepting feedback? 
    Damon Leff: No, the date [01:23:00] for comment closed the end of October. Okay. I think they probably would accept feedback if they received it, but no, the official date for comment on that bill is closed. And depending on the number of submissions that they receive, if, for example, they feel that they need to have yet another public participation process, they may open an opportunity for comment again, but they seem to be determined to want to finish this investigation. It started in 2007. 
    Josh Hutchinson: Yeah, 15 years already and not finished. But it sounds like there would be another opportunity for you and others to offer comment if it were taken up by parliament. 
    Damon Leff: Once the commission recommends to parliament that the act be repealed ,the Parliamentary Investigation Committee of the Justice Department would have a look at that, have a look at the work that the commission has done, have a look at the motivation for why they want [01:24:00] the, or suggest that the act should be repealed. And if they agree with the commission's decision, then it's a simple process of making a recommendation to the president and the National Commission commit, that and the national House of Parliament to have the Act repealed. That should be a straightforward process.
    Sarah Jack: What is the future of witch hunts and advocacy?
    Damon Leff: Let's hope that it includes an end to legal prejudice against the subject of witchcraft entirely. Let's also hope that it ends accusations of witchcraft on a grassroots level. Is there a need perhaps for the states to acknowledge that there has been this historical human rights abuse as committed as a result of a belief in witchcraft as something evil? I don't know. And it's easy to talk about a monument for the victims [01:25:00] of accusations when the state was involved in the trials. I'm not sure that our parliament would see a reason for a national monument for the victims of witchcraft accusation. It could be something to consider down the line that those who have lost their lives as a result of accusations of witchcraft need somehow to be acknowledged, that the members of their family need to be acknowledged. Their pain, their suffering, their loss needs to be acknowledged, hopefully, possibly, by the members of the community that committed the atrocities. The need for restorative justice essentially. I don't think that's something that the South African Pagan Rights Alliance could lead. We could certainly encourage it, but that coming to terms with the atrocities of one's [01:26:00] past needs to happen between and by the people involved in those atrocities.
    Yeah, and I think the appropriate forum to manage those discussions, negotiations would be something like the Human Rights Commission or the CRL Commission. Yeah, as far as the Pagan Rights Alliance is concerned, once the act has been repealed, hopefully by then we'll have trained enough paralegals who would be able to assist local communities irrespective of who they are, where they are, who are still dealing with accusations of witchcraft.
    It might be very helpful to be able to get paralegals to form working partnerships with police in local communities where accusations are common, so that they can [01:27:00] intercede and assist police, ensure that social workers are there, that the victims are cared for in a humane way. Their might be a role for us there, but not something that, that we have any concrete on now, but it could be a role for us in the future.
    Josh Hutchinson: Here's Sarah Jack, president of End Witch Hunts, director of the Connecticut Witch Trial Exoneration Project, host of Thou Shalt Not Suffer: The Witch Trial Podcast, bringing you an important End Witch Hunts Advocacy News report. Listen to what she says. It's very important, and we need to heed her call to action.
    Sarah Jack: End Witch Hunt's World Advocacy Report. This episode offered a snapshot of the phase of witch-hunt behaviors that South Africa now navigates. The South African Pagan Rights [01:28:00] Alliance Advocacy Against Witch Hunts has worked to promote protections and breakdown barriers around modern witchcraft violence, prejudices, and allegations in South Africa.
    This organization advocates for legal protection against religious witchcraft discrimination. South Africa has seen a decline in witch attacks. South Africa moved in a positive direction towards inclusive religious tolerance for South Africans with diverse religious practices by activism and strategic efforts.
    Advocates like Damon Leff are taking effective action in educating the world to accept religious diversity. They're demanding civil accountability against witch allegation crimes and human rights protections from witchcraft discrimination. Without this purposeful work, witch-hunting and hurtful religious discrimination will continue to grow its interlocked deep roots into the foundations of our communities. These harmful roots of fear and hate can be cut out and ended, but we must do the work. 
    As Damon Leff has demonstrated, the prejudiced and assumptive message of the media and witchcraft [01:29:00] legislation can be challenged and changed. The South African Pagan Rights Alliance Advocacy Against Witch Hunts effectively informed and impacted the message of media writers and reporters around witchcraft ideology. The Alliance took effective action to support the repeal of the Witchcraft Suppression Act of 1957. They have facilitated responses across complex groups like officials of the government and religious organizations. 
    Likewise, Thou Shalt Not Suffer podcast amplifies the message that nations and communities across the world have continued to be shrouded in witch-hunt injustices. These communities have advocate networks offering solutions and education to their community leaders. They're asking the world for acknowledgement and witch-hunts are an extensive and widespread past and present violent social phenomenon. Witch-hunting has operated within official law and courts and outside the law. Thou Shalt Not Suffer Podcast peels back the onion layers of witch-hunt components to evaluate the connections and similarities between [01:30:00] past and present witch-hunting. Witchcraft hunts have reached every continent and continue unjust suffering into new generations.
    Each community is in a unique situation for the enabling of witch-hunts. But throughout time and humanity, the worldwide perception of witchcraft has been cloaked in fear, false allegations, and violence across all times. In South Africa, advocate and media conversations, as well as legal initiatives have begun to change the course of action around modern witch fear. 
    Scotland and the United States are an example of nations advocating for victims in a different witch-hunt phase. These advocates are building conversations across collaborative cooperatives, calling for legislated national pardons and state exonerations to clear names of the wrongfully accused and executed men and women in their community histories.
    From trials of the past to attacks in our modern time, witch-hunt chapters are wide open in our world witch-hunt story. Generations of individuals still take a casual interest in the cause and relevance of witch-hunts past and present. Witchphobia is generally [01:31:00] tolerated in most societies across the globe, and harm from witchcraft allegations is clear. People must learn and pay attention. You are intentional bystanders if you are not taking action.
    We are End Witch Hunts. End Witch Hunts is the nonprofit organization dedicated to eliminating harmful practices related to accusations of witchcraft and ritual attacks around the globe. The world must stop hunting witches. The world must stop hurting women and children out of fear. Please follow our End Witch Hunts movement on Twitter @_endwitchh unts and visit our website at endwitchhunts.org.
    End Witch Hunts Movement and Thou Shalt Not Suffer podcast support the worldwide movement to recognize and address historical wrongs.
    Josh Hutchinson: Thank you, Sarah, for that insightful and critical update on the real world, modern-day situation that many countries are faced with.
    Sarah Jack: You're welcome.
    Josh Hutchinson: [01:32:00] And thank you for listening to Thou Shalt Not Suffer: The Witch Trial podcast. 
    Sarah Jack: Join us next week.
    Josh Hutchinson: Subscribe wherever you get your podcast, and never miss a moment. 
    Sarah Jack: Visit us often at thoushaltnotsuffer.com. 
    Josh Hutchinson: Remember to tell your friends.
    Sarah Jack: It's really good.
    Josh Hutchinson: Exciting, tantalizing, scintillating. 
    Sarah Jack: Support our efforts to End Witch Hunts. Visit endwitchhunts.org to learn more about our nonprofit.
    Josh Hutchinson: Have a great today and a beautiful tomorrow. 
    [01:33:00]